5 ms·
By the time you're building self-driving car-exclusive tunnels and the like, you really are getting very little benefit over a train system to justify doing it,
by emodendroket 8y ago
By the time you're building self-driving car-exclusive tunnels and the like, you really are getting very little benefit over a train system to justify doing it, especially when you take emissions into account.
- gdulli 8y agoI agree. Anything with low-occupancy vehicles feels like a dead end to me. Of all things, car ownership is the thing we're aggressively enabling/optimizing in 2018? Really? I'm usually not a person who's sympathetic to complaints about advances in technology eliminating jobs. Not for a real overall long term gain to society. But autonomous cars putting swaths of people out of work while at the same time taking us in the wrong direction on traffic, emissions, etc. doesn't feel great. Those drivers losing work slowly over time as cities evolve truly better and more sustainable transportation options feels more right. Aside from the opportunity cost of not furthering public transportation, autonomous cars will drive around aimlessly anytime the cost of fuel is less than the cost of parking. We already have Uber creating waste by idling/driving around between passengers.
- icebraining 8y agocar ownership is the thing we're aggressively enabling/optimizing in 2018? Really? On the contrary: making taxis cheaper (which self-driving can do, by eliminating the biggest cost - the driver) makes it much easier to live without owning a car. If there was no Uber and such, I'd probably have to own a car for the exceptions not covered by public transport. And after paying for the fixed costs anyway, the marginal cost per trip is low, making me more likely to use it over PT. autonomous cars will drive around aimlessly anytime the cost of fuel is less than the cost of parking Per the above, cheaper taxis → fewer owned cars → more free parking spaces.
- gdulli 8y agoWho happens to own the car, the driver or a service provider, is inconsequential in assessing the big picture consequences of more cars on the road vs. more sustainable options.
- icebraining 8y agoBut it's not more cars, that's my point. Say public transport covers 95% of my needs. If I have cheap taxis, I'll use public transport most of the time, and cars only 5%. If I have to buy a car because I can't afford those taxi rides, I might use it for 30% or 40% or more of the trips, since it just costs me a bit of gas (or electricity) - the fixed costs are sunk.
- emodendroket 8y agoI mean, the incentives are also kind of backwards -- it's usually free to drive and you have to pay to ride the train. If we're really looking at climate cataclysm it might be worth thinking about changing that dynamic.
- thebradbain 8y agoIt's "free" to drive in the sense that you don't have to take money out of your wallet to get into the driver seat of your car, yes. But that doesn't account for: - The monthly payment on the car (if applicable) - Liability / collision insurance - Gas - Tolls - Parking - Repairs - Washes With this in mind, public transportation is obviously way cheaper than driving – and exclusively using Uber may very well be in some cities, too. But yes, I'd agree with you that many people don't seem to account for those hidden costs when justifying driving over taking public transit in a city that adequately supports it. Hopefully one day soon that will change.
- emodendroket 8y agoAssuming you have a car (which is more or less necessary in most places you might live in this country), for any given trip it's very close to free to drive while the train is more expensive. And if you're thinking about parking and riding, between the higher cost of those tickets and the parking fee it's actually pretty expensive to do and driving all the way into the city is definitely cheaper.
- Piskvorrr 8y agoI can imagine a part of the Interstate mesh getting repurposed as SDV-only. In a city...not so fast.
- thanatropism 8y agoLong range trucking is really the killer app. Fleets of N trucks can take an entire lane of road in sequence (almost like train wagons) and talk to each other and have M<N supervisors.
- emodendroket 8y agoBut long-range trucking seems just as amenable to replacement by freight trains if we're building dedicated infrastructure.
- ams6110 8y agoTrains don't run on demand from point to point. All your Amazon next day deliveries depend on trucks and airplanes. Trains work for some freight delivery patterns, but not nearly all. Stuff that can go by train for the most part already does.
- Piskvorrr 8y ago1. Building railroads is an order of magnitude harder than building roads (gradients, turn radii, clearance, yards). 2. Not even building, just repurposing. "This road/lane/whatever now SDV only." 3. Trains only run on rails. Trucks that could be run as SDVs on dedicated infrastructure and as human-driven on shared infrastructure tackle the last-mile problem far more efficiently. 4. Trains are built on the "smart infrastructure" paradigm (go straight at the speed which the signals tell you, until the signals tell you to stop); trucks on the opposite "smart vehicles" paradigm (road exists, everything else is your responsibility). This makes a truck rollout far more scalable (as in "just add this road to whitelist").
- maym86 8y agoRight. We already have a great solution to many of the autonomous vehicle problems. Trains and busses.
- ams6110 8y agoTrains and buses don't run on demand from point to point.
- maym86 8y agoThey do a pretty good job of getting you very close in London and NYC. Longer distance trains get you between cities much faster than in a car. They don't solve everything but they are definitely underutilized as a solution in the US. We could put effort into making them better but it's not as sexy.
- tialaramex 8y agoMetro service is the key. When frequencies get high enough the timetable exists only for the benefit of the operations personnel, customers don't care about it because their experience is like with an elevator. You don't ask for a timetable for the elevator, you just go to the place where elevators arrive, and wait, and very shortly there will be an elevator. Very high densities are both the problem and the solution. They're the problem because under very high density private car ownership is infeasible, and the solution because public transport becomes fast and affordable. If you let it.
- emodendroket 8y agoFrankly I think commuter rail for suburban riders is great and I think there should be more of it too. Who the hell likes driving to work during rush hour?
- maym86 8y agoExactly. A lot of the issues with public transportation are because we underfund the systems and they end up seeming worse than they could be. The complaints that users have are not with the concept of trains or busses but with the failures, which can be minimized with adequate investment.