3 ms·
>Today, most cloud providers offer Redis as a managed service over their infrastructure and enjoy huge income from software that was not developed by them. Redi
by andrepd 8y ago
>Today, most cloud providers offer Redis as a managed service over their infrastructure and enjoy huge income from software that was not developed by them. Redis’ permissive BSD open source license allows them to do so legally, but this must be changed.
Then it seems the solution is simple: use GPL rather than BSD. In other words, say "Do you want to use this free software for your benefit? Fine, but in turn give back your improvements to the community for our benefit.". Without this safeguard, progress and shared good is not achieved.
- johncolanduoni 8y agoDo the cloud providers make significant in-house modifications to Redis?
- andrepd 8y agoBig or small, they would have to duly disclose and release what they built from that tool.
- mikekchar 8y agoNo they don't. Under Apache 2.0 they only have to provide source code changes if they distribute the software. If they are providing it as a service with modifications, they are allowed to do that without redistribution. However, I don't think anyone has suggested that they are doing that -- only that they are offering a service for money that uses Redis (and the affected modules).
- noncoml 8y agoYou are thinking AGPL maybe?
- abrookewood 8y agoI don't see how the GPL helps. AWS etc make money by providing Redis as a service, which the GPL allows. If most of the work they have done is to support Redis, rather than changing code in Redis, nothing changes.
- ubernostrum 8y agoAGPL would do it, since it's specifically designed for the "cloud loophole" (or whatever the FSF chooses to call it).
- mikekchar 8y agoNo, it just requires the service provider to also provide source code. The issue here is that RedisLabs wants to ensure that no service providers can use their modules and receive money. The AGPL specifically allows people to run the software for any purpose and also specifically disallows tacking on other clauses. (As does the GPL -- the only difference with the AGPL is that providing it over a network is considered "distribution" for the purposes of license compliance).
- ubernostrum 8y agoIn practical terms, AGPL would do it because far fewer people are willing to touch AGPL'd code. And the start of this specific comment chain wasn't about "make money", it was about ensuring cloud providers "give back" their improvements.
- johncolanduoni 8y agoIn the case of Redis and the handful of cloud providers, I’m pretty sure they wouldn’t leave millions on the table just because they’re anxious about having to run it by legal.