4 ms·
Money is a bad medium for measuring purpose, it’s just the best way we have that is interoperable in a useful way. It is important not to attach too much meani
by prepend 8y ago
Money is a bad medium for measuring purpose, it’s just the best way we have that is interoperable in a useful way.
It is important not to attach too much meaning because of it, because, like you said, is the crap peddler more meaningful than the doctor? This certainly can’t be determined based on income.
However, there’s no real other way that’s useful. Money at least forces prioritization and has supply and demand effects.
A classic example is teachers being underpaid. Teachers should be paid more, but the reason they aren’t is because communities prioritize them lower than other costs. This isn’t a direct measure of value, but it certainly an indicator when teachers are paid less than administrators [0].
Unfortunately, there’s no meaningful way to assess meaning that is easily measureable and comparable universally. It’s not really possible to measure the impact of the doctor’s cure over time and compare that to a different doctor. Or a speech therapist. Or whatever.
[0] highly variable of course, but here’s some California Data https://www.cde.ca.gov/fg/fr/sa/cefavgsalaries.asp https://www.cde.ca.gov/fg/fr/sa/cefavgsalaries.asp
- repolfx 8y agoWell, cigarette companies can't even be said to be "crap peddlers" really. Lots of people enjoy smoking, that's almost the problem - they enjoy it too much and can't stop. I think you could argue that addictive substances shouldn't be considered a normal part of capitalism, they're too far from the norms, but that quickly takes you down a complex path (is a water supply "addictive"? you sure do need one!). I fully agree that money is the best mechanism we have to decide if work done by someone is valuable or not. Teacher's wages are suppressed by the fact that it's not very hard and there are lots of people who want to do it. Whereas administration is (perceived as being) harder and not every teacher is willing to move into management.