3 ms·
This is almost literally a Godwin argument. Your argument basically unpacks into, "there's a dangerously slippery slope between fake door tests and war crimes",
by philwelch 8y ago
This is almost literally a Godwin argument. Your argument basically unpacks into, "there's a dangerously slippery slope between fake door tests and war crimes", and it's most often used as a self-serving justification by bureaucrats who want you to do hours of busy work before giving people a questionnaire: http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/08/29/my-irb-nightmare/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/08/29/my-irb-nightmare/
Look, marketing researchers are not going to just accidentally vivisect concentration camp inmates to death just because you leave them unregulated. It's not like people just accidentally go around committing crimes against humanity because there aren't any regulations stopping them from doing so. In fact, at Nuremberg, it turned out that most of them committed crimes against humanity specifically because there were regulations requiring them to do so!
This isn't to completely pooh-pooh the necessity of research ethics and regulation. But those regulations need to be based on realistic risk models.
- lalos 8y agoIt is not my fault that the rules that govern research and interaction between researchers and tests subjects occurred because of WW2 and that Godwin's law exists. I mentioned that as a historic fact. So nobody can talk about how this started because it is literally Godwin's law? Great idea.
- philwelch 8y agoI'm not saying it's your fault; I'm saying that AB testing pizza advertisements for a fictitious pizza brand on YouTube is so far away from the risk of committing war crimes that it's a big stretch to invoke the Nuremberg Code as a criticism of it.
- lalos 8y agoThe code is more about a simple set of rules for research involving human test subjects. That is the baseline. It started because of that and got adopted by the scientific community as the most basic rules. I'm not implying anything about war crimes because I would've still referenced if they were created randomly by any other random event.