4 ms·
The key is the onboarding program. Bakeries are nice, they have a range of jobs that go from very simple (sweeping up and cleaning) to very complex (scheduling
by ChuckMcM 8y ago
The key is the onboarding program. Bakeries are nice, they have a range of jobs that go from very simple (sweeping up and cleaning) to very complex (scheduling different products for baking). If you have that range you can absorb a lot of different people.
That said, if you recall the story we had here a while back [1] about how janitors used to work for the company and now they work for a contracting firm, this is very relevant. There are a lot of jobs at even a high tech company like Google or Apple that could be filled by someone with a high school degree and nominal fine motor skills, but those jobs are currently firewalled behind a general contracting company. That perversely misaligns the end employees motivations and the company motivations.
It was interesting to me to see the remnants of a system like this at IBM which had 10 "bands" of employment level, where band 1 was janitor level, and band 10 was principle engineer/senior manager type level. But it seemed like these days they only used bands 6 - 10 because that was where 'entry level engineer' started (band 6). Many if not all of the jobs in the lower bands were outsourced as far as I could tell. And a lot eliminated when they sold off factories or other parts of the business that had a lot of technician level labor.
I will be interesting to see if we could get back to a more reasonable way of managing these things.
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/03/upshot/to-understand-rising-inequality-consider-the-janitors-at-two-top-companies-then-and-now.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/03/upshot/to-understand-risi...
- jt2190 8y ago> There are a lot of jobs... currently firewalled behind a general contracting company. That perversely misaligns the end employees motivations and the company motivations. Would you mind elaborating on this point a bit? I have some notions of what you're suggesting, but I'd rather not assume.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoThe contracting company adds a cost layer between the worker and the employer. The money funding that cost layer comes out of the worker's salary not the price they charge the company they are providing services for. So the worker knows the contracting company is squeezing them and they get into a sort of adversarial relationship.
- Retric 8y agoA significant potion of this is an end run around immigration law. Cleaning companies need to compete with companies willing to employ illegal immigrants for very low wages which drives down the costs below what companies like IBM would pay people. Change some of these loopholes and the outsourcing overhead becomes far more significant. Though employing large numbers of part time workers works better at scale so the practice has some advantages.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoI have heard variants on this as well but haven't seen any actual data or research that supports this notion. If you come across any I'd be interested in reading that. There is a tremendous exposure to legal risk both for the contracting company and the company that hires the contracting company if they employ workers who do not have the right to work in the US. Having worked with IBM's legal department I'm pretty sure they run audits on any company they employ to insure they comply will all laws (they are really fussy about that stuff). In the New York Times article the Apple contract janitors weren't illegals either just under paid. Now the 'gig' economy? Sure. People who hire day laborers from the parking lot of the home improvement store? No question. But running a contracting business? I've not seen anything that backs up that assertion, and certainly nothing that is 'significant.'
- Retric 8y ago> tremendous exposure to legal risk In practice that's very rarely an issue. One recent case had Target using a cleaning service that way paying illegal immigrants below minimum wage. The government did not care and the only impact was being forced to pay actual wages. And remember that's the worst case, which means sticking with minimum wage is safe. Now, IBM/Apple/whatever may take steps to avoid illegal immigrants. But, the market clearing price does not have a simple illegal vs. non separation for jobs. So, companies bidding on work are faced with some hard choices. PS: Now, if you can find examples of penalties for the big company side of things outside of the most blatant violations I would be curious.
- PurpleBoxDragon 8y ago
- Inconel 8y agoI’m writing this on my phone while on break so I can’t get as detailed as I’d like but I just wanted to express agreement with your point regarding the effects of low level jobs being outsourced to contractors. I don’t want to get too specific in my role but I was able to go from a very entry level position at SpaceX, let’s say something along the lines of kitchen/cafeteria/janitorial/facilities staff, to a much more technical position working on actual launch vehicle hardware. I know I’m not the only one that’s moved up from those positions into our technician roles. It actually happens somewhat regularly. I can’t imagine this being the case if all of our lower level positions were outsourced to contractors.