6 ms·
The ongoing "Russia is up to something" narrative is an unpleasant death by a thousand cuts. China is doing 'interesting' expansionary work encroaching on terr
by roenxi 8y ago
The ongoing "Russia is up to something" narrative is an unpleasant death by a thousand cuts.
China is doing 'interesting' expansionary work encroaching on territory in the South China Sea. America has no doubt spawned a generation of enemies in the Middle East from the last 15 odd years of warmongering.
The Russians have no demonstrated ability to do anything dangerous politically, or any particular motive not shared by the ~20% of the world population living in China. To even influence the conversations in American politics they will have to wait in line behind a maelstrom of corporate interests that have the political scene quite neatly locked down.
It is heartbreaking to see the usually vibrant US political scene get so lost in the bushes on foreign policy and threat assessment.
- gameswithgo 8y ago>The Russians have no demonstrated ability to do anything dangerous politically, Huh, I dunno I've been watching first hand how russians on social media have been stirring up conservative vs liberal shit storms. The election was a close one so any one of a thousand small influences might have shifted it into it's current disastrous state. When people are at a tipping point it doesn't take much.
- bryanlarsen 8y ago"one of a thousand small influences" That's the point. The election was so close there were likely at least a thousand different things that, had they gone slightly differently, would have shifted the election to Hillary. Russian interference accounted for a small number of these, but there were so many more that aren't getting any attention.
- gameswithgo 8y agoThere are quite a few that have been getting attention. Facebook/twitter/social media has been a hot topic. How the media conducts itself and how much it is trusted has been big. Gerrymandering has been a hot topic. What else do you feel should be getting attention that is not?
- bryanlarsen 8y agoI'd add the Comey interference, but that too has been well covered. There's a lot more, but most if it was fair game / water under the bridge. Interesting in a historical context or to internal party strategists, but doesn't deserve attention in the public context of upcoming elections. So you're right. It does sometimes seem that commentary about Russia dominates, but it probably isn't strangling focus on other important issues.
- jessaustin 8y agoHow about the fact that TV news was all-Trump-all-the-time from about July 2015 on through the election? Trump voters are old and unsophisticated (on average; of course there are exceptions); they take their instructions from TV not online sources. No one could have afforded the marketing that "TV journalists" gave Trump for free. They broadcast an empty lectern whenever he took longer than expected in the restroom. Meanwhile all other Republicans, all third party candidates, and Sanders got no coverage. (You might remember a lot of the Sanders campaign, but that was grassroots crowd-driven stuff, not the networks deciding to cover Sanders.) Some reckon it was a sort of pied-piper strategy to ensure Hillary got her weakest possible opponent. I can't believe that even Democrats are that dumb: Trump was uniquely qualified to run against her. Why would she have been afraid to face Jeb or Ted? Did she really think that all that TV coverage was somehow unrelated to the election? The conspiracy theories ignore the main reason that TV news covers Trump all the time: he improves ratings and profits. Millions of morons invited him into their homes when he had that awful reality show, and now they can't get enough of him. He has carefully cultivated the same persona as president and that's just fascinating to people. Those fascinated people are watching a lot of TV news even now. The only candidate who could counter this strength would be someone with her own reality show. One might wonder, given that the TV news organizations continue to make bank with Trump ad nauseum, why we'd expect the results to be any different the next time Trump runs...
- pathseeker 8y ago>Trump voters are old and unsophisticated (on average; of course there are exceptions); they take their instructions from TV not online sources. White people voted for Trump in a majority in both the educated and uneducated categories. People making more than 50k voted more for Trump and people making less voted for Hillary. Trump pulled in more independents than Hillary. Don't repeat the trope that Trumps supporters are 'old and unsophisticated'. It does a disservice to any actual debate and results in completely incorrect analyses of why he won (e.g. your assessment that only tv-watching morons voted for him). https://verdict.justia.com/2018/02/16/trumps-base-broadly-speaking https://verdict.justia.com/2018/02/16/trumps-base-broadly-sp...
- prolikewh0a 8y ago>Huh, I dunno I've been watching first hand how russians on social media have been stirring up conservative vs liberal shit storms. I don't know how you jump from organic "shit storms" with a declining economic and social future for a lot of people, to a blanket Russia is doing this. It's exactly what should be happening as we have a racist shit-for-brains in the White House. People are pushing further right and further left and the political atmosphere is exactly what you would expect. Things shouldn't be calm.
- mrguyorama 8y agoMany "organic" shitstorms are purposely seeded by russian backed groups, with the express intention of creating anger and, well, more shitstorms
- prolikewh0a 8y agoGood! People should be angry! The system is not working for the majority of people. People should be pissed. Do you have any evidence that all 'shitstorms' are created by Russia? I bet you can't provide evidence that even 0.01% of 'shitstorms' are created by Russia. Apply some Occam's Razor here.
