5 ms·
You can think a 5-person team can build highly performant native apps for a number of different platforms in a matter of months?
by fastball 8y ago
You can think a 5-person team can build highly performant native apps for a number of different platforms in a matter of months?
- StaticRedux 8y agoYes
- fastball 8y agoGreat! Now can you name an app where that actually happened?
- conradfr 8y agoDo they have to do a DSM everyday and retrospective, backlog grooming, sprint planning and whatnot every two weeks? Then no.
- joelhaasnoot 8y agoStart with Mac, find some good metrics that indicate that a lot of your users are on Mac and go from there. (parse your user agents for instance) Once it's proven itself, you can try Windows and some other options as needed (probably mobile).
- russdpale 8y agoYou don't even need good metrics. Just write some software that doesn't run like shit. That is the only metric that is needed. If you build it, they will come. Especially if they don't have a choice. So build the new, deprecate the old.
- paulie_a 8y agoWhy would someone start with a minor platform? Mac is consistently 5-6 percentage of the market and has been for decades. They honestly have never been a player.
- flukus 8y agoBecause mac users have been the most concerned about native look and feel for decades, most windows users probably couldn't tell you what the native look and feel is because even MS don't don't don't follow one.
- paulie_a 8y agoBut they a still an incredibly irrelevant platform when it comes to userbase, if anything make windows top tier and Mac users can have the half assed version. Slack is typically a business application. You will use it if it's required and Mac users just are not that big in a corporate environment.
- toast0 8y agoYou're absolutely right, but consider that most of the people complaining who indicate their computer type are mentioning using Apple computers (perhaps electron works better on Windows? Perhaps people don't name drop Windows as much? Perhaps Windows users have lower expectations?). Also, consider that the supported hardware base for a Mac app is much smaller than a Windows app, which means fewer devices to test on, etc, and probably fewer operating system versions to support too. It should be (but may not be) a lower effort project than supporting Windows, and it will be easier to kill if it doesn't go well ('whoops that was a bad idea, but only 2% of our users used it' -- nevermind if that's 80% of their user base that could run it)
- deusex_ 8y agoEver heard of selection bias?
- fastball 8y ago??? We're talking about a chat application for diverse corporate teams. If you don't have native apps for Windows/MacOS/Android/iOS at the get-go then you've missed the boat.
- chrisco255 8y agoYeah, pretty amusing to hear all these arm-chair quarterbacks on how easy it is to build a rich, real-time chat app like Slack but with native tech. Not only do you have to have all the basic functionality, like emoji reactions, link preview cards, inline images, video, message actions, mention preview, threads, channels, avatars with presence, file attachment upload, etc but you also have to consider that Slack is a moving target. They can't stop shipping new features. They have Microsoft Teams to compete with, which is also an electron app by the way. Sorry about everyone complaining about CPU, but Slack won the chat wars in part because they were early adopters of Electron, and got plenty of developer productivity benefits out of using the web stack to build on.
- axaxs 8y agoAbsolutely. Even faster if using some cross platform nicety like Qt.