4 ms·
It worked pretty well for the Manhattan Project and the Apollo missions. I think that you're romanticizing technological progress a bit if you don't believe tha
by adrianN 8y ago
It worked pretty well for the Manhattan Project and the Apollo missions. I think that you're romanticizing technological progress a bit if you don't believe that more money (often) leads to more progress.
- WalterSear 8y agoI think their point is that you can't just buy progress on demand.
- wmeredith 8y agoAnd I think the counterpoint offered was that the Mamhattan Project and Apollo programs did just that. Note that in both cases you had government-deep pockets and global sociopolitical ramifications as team motivators-a potent combination.
- WalterSear 8y agoNo, they set up a multi-year governmental project. It's rather different from throwing money at a c-suite executive and telling them to hire developers.
- LoSboccacc 8y agothose where quite different projects, having to surmount lot of known unknowns. self driving is still fraught with unknowns unknowns. once the problem gets mapped out money will enable company to power trough.
- majewsky 8y agoSmells like hindsight bias.
- LoSboccacc 8y agonot really. both those indicated projects had all the required component worked out already, plus the physics at their basis where understood. there was a working reactor and the governing phenomena was well understood. it was mostly a refinement and tuning process to get it right. same with apollo, at that point nasa had been launching people in space for a decade, working out the docking procedures and capsule operations. contrast with deep neural network, there are no models to predict overfitting or undertraining beyond what training cross validation say. hardly the same situation. there's no model that can predict a network confidence and network output as a classifier is still very rough even before it gets converted into car commands (i.e. see Uber report) those cited project had a theoretical framework on which they were built upon. neural network are still rooted in 'tune them if they don't work' stage.
- dalbasal 8y agoI dunno if I'm romaticizing. A massive mission/goal driven exercise can be quite romatic. Tesla did that, and I'd call that more romantic than (for eg) FB's path. Good points though. Tons of resources, people working in secret, and a total absence of "market feedback" have yielded big, impressive results before.
- oh_sigh 8y agoBoth of your examples where government-run "monopolies" - that is, if you were a physics or rocketry expert, you didn't have much of a choice of which organization to join in order to build an A-bomb or rocket.
- jonny_eh 8y agoAnd it's likely you got kicked out of the competition's country for being Jewish. America got super lucky.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- knuththetruth 8y agoIt only works when you're talking massive, government-backed support for basic scientific and technological research. The tech industry likes to lean on this narrative, but the reality is they just exploit the gains of basic research and are probably reaching the limit of what can be drawn from the last time this happened (i.e. when governments created the internet). This is why you see tech shifting into so much rent-seeking nonsense and bizarre financialization strategies that mirror Wall St/the banking industry. They're scraping the bottom of the government-financed research well and don't have much actual ability to create fundamental technological innovation themselves. The good news is all we have to do is shift back to massive government investments in basic research to course correct and compete with entities like China(who seem to have a clearer picture of how Capitalism actually works in practice).