4 ms·
An interesting article, but the whole thing had a whiff of "paying income tax is unconstitutional", complete with the protagonist coming off as just a tad unhin
by mikestew 8y ago
An interesting article, but the whole thing had a whiff of "paying income tax is unconstitutional", complete with the protagonist coming off as just a tad unhinged. IANAL, and even as an amateur one I wouldn't begin to claim to argue the merits of the law. But none of the folks mentioned in the article garner any sympathy from me. Banks weren't screwing anyone, AFAICT. Folks just couldn't make the payment, and found a loophole. Hell, one person had mortgages on eleven houses in San Diego. Hmm, could it be that they were just a bit over-extended, and not victims of the evil banking system?
Now, I'm not hatin' on anyone mentioned in the article. Overall, I'm about as neutral as I would be watching two people I have no interest in have a fist fight, because I have no great love for banks, either. And if they succeed, good for them. But the state of ID, as pointed out by another commentor, seems to put this in the "don't pay income tax" bucket as well.
- thanatropism 8y agoI think you're getting downvoted for typin' "hatin' on" rather than something that's grammatically appropriate for written discussion and more specific, such as "Not that I condemn...".
- mikestew 8y agoI appreciate your feedback. Though if I were to guess, it's more the "I have no sympathy..." than my street grammar. :-) I've got 10K points of imaginary Internet cred, I don't worry about a downvote or two except as a sanity check for the rare times I get out of line.
- Afforess 8y agoPaying income tax _was_ unconstitutional. The 16th amendment had to be passed to make it constitutional. Only Federal Income taxes after 1913 were constitutional: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sixteenth_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sixteenth_Amendment_to_the_Uni...
- mikestew 8y agoGrammatical tense is important, as I was referring those that argue the same even today.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Paying income tax _was_ unconstitutional. It was never generally held to be, and the US had (though not permanently) income taxes prior to the 16th Amendment. > The 16th amendment had to be passed to make it constitutional. No, it had to be passed to make income tax on revenues from certain forms of interest, dividends, and rents to be Constitutional under the (quite controversial) holding in Pollock v. Farmers Loan Trust Co. Income taxes moe generally were held by the Supreme Court to be excises rather than direct taxes and therefore Constitutional even prior to the 16th. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pollock_v._Farmers%27_Loan_%26_Trust_Co https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pollock_v._Farmers%27_Loan_%....
- preinheimer 8y agoSo the people in the story had an obligation: to keep paying their mortgage on time. The banks also had an obligation: to follow all local and state rules regarding liens on property. Should the mortgage be sold the local county clerk would need to be informed, forms would need to be filled out, possibly a fee need to be paid. But they didn't. Instead they used MERS to make transferring mortgages webscale. Who owns a debt seems like something that should be quickly and easily determined. This helps avoid problems like "I've been paying bank A for years, bank B just showed up and said I should have been paying since last year!" (and if you're reading student loan horror stories, that's a common refrain). For mortgages (a secured debt) it seems like the county clerk office should hold the canonical answer. But that stopped being true. Maybe the homeowners here shouldn't get off scott free, but maybe the banks shouldn't either.