- InTheArena 8y agoRussia can’t do anything, Unless you are Ukraine(invaded), Georgia or Europe (remember that fuel crisis and pipelines) that is. Or the United States in our case. Or Syria (Russia is assad’s Primary backer).. So yeah, remember when Democrats ridiculed Romney for his Russia statements and Obama and HRC declared it was time for a “reset button” for the bad relationship betweeen the Bush white goose and Russia? Or how about their efforts to back certain black lives matter groups and pro police group on the other hand to stroke racial tension does that not matter? Or their current effort to discredit Republican Who have split from Trump. We still live in that world, And the consequences for people both in the United States and outside of the United States are immense. At some point this stops looking like normal relationships and start looking like an act of war
- roenxi 8y ago> Russia can’t do anything, Unless you are Ukraine(invaded), Georgia or Europe (remember that fuel crisis and pipelines) that is. Yes, Russia would be a concern to me if I lived in Europe. > Or the United States in our case. That is neither an argument nor a fact, so I can't really address it. > Or Syria (Russia is assad’s Primary backer).. Isn't Russia supporting the legitimate government in Syria? Obviously that isn't supporting US interests, but it is hardly a radical position. > So yeah, remember when Democrats ridiculed Romney for his Russia statements and Obama and HRC declared it was time for a “reset button” for the bad relationship betweeen the Bush white goose and Russia? No, don't follow US politics that closely. It would be nice to see the US reset its bad relationship with Russia if I'm reading that right. The world is better if we all try to get along civilly. > Or how about their efforts to back certain black lives matter groups and pro police group on the other hand to stroke racial tension does that not matter? Pardon? I don't understand. > Or their current effort to discredit Republican Who have split from Trump. Approximately half the political apparatus is constantly trying to discredit the other half, and the other half is usually infighting quietly and jocking for positions. Russian trolls aren't going to be able to get in before the Democrats have started savaging them. > We still live in that world, And the consequences for people both in the United States and outside of the United States are immense. Yes. > At some point this stops looking like normal relationships and start looking like an act of war No they don't. Acts of war involve material harm at some level. I know Trump isn't that popular, but he has ballpark similar ratings (~1 person in 20 difference) to Ronald Reagan, Bill Clinton or even Obama at this point is the presidency [1]. If the Russians are somehow having an impact, it isn't upsetting anyone unduly, let alone an act of war. [1] https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/trump-approval-ratings/ https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/trump-approval-ratings/
- matt4077 8y agoRussia, and Putin specifically, are suffering from a serious case of inferiority complex ever since the USSR broke apart. They could obviously prosper easily by integrating themselves into Europe & the west economically. Instead, they are willing to hurt themselves significantly if it allows them to inflict any harm on their "opponents". China is powerful, but has actually been rather docile, historically. They have none of the expansionist instincts that still come natural to Russia–the only exception being a few tiny islands. The US, Great Britain: every superpower in history was more aggressive than China today. Russia has unfortunately proven that they are very much capable of inflicting some serious harm. They are partly responsible for millions of deaths in Syria, they are undermining 70 years of rather successful attempts to make the forcible taking of territory a thing of the past at least among some nations. They are undermining the singularly successful effort to abolish chemical weapons (both with their support in Syria and their executions in GB). There's some real fear that they could test NATO, and that he-who-shall-not-be-mentioned might be willing (eager?) to let NATO fall apart. That would be an existential threat for every independent country east of Germany, and it doesn't entirely not be plausible as an inflection point that future history books cite as the cause for the next big war.
- erw1 8y agoWe made a genuine attempt to integrate with the West. We were rebuffed. That seems, just like you say, pretty obvious to me. Sure, it was all good and dandy for a while, especially in the context of economic cooperation and dismantling communism. But when you look at deeper issues like national security, you can't deny that Russia got completely tuned out by the West. I still don't understand what the US was thinking when they tried to expand NATO into Georgia and Ukraine, two critical security frontiers for Moscow (even as they said they wouldn't do it [1]). And in case you missed it, we voiced our opposition to NATO expansion loudly, bitterly, and repeatedly over the last two decades. You just chose to ignore it. And now the West collectively acts like the resulting conflict is some kind of unexpected flare-up of Russian paranoia/empire syndrome/general wickedness. John Mearsheimer put it best [2], so I don't want to keep beating a dead horse. In the end, if you are trying to build a more integrated and safer world, you have to take the interests and sensibilities of all major stakeholders into into account. That's how you build mutual trust. If you don't thread carefully you risk signaling disingenuousness and opportunism. So you get what you get. PS As a side note, I do find the cartoonization of this conflict very bizarre. Russian are the orcs, completely alien and wicked, Putin is the omnipotent Sauron, US is the noble and selfless Aragon, Trump is turncoat Saruman, and Europe and the wider world in general are apparently hobbits, plucky but completely clueless on their own. It's like an echo chamber. [1] https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/briefing-book/russia-programs/2017-12-12/nato-expansion-what-gorbachev-heard-western-leaders-early https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/briefing-book/russia-programs/2017... [2] https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/russia-fsu/2014-08-18/why-ukraine-crisis-west-s-fault https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/russia-fsu/2014-08-1...
