3 ms·
Well, in that case was the Mechanical Turk a machine that played chess? I mean, it was a machine and it did play chess. There was a person inside it that actual
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
Well, in that case was the Mechanical Turk a machine that played chess? I mean, it was a machine and it did play chess. There was a person inside it that actually did all the work, but does that make it not a machine that played chess? We could debate the meaning of "plays" until the cows come home and perhaps arguing that the machine should be able to play chess on its own, or that it doesn't because one component of it is a human being that also functions independently to the machine is pedantic. But perhaps it is productive after all, to challenge and analyse claims regarding the nature of things people make.
If I understand this memristor paper correctly, the whole issue seems to be that what is supposed to be a new kind of Thing, that didn't exist before, is actually made up of already existing Things with well-understood properties in one possible configuration that doesn't do anything radically new, that other configurations can't already do anyway.
So in other ways- we have the useful properties but a) we always had them and b) there's no new Thing.
- VikingCoder 8y agoWe did not always have what HP created. It's not a trick, it just doesn't work on the underlying mechanism we thought it did. The new configuration is itself radically new. The Mechanical Turk was a trick, designed to deceive. It's a very unfair comparison.