3 ms·
Take care that you can distinguish "allow humanity to be exterminated" from "there is a vague possibility that some people may be hurt." In the heat of the mome
by mcguire 8y ago
Take care that you can distinguish "allow humanity to be exterminated" from "there is a vague possibility that some people may be hurt." In the heat of the moment it's not always an easy line to distinguish.
Way back in the early 2000s, there was a discussion of the morality of torture; would it be moral, or should it be legal, to torture someone if they know where the bomb is?
My answer was that it was the wrong question. Torture is wrong, and should be illegal, but a true patriot (or a reasonable facsimile) would certainly be willing to do it anyway if necessary, and if the bomb is defused I'm sure everyone would pardon him.
- scotty79 8y agoFortunately whole theoretical debate was stupid because torture doesn't work as information extraction tool.