6 ms·
Couple of points: Taxes don't work to work to change behavior, or people would have stopped speeding a long time ago, sugary drinks wouldn't sell in Seattle, a
by exabrial 8y ago
Couple of points:
Taxes don't work to work to change behavior, or people would have stopped speeding a long time ago, sugary drinks wouldn't sell in Seattle, and people would stop buying coffee in California. They are an unfortunate excuse used by politicians to fool the public into "hey I'm doing something!".
Instead, innovation is needed around providing biodegradable solutions that can outcompete their plastic counterparts. People will naturally switch to something healthier for the environment when it's more convenient and it saves them money. In this light, taxing plastics looks like an act of desperation admitting that "alternatives will never be as good, we have to help them out!" This actually stalls development on the renewables since an artificially inflated market is created.
Finally, this would become a source of revenue for governments that would be hard to eliminate. When environmentally friendly solutions finally came about, we'll literally have people saying "If we ban plastics, how will we pay for schools?"
There is a huge investment opportunity to replace them in the vast majority of areas. We need research, innovation, and investment, not more taxes.
- snowwrestler 8y agoTaxes don't work to change behavior, prices do. To the extent that a tax changes a price, it will change behavior. > People will naturally switch to something healthier for the environment when it's more convenient and it saves them money. Right, and one way to make the desired thing save consumers money is to apply tax policy.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoTaxes don't have some absolute power to control behavior, but they do influence it to some degree. (I am not taking a position either for or against taxing this specific issue.)
- mehrdadn 8y ago> Taxes don't work to work to change behavior, or people would have stopped speeding a long time ago, sugary drinks wouldn't sell in Seattle, and people would stop buying coffee in California. You do realize "work" isn't a binary thing?
- rhacker 8y agoCigarettes can be an indicator: http://www.nber.org/papers/w18326 http://www.nber.org/papers/w18326 > Our evidence suggests that increases in cigarette taxes are associated with small decreases in cigarette consumption and that it will take sizable tax increases, on the order of 100%, to decrease adult smoking by as much as 5%.
- mehrdadn 8y agoYeah, though cigarettes are actually biologically addictive... probably not the best comparison point against plastics.
- WalterBright 8y agoCanada tried increasing cigarette taxes a lot a couple decades ago. The result was the emergence of a black market, smuggling, and drive-by shootings of the rival smuggling gangs. The tax was lowered back down.
- WalterSear 8y agoPlastic isn't an addictive substance.
- rrcaptain 8y agoA small decrease in plastic waste is insufficient. We need radical solutions yesterday, not lackluster solutions three months from now.
- francisofascii 8y agoIncreasing the cost of something (through taxes) most definitely changes behavior. Just look at a how plastic bag taxes reduced usage or cigarette taxes. The purpose is not to stop plastic usage entirely, but to recognize the true cost of the usage by factoring in the harmful effects now rather than down the road. That make it a fair market, not an artificial one. I agree research and innovation is needed, and tax revenue could help pay for it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- exabrial 8y agoWould you agree that taxes has had a bigger impact on smokers than education [about addiction/cancer] and availability of vaping?
- c3534l 8y ago> Taxes don't work to work to change behavior This is absolute nonsense and flies in the face of established economic theory backed up by empirical evidence. I don't understand why there are so many people in this thread pulling assertions out of their ass like this. HackerNews is better than that.
- erulabs 8y agoUnfortunately the planet Earth is not a laboratory, and correlation is not causation. If a tax is added to cigarettes, and the tax is passed by elected officials, and the elected officials are responding to the attitude of the populace, how do we know it was the tax, and not _the attitude of the populace_ that lead to lower cigarette usage? A classic example of this is the Civil Rights Act. Did racism become abhorrent due to the signing of a bill, or was racism _becoming viewed as abhorrent_, and the bill codified the new cultural attitude? Keep in mind, I am of course not saying this means "no need for laws!", that would be insane - but there is no causal link and there cannot be a causal link, because one cannot do experiments with the human race. This line of thinking splits economics apart into different schools - with my conclusion being economics must be built from pure logic, upon a priori fact, rather that be gleaned by viewing society from afar. "Human Action" by Ludwig von Mises explores this in detail (https://mises.org/sites/default/files/Human%20Action_3.pdf https://mises.org/sites/default/files/Human%20Action_3.pdf)
- c3534l 8y agoI mean, there's an entire area of accounting called tax planning where accountants consult with businesses about how to conduct business to reduce their tax burden. Avoiding paying taxes isn't some obscure thing that people do, it's something you can make a six-figure salary doing as a profession. Additionally, there is no shortage of data for changing taxes. There are more than enough natural experiments as well as actual municipal experiments testing how people react to taxes. It turns out that most people avoid spending money they don't have to. People like money and they go out of their way to keep it.
- skybrian 8y agoYou're confusing the issue by comparing it with something much more complicated. A tax is another kind of price increase and we do know, empirically, how to study changes in supply and demand. You can get good datasets for it and any company can do experiments by changing prices. Logic is helpful in understanding how to analyze data but you can't get very far without data.
- WalterBright 8y agoAll you have to do is look at the evolution of beer cans. Over the decades, you'll see a steady reduction in the amount of metal used in them. This isn't for any environmental or regulatory reasons, it's purely cost reduction, since COGS (Cost Of Goods Sold) reduction is a powerful way to increase profits.