4 ms·
I'm not sure why the good doctor isn't worried about inflationary spirals. He talks about deflationary spirals, but here's the situation I see: Economy goes i
by dnautics 16y ago
I'm not sure why the good doctor isn't worried about inflationary spirals. He talks about deflationary spirals, but here's the situation I see:
Economy goes into a depression, so there's stimulus, to give jobs to either government positions or favored private entities. The requisite money printing causes inflation. Inflation causes the cost of living and operating businesses to go up, which either sends jobs overseas (prompting government to inflate more to create a better trade balance) or corporations (esp. small businesses which are more sensitive to price indices and less likely to get stimulus) to close shop. If jobs are lost, government must inflate more to pay for new jobs or create more stimulus.
Rinse, wash, repeat.
All things being equal, I'd rather have a deflationary spiral, which can have a levelling effect - as inflation erodes saving power - hitting the poor far far harder than the rich.
- lzw 16y agoGovernment spending is not stimulative, because the inflation (or taxation if it is paid for that way) is detrimental to economic growth, as you have pointed out. The fear of deflation, however, is misguided and I think founded on a deception. I'm not sure the deception is intentional or not.... but politicians certainly benefit from it because it allows them to get away with more inflation. Deflation can happen in two ways. The first way is that there simply are no customers out there and so businesses start lowering prices desperately to cut inventory because of inventory carrying cost. In this age of just in time manufacturing, there is less of a risk of this... This is a bad situation and we can call it desperate deflation. But this kind of deflation is due to a serious structural problem in the economy, and it is not solved by monetary inflation. Keynes believed it could be, helped with short periods of monetary inflation, but nobody is actually following keynes prescription (Which calls for the government not running deficits and for the inflation to be absorbed when good times come back, which is effectively monetary deflation in good times.) Anyway, this "Bad deflation" is very rare, and is a symptom of another problem. The other form of deflation is the increasing purchasing power of money. This can happen in a robust economy, in fact it often happens in a robust economy. Imagine a country on the gold standard. The economy is growing well, but gold is coming out of the ground slowly (which it always does) so monetary inflation is low, while GDP growth is high. This means each year a given amount of gold will buy more stuff. Businesses make more profits, even as they lower prices, consumers can buy more for a given amount of gold, and the economy continues to grow, in large part because prices are going down. This is a good thing, and in fact this is the natural state of affairs in a free market, because productivity increases are always being created and technological advances are always being discovered, which means every decade the efficiency of the economy should be going up creating an increase in purchasing power. Governments, on the other hand, operate by promising programs to people in exchange for getting power. These programs are often not well managed because they are not subject to market forces. Further, since government has turnover of less than a decade, there are constantly new faces who want to make a name for themselves with new programs. Goernment thus has a strong incentive to inflate (because taxation is politically dangerous) to pay for these ever increasing new programs (they can't cut old programs because that's as politically dangerous as taxation.) Thus the governments spokesmodels (like Paul Krugman) are always pushing the idea that inflation is good and deflation is dangerous. Though it isn't difficult to see why the opposite is true.
- CWuestefeld 16y agoThus the governments spokesmodels (like Paul Krugman) are always pushing the idea that inflation is good and deflation is dangerous. I generally agree with you, and yes, Krugman-the-columnist is an ass (as opposed to Krugman-the-economist of days gone by). However, there is something (small) to be said for inflation. Behavior econometrics shows us that in some areas, our economic behavior is not what rationality would suggest. One of these areas is around wages: we expect upward movement of wages, and won't tolerate nominal decreases, even when buying power is increasing so that real wages are increasing. Maintaining a constant low level of inflation allows us to create an illusion that counters the irrational behavior, so that employers are still able to exercise a small degree of control over wages, at least over longer periods.
