4 ms·
I wonder how many people read the article to the end, let alone the addendum filed by SCCFD [1]. This has nothing to do with the definition of "unlimited" or t
by thaumaturgy 8y ago
I wonder how many people read the article to the end, let alone the addendum filed by SCCFD [1].
This has nothing to do with the definition of "unlimited" or the fine print for it. OES 5262 (that's a CalOES resource) had sufficient bandwidth for fire response needs up until the Mendocino Complex incident, when their connection was strangled so badly that it wasn't just slow, it was unusable, during a major state disaster. This put a lot of lives directly at risk.
Their brief is arguing in support of the lawsuit against the FCC that's attempting to overturn the repeal of net neutrality. They argue that in a deregulated environment, providers like Verizon can and will use disasters to strong-arm responding agencies -- state and local governments -- into paying higher fees. This is well supported by Verizon's emails, which flatly refused to assist SCCFD until they ponied up the extra money for a plan upgrade that they didn't need until the Mendocino fire.
The article also adds that the FCC's removal of net neutrality removed the ability for SCCFD to complain to the FCC about this behavior.
A few people are saying that maybe the fire department should have more carefully reviewed their plan information, or they should have had more qualified people in IT. Well, maybe. I looked up Eric Prosser's LinkedIn profile, and he's spent his whole career in management. Maybe there was a technical issue, or maybe it was just an oversight.
But ultimately it's hard for agencies to attract strong technical talent, especially in Silicon Valley, where so much of that talent is working on the much more interesting problems of squeezing more money out of advertising or debt collections. If you want your first responder agencies to have working technology, get involved. Somewhere in each of those agencies is a human being who may not think about things like bandwidth throttling as carefully as HN's nerds.
[1]: https://arstechnica.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/fire-department-net-neutrality.pdf https://arstechnica.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/fire-depa...