3 ms·
Food commercials are purely aesthetic. They are not really attesting to that the food you get will look or taste good. Logically, how could they? That being sai
by jchw 8y ago
Food commercials are purely aesthetic. They are not really attesting to that the food you get will look or taste good. Logically, how could they? That being said, it's apparently a myth that food commercials don't use real food. But does it matter, given that your Whopper won't look exactly like the one in the ad regardless?
It is a lot different if you outright claim your smartphone took photos it did not. That is more like saying that your new car can get 35 MPG when it couldn't under any circumstances.
People would probably find it a lot easier to be outraged if Apple faked an iPhone camera shot, which probably says more about people than it does about companies.
- gruez 8y ago>Food commercials are purely aesthetic. They are not really attesting to that the food you get will look or taste good. Logically, how could they? That being said, it's apparently a myth that food commercials don't use real food. But does it matter, given that your Whopper won't look exactly like the one in the ad regardless? supposedly they have to use the same ingredients that make up the food. yes, they can still use all sorts of camera tricks and practical effects to get it look better than it is, but at least it puts an upper bound of how much bullshitry they can create.
- newnewpdro 8y agoWhen a relative entered into the advertising business out of college she would tell me all about the tricks they did to make foods look good in the photo shoots. The burgers had toothpicks inside to make everything stand taller, grapes and other fruits were dipped in oil...
- vatueil 8y agoArs Technica noted that "Shot on iPhone" ads are technically correct but may use additional lenses and photo editing: https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2018/08/huawei-was-caught-using-a-pro-camera-to-fake-smartphone-photos-again/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2018/08/huawei-was-caught-us... > Photos from Apple's "Shot on iPhone" ads are indeed taken with iPhones, albeit with additional equipment like special lenses attached to the phone, and they've been touched up with professional photo editing software... A tiny, fine-print disclosure about lenses and retouches appears on the Apple ads...
- jchw 8y agoInteresting. In fairness, the quality of modern smartphone cameras makes this not so surprising to me. I think it might become normal to throw a smartphone photo into Lightroom in the future, even if it's probably overkill today. Now I wonder if the same caveat applies to the Pixel photos that are used in advertising.
- coldtea 8y ago>I think it might become normal to throw a smartphone photo into Lightroom in the future, even if it's probably overkill today. There's already Lightroom for mobile -- that can sync and have the same editing/presets as the desktop counterpart. And tons of people throw smartphone photos into desktop Lightroom as well.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- archi42 8y agoKeep in mind: A great lens on a mediocre sensor will still produce much better results than a mediocre lens on a great sensor. If they replace the whole iPhone lens assembly with a properly spaced Nikanon socket, they can attach some pretty nice glass to it.
- wl 8y agoMounting an SLR lens to an iPhone sensor would produce worse results than using the default lens. The imaging sensors used in cell phones are much smaller than SLRs, so you'd need to get a much wider angle lens. Then, you'd only be using the center of the lens, which the sensor would outresolve anyway.
- roywiggins 8y agoI have heard the rule is that if it's the food you're selling, it has to be real. But if you have some extra stuff in there (suppose you're selling a topping or something like that), that stuff can be fake food because it's not the food being advertised. One story that I read somewhere involved opening 50 frozen dinners and picking the 20 or so very best peas for the photographs. Technically each pea came from the actual product! So they seem to go to some lengths to obey the rules, even if it involves some bending.