- dnautics 16y ago(flameshield) So giving employers control over wages is a liberal position? Just as I thought. (/flameshield) I guess, as a libertarian, my position is that irrational behavior is just that. It's going to happen, there's no reason to believe that government is going to be any less irrational than individuals, and on the balance, giving people freedom (to screw up, too) is more important, more sustainable, than imposing order and control over the populace. One thing that opened my eyes was this notion that a lot of what we do is totally a misjudgement of probabilities. If you have a game that 99.9999% of the time makes you a 100% return and .0001% of the time puts gives you a negative 10^1000 fold loss, you can wind up severe sample biasing that leads you to think that you're churning out awesome returns, when the equilibrium position is way bad. Of course, the solution that we as a society seem to have been headed toward is centralization of responsibility and insurance - which, IMO, has the potential to put everyone in the hole - when, instead we should possibly be embracing solutions of insulating risk and decentralizing, personalizing responsibility, combined with, you know, forgiveness. Seems to me like a more sustainable, humanizing way to handle things.
- CWuestefeld 16y agoNo flames necessary. I'm also a libertarian, so philosophically I agree with you. I'm also a bit of an armchair economist, and here I was just noting what economic theory tells us. To be sure, Milton Friedman would tell us that not only isn't inflation not fooling anyone, but it also represents a real transfer of funds into the hands of those who manage to first get their hands onto "new" dollars.
- sethg 16y agoIf you are in debt at fixed (or capped) interest rates, then inflation is good for you, since your income goes up while your monthly payments do not. If you depend on a fixed nominal income, then inflation is bad for you, since the prices of everything around you go up while your income does not. I think poor and lower-middle-class people are more likely to be in the first group than the second.
- hop 16y agoHow about the older poor and middle class on fixed incomes. Inflation will destroy their buying power (Though it may make social security less insolvent).
- dnautics 16y agoWrong. Here is why. Let's say you're poor, and spending 90% of your income on day to day needs. Versus if you're rich, and spending 20% of your income on day to day needs. a 10% inflation (absent corresponding wage inflation - which lags, but I'll omit it to keep things simple, the numbers have been rounded to make the math easy anyways) takes the poor person to 99% day to day and the rich person to 22% day to day. That represents a 90% decrease in ability to save or pay off debt. Versus the rich person who has lost 2.5% ability to save or pay off debt. Now. With a 10% inflation, your real debt burden has gone down 10%. Would you trade a 10% loss of debt burden for a 90% loss of ability to pay off the debt? I would not. Who is it that has promulgated this myth that inflation is good for poor people? I keep hearing it everywhere, and it appalls me that no one has really stopped to think about it.
- gnaritas 16y ago> absent corresponding wage inflation - which lags, but I'll omit it to keep things simple It doesn't just keep things simple, it changes things. You can't leave out wage inflation. Of course inflation is bad if your wages don't keep up, but what if they do? That's the actual question. Inflation also lags, printing money doesn't instantly create inflation, it takes time for the market to adjust to the new circulation.
- jsz0 16y agoPerhaps a stupid question but given the deficits created by two wars, the post 9/11 spending spree, unfunded tax cuts, TARP, and the first stimulus package why aren't we already deep into an inflationary spiral today? Is there anything to suggest another $1-2T of government stimulus brings us to a breaking point for inflation?
- d2viant 16y agoIt's very simple: People are still willing to lend money to the US government at very low rates because the other areas for investment (i.e. the stock market) are viewed as too risky. Additional government stimulus has little to do with it at this point, that will only come into play when inflation actually hits. When things change and people become more tolerant of risk and less tolerant of low returns, all the government deficits that have been accumulated will become a huge issue. When lenders to the US government start demanding 5%+ on their money, the interest payments on our debt will skyrocket.
- CWuestefeld 16y agoPaying just the interest on the debt takes a significant portion of government revenue, although I don't have citations handy. As that proportion increases (that is, how much of government revenue is spent just on paying for past debt, rather than anything productive), the likelihood of some threshold being crossed increases. But until that point, the government is able to sweep it all under the rug.