4 ms·
Somewhat off-topic, but I just hate that Snopes article. It's wrong, and rather off-base. Functionally speaking, the main disconnect in the article is the diff
by jcranmer 8y ago
Somewhat off-topic, but I just hate that Snopes article. It's wrong, and rather off-base.
Functionally speaking, the main disconnect in the article is the difference between loading gauge and track gauge. 1435mm, or 8'4.5", may be the standard track gauge and uniform between most countries, but the actual standard loading gauges varies quite dramatically between different countries. The UK has a positively tiny loading gauge (about 2.5m), while the "standard" EU loading gauge is 3.1m, the US is slightly wider at 3.2m, and Sweden opts for a roomy 3.4m.
The original notion that the SRB has to be "slightly" larger than the 1435mm track gauge is ridiculous, since as you can see, the loading gauge is over twice the width the track itself. Of course, there's also rooms to play tricks here if you need to. Schnabel cars can laterally offset the loads they're carrying by up to a meter or so, which gives you some extra height to play with if you're dealing with a double-track tunnel with an arched roof.
The other point to mention that's completely omitted is there is a rather big difference between rail carriages and horse-drawn carriages. On rail carriages, the cars sit above the wheels, while horse-drawn carriages sit between the wheels. Something like this:
bbbbbb bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbnbb
b b b b
w b b w w b b w
w bbbbbb w w b b w
waaaaaaaaw waaaaaaaaaw
w w w w
w w w w
(Note that this is one of the reasons that the standard gauge was chosen over a broader gauge).
As for why standard gauge was chosen, well, keep in mind that a) there was a lot of variance of track gauge in the 1800s, and b) the actual tolerance of track gauge was pretty damn massive. A track gauge differing by as much as two inches or so wouldn't have impeded the ability to transfer rolling stock. Stephenson built the first practical steam locomotive on a line that was 4'8", and so people who wanted to reuse his locomotives would have been drawn to a gauge around 4'8"-4'9". Gauges around 5" and slightly larger were selected in part to prevent interconnect between different railroads (basically, the same concept as vendor lockin).
Contrary to the Snopes article, the South mostly standardized on 5' gauge, but it didn't have as dense a network as the North did. The South eventually converted to 4'9" gauge (the Pennsylvania Railroad's gauge)--in 1886, 20 years after the Civil War. Conversion thence to 4'8.5" took much longer, but was much less dramatic because 4'9" and 4'8.5" are within gauge tolerance.