4 ms·
Wrong. Here is why. Let's say you're poor, and spending 90% of your income on day to day needs. Versus if you're rich, and spending 20% of your income on day
by dnautics 16y ago
Wrong. Here is why.
Let's say you're poor, and spending 90% of your income on day to day needs. Versus if you're rich, and spending 20% of your income on day to day needs.
a 10% inflation (absent corresponding wage inflation - which lags, but I'll omit it to keep things simple, the numbers have been rounded to make the math easy anyways) takes the poor person to 99% day to day and the rich person to 22% day to day.
That represents a 90% decrease in ability to save or pay off debt. Versus the rich person who has lost 2.5% ability to save or pay off debt.
Now. With a 10% inflation, your real debt burden has gone down 10%. Would you trade a 10% loss of debt burden for a 90% loss of ability to pay off the debt? I would not.
Who is it that has promulgated this myth that inflation is good for poor people? I keep hearing it everywhere, and it appalls me that no one has really stopped to think about it.
- gnaritas 16y ago> absent corresponding wage inflation - which lags, but I'll omit it to keep things simple It doesn't just keep things simple, it changes things. You can't leave out wage inflation. Of course inflation is bad if your wages don't keep up, but what if they do? That's the actual question. Inflation also lags, printing money doesn't instantly create inflation, it takes time for the market to adjust to the new circulation.
- dnautics 16y agoOmitting it only changes the 'relative magnitude'. So, what let's say wage inflation is 5%. So then there's effectively a 5% inflation. The poor person goes from 90% to 94.5%, rich person 20% to 21%. Are you seriously going to argue that you'll take 10% inflation with a 5% wage inflation over a general 45% decrease in ability to pay debts off? i don't know anyone who claims that wages don't lag behind inflation. Even Krugman argues that that's the whole point of inflation - to make it easier for employers to stealthily get around that pesky problem of sticky wages, make the relative cost of labor cheaper and keep the rubes employed. http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/08/02/why-is-deflation-bad/ http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/08/02/why-is-deflation... Also please consider that I'm not taking into account the mechanism of inflation, just inflation as a policy. I don't care if it's done by printing money or by relaxing reserve requirements, or by smelting impurities into the gold.
- sethg 16y agoReturning to my earlier example: suppose I spend 30% of my income on a mortgage with fixed payments, and 70% on Stuff. If I have wage inflation of 7%, and the price of Stuff goes up by 10%, then I have to spend a higher proportion of my income on Stuff, but I am spending a lower proportion of my income on my mortgage, so it precisely balances.
- dnautics 16y agoNo doubt, you are okay in that scenario. But people spending more than 70% on Stuff (i.e. people marginally poorer than you) are still screwed, and furthermore, the poorer they are relative to you the more screwed they will be.
- gnaritas 16y agoYea, but the question is what's better, continual slight inflation, or swinging back and forth between inflation and deflation? See, you're arguing that inflation is bad without saying what would be better; I'm saying continual slight inflation is the best option we have, so how is it bad?
- dnautics 16y agocontinual slight deflation is the best option. Deflation is the natural order of things, technological development is supposed to make things LESS expensive. Anything more inflationary than natural deflation (of course society will go through occasional inflationary bouts) is effectively stealing the fruits of societal progress from the poor, and reappropriating it to the rich or politically connected. Consider this: With continual slight inflation, in order to keep up, society is pressured to keep expanding exponentially. Well, I'm sorry to tell you son, but we live on a finite planet, and exponential expansion at some point is going to hit a limit.
- gnaritas 16y agoPlease don't call me son, I'm not your kid nor am I a kid. > With continual slight inflation, in order to keep up, society is pressured to keep expanding exponentially. True, but this assumes no corrections, like the one we're currently in. Ideally there'd be no inflation or deflation, but that's just not practical as wealth is not fixed nor can the money supply be. So the balancing act either tries to stay centered or slightly to one side or the other. > continual slight deflation is the best option. Deflation increases the value of my debt load putting me in deeper and deeper and reduces the value of my assets; how is that good? Deflation increases the value of saved cash. If anything, that sounds way worse for the poor than slight inflation. If I'm rich I just keep all my wealth in cash and steal from the poor via deflation. Under continual inflation, I can't do that, I have to convert my wealth into hopefully appreciating assets-and I could easily bet wrong-and the poor have continually decreasing debt as long salaries keep up with inflation. Sounds like a better deal to me. > Deflation is the natural order of things, That's not an argument, being natural doesn't equal being good. > Anything more inflationary than natural deflation (of course society will go through occasional inflationary bouts) is effectively stealing the fruits of societal progress from the poor, and reappropriating it to the rich or politically connected. You assert that, but I don't see any proof or evidence of it. You've shown me why you think inflation is bad, but now why you think deflation is good; you just assert it is.
- sethg 16y agoBy assuming away wage inflation, you’re really stacking the deck in favor of your argument. You are also treating “ability to save or pay off debt” as a generic thing, rather than considering fixed-payment debts (e.g., fixed-rate mortgages), variable-rate debts (e.g., credit cards), fixed-rate investments (e.g. bonds), and stocks as separate things. If, for example, I spend 30% of my income on a fixed-rate mortgage, and both wages and prices go up by 10% across the board, then I would end up spending only 27% of my inflated income on the mortgage, and the nominal value of my house would go up by 10%.
- dnautics 16y agoHaha. Well, during my six years as a graduate student, the CPI went up 8% per annum, and my salary went from 24k to 27k. Show me some data that there isn't a lag between wages and prices. As far as I know, typically the way that people get their wages to keep up with inflation is by shifting jobs horizontally or vertically. All evidence shows that that's not working so well. In the 50s a family could survive on one salary working a 40-50 hour work week. We're increasingly seeing families requiring two breadearners pulling 50-80 hour weeks. I think my argument is sound. All I'm saying is that the blanket statement that inflation is beneficial to poor people is flat out wrong. Consider also that poor people aren't getting fixed rate mortgages (more like variable rate ones - which are worse) and aren't investing in stocks or bonds which at least have a chance of beating inflation (if you play it right and get out before crashes). If you want to critique my argument, plug in real numbers and show me I'm wrong in our current situation. I believe that the numbers will hold up in my favor.
- kenjackson 16y agoDude, you were a GRAD STUDENT. The fact that your wages went up at all is a miracle. Everyone knows that grad students are basically free labor.
- dnautics 16y agoSo, you don't think capitalists (in the sense of business owners, industrialists; not the philosophical position) have the same attitude towards fungible, unskilled labor? At what point will internet startup VCs start to take that attitude towards commodity coders? Aren't we already seeing coding jobs escape to hyderabad?