3 ms·
The major part of this article that I find convincing is that Card worked hard on the structure of the story to make Ender innocent. Sure, he may guilty and tor
by mcguire 8y ago
The major part of this article that I find convincing is that Card worked hard on the structure of the story to make Ender innocent. Sure, he may guilty and tormented about what he's done, but you and I, the readers, know he doesn't need to. He was tricked! and It was necessary! and all that.
Some deeds may never be good, but it sure looks from the story like what Ender does isn't one of them.
- scotty79 8y ago> but you and I, the readers, know he doesn't need to. He was tricked! and It was necessary! and all that. That's the whole point. It's constructed this way to show that no matter how innocent circumstance make you, you are still guilty. > Some deeds may never be good, but it sure looks from the story like what Ender does isn't one of them. Did you read the second part? "Speaker for the dead"? Few hundreds years have passed and he's remembered by everyone as genocidal murderer of the past. Maybe that's why for me "Ender's Game" means what it means, because I read it back to back with "Speaker for the dead".
- mcguire 8y agoI haven't read Speaker, so I don't know, but from everything I've seen, Ender is still the "hero" and the one leading the speaker-for-the-dead movement. He's portrayed as good but misunderstood.
- scotty79 8y agoPlease, read it. Speakers are just a sort of secular religion focused on speaking thruth about the dead. Ender is just one of the "priests". He's not a hero. He's remembered as the guy who commited xenocide. Highly regrettable affair. Nobody remembers circumstances. Imagine living in a remote village and suddenly in a conversation it turns out that your local pastor, Khan, is actually (let's say) the Gengis Khan, responsible for wiping out whole nations. You still say 'hello' to him as usual because he's thoughtful, helpful and impeccably polite but you can't help feeling bit uneasy.