- 13years 8y agoPrior to this Russian threat narrative, it was always China who was in the news doing the hacking. Our government banned some Chinese built computers for use in government due to fears of builtin hardware spy devices. There is a long history of Chinese capturing and infiltrating top secret information. The state of the world didn't change. The Chinese didn't stop and Russia didn't just start. These types of things have been going on by multiple actors for a long time. Only the narrative changed due to opportunistic political advantages.
- mistermann 8y agoThis is more or less my thinking on the matter as well. I'm also very skeptical (uninformed?) of the evidence that ties Russia to all of this. In this case: "Microsoft said its digital crimes unit (DCU) had acted on a court order to take control of six internet domains created by a group known variously as Strontium, Fancy Bear and APT28, which it said was associated with the Russian government. As well as the two think-tanks, other home pages had been set up to mimic the websites of the U.S. Senate and Microsoft’s own Office software suite, it added. " So, these sophisticated Hackers registered web pages under their own organization names? Is that not a bit like robbing a bank and leaving your business card behind? And in the case of the former Russian hackers in the news, I may be wrong but is it not ip addresses that were used as evidence? If so, I've always been under the impression that ip addresses can be spoofed, and so the rumor goes the CIA (at least) possesses a wide variety of cloaking techniques. https://www.eff.org/files/2016/09/22/2016.09.20_final_formatted_ip_address_white_paper.pdf https://www.eff.org/files/2016/09/22/2016.09.20_final_format... https://wikileaks.org/ciav7p1/ https://wikileaks.org/ciav7p1/ To be clear, I'm not claiming this proves (or disproves) anything one way or the other, what I am saying is that the "evidence", at least what I've seen, leaves me feeling rather skeptical. In it worries me that there aren't very many people in the skeptical centre here with me, most everyone seems to be out on the polar opposite ends of the spectrum on whether Russia did this or not. EDIT: Downvoter(s) - feel free, but if you are downvoting based on disagreement, would you mind posting a link to an article that explains the method(s) by which we can conclude definitively that all of the alleged Russian attacks were indeed committed by Russia, rather than a 3rd party posing as Russia? If my skepticism is "simply wrong", then it should be easy to simply demonstrate that. It's a pretty sad state of affairs if people can't address sincere, worthy questions, but "know" they are wrong.
- malvosenior 8y agoThank you. As someone who lived through the end of the cold war, I have no desire to go back to that (legitimately fearing for worldwide nuclear holocaust) and I don't understand why in 2018 some people are so enthusiastic about pitting Russia against the United States again. We made major strides in our relationship with them and now it seems like those have been erased in the name of local politics. Doesn't seem like a wise decision.
- rbanffy 8y ago> We made major strides in our relationship with them Unfortunately, they decided to commit murders on foreign soil, invade other countries and other nasty things that made this relationship a lot less attractive than it could have been. Had Russia become a democracy, it'd be different, but an autocrat with profound disregard for foreign democratic institutions would never be a good friend.
- malvosenior 8y agoEvery major political power (including/especially the US) does this and it's never cut and dry good vs. evil. Russia's actions are the same and as someone living in the US there's nothing they are doing that justifies putting the entire planet at risk by reigniting our tensions with them. The cold war was an entirely different thing. It wasn't a local skirmish, it was doomsday hanging over the world every day for 40 years.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y ago> Unfortunately, they decided to commit murders on foreign soil, invade other countries and other nasty things... Is this not exactly what the US (and its allies, including my country) are doing in the middle east?
- rbanffy 8y agoAnd it's be perfectly understandable that many of the countries where such acts happen are not exactly friends of the US.
- sudoaza 8y agoNot only in middle east, USA has setup dictatorships all over latin america and gained several enemies here too
- simonh 8y agoIt is true that Russian electoral interference is probably only having a marginal and low impact effect on actual election outcomes. That's not the primary objective though. The goal is to incite and inflame partisan distrust and anger in order to foment political paralysis, hence the Russian support for extreme fringes of both factions. This strategy has been incredibly successful. Every time Trump mentions Russian interference it's to blame it all on fake news from the media and Democrats. Every time the media or Democrats talk about it, they frame it in terms of Trump providing cover for the Russians. Both sides expend all their ammunition on each other.
- kodablah 8y ago> The goal is to incite and inflame partisan distrust and anger in order to foment political paralysis This is arguably the similar goal of hyperbolic reporting about the effects of Russian influence and the frequency of these stories in the news cycle
- simonh 8y agoYes, that's definitely part of it. But what are the media supposed to do? Russian interference has been so spectacularly effective at dividing America, how can they not report on it? Yet reporting on it fuels the fire. Putin must be wetting himself laughing.