10 ms·
That graph is pretty useless by only focusing on single family homes in metropolitan areas. Single family homes may hold nationwide as a housing growth indicato
by Nasrudith 8y ago
That graph is pretty useless by only focusing on single family homes in metropolitan areas. Single family homes may hold nationwide as a housing growth indicator but one would expect mature and rising cities to have more multifamily residences even if they had a space boon from obsolete industrial jobs move elsewhere due to urban areas providing less of an advantage due to high numbers of workers being less needed with increased automation. Similarly sixteen high rise permits would do more for housing than one hundred sixty single family homes despite there technically being fewer new construction permits - evem though they would rightfully be more involved in making sure it wouldn't cause disaster. While I do not doubt that many urban areas have a housing shortage that isn't very good evidence given the caveats.
- rootusrootus 8y agoCondominiums each get their own set of permits. Most importantly, just like a single family house, they each have to be issued a Certificate of Occupancy.
- quantgenius 8y agoThis depends on the market. This is definitely not the case in NYC
- Spooky23 8y agoHuh? The NYS Attorney General approves all condos separate from the local building permitting process.
- mdorazio 8y agoI'm not following what your point is. If I'm reading the first table in [1] correctly, 20+ unit condo (and maybe apartment?) complex new construction starts have been declining annually while single-family home construction has been increasing. This seems to support the parent comment's argument that growth indicators are out of alignment with what markets actually need. [1] https://www.census.gov/construction/nrc/pdf/quarterly_starts_completions.pdf https://www.census.gov/construction/nrc/pdf/quarterly_starts...
- rootusrootus 8y agoI was replying to the assertion that it's not comparable to look at permits as an accurate measurement of new construction since a building in the city holds many families, versus one family per building in the 'burbs. In reality it's pretty straightforward to use certificates of occupancy as a measurement because it [nearly always] measures housing units instead of clusters of housing units. Apartments (not condos) are sometimes an exception.
- mdorazio 8y agoAh, I see. Thanks for clarifying. In that case I agree.
- ryandrake 8y agoEven in places that are appropriate for single family homes, like suburban areas far from the housing crises in San Francisco and San Jose, it is getting harder and harder to find new-ish single family homes. And there is zero new construction of such homes. If you prefer that kind of lifestyle (1X00 sq.ft. with a lawn), you’re stuck with housing stock built in the 1980s and earlier. Everywhere I see new construction, even out in the exurbs, it’s 3-story apartments and ugly row homes squished together on postage stamp-sized lots.
- mikestew 8y agoIf you prefer that kind of lifestyle (1X00 sq.ft. with a lawn), you’re stuck with housing stock built in the 1980s and earlier. The problem around the Redmond, WA area is that if you want the lifestyle you describe, despite lots of new houses going up you will still have to have something built in the 80s. Because everything being built is 3200 sq. ft. or more. Now, I understand why, because you get more money from a $1.3MM house than you do a $800K one. But if you don't want some monstrosity with a postage stamp lot (because the house took it all), good luck finding one in Redmond. They're building houses, but nothing I'd personally want to buy.
- briffle 8y agoHowever, all those people moving into the 3200 sq ft homes have to move from somewhere. That opens up smaller homes, large apartments, etc.
- mikestew 8y agoWellll, except about a mile south of us someone is snapping up the 1200 sq. ft. houses and dropping 3500 sq. ft. warehouses on them. It was kind of sad when I saw the kids playing on the sidewalk, because you could cut the front yard with scissors in about ten minutes, and I imagine the backyard isn't much bigger. But I take your point. Our little rambler is a hidden gem that will be worth millions when the trend swings the other way. :-)
- ryandrake 8y ago
- Spooky23 8y agoThat graph doesn't tell the story, it's just picked because single family is the simplest indicator and has well defined economic benefit. The figures always incorporate new housing units -- a 20 story high-rise does not look like a single family home in the stats. You can look at the raw data and see single/multi/large residential starts: https://www.census.gov/construction/nrc/pdf/bpsa.pdf https://www.census.gov/construction/nrc/pdf/bpsa.pdf Single family construction is the canary in the coal mine because the costs are escalating to the point where more and more people are priced out. New construction is $150-275/sqft (10% more if no garage is present). When I started working in 2000, it was about half that. Per-unit costs drop with multi-family, but it's still creeping up there. The minimum price for finished new construction condos in my area (which is usually a 50th percentile market in the US) is about $350k.
- magduf 8y agoPeople don't need single-family homes. People in other countries do just fine with multi-family dwellings: high-rise condos, apartments, etc. In cities which are steadily increasing in density, single-family homes are utterly wasteful, and completely unnecessary. You can only fit so many of them in a given area, whereas with a high-rise, you can fit hundreds of people into the area used by a small handful of single-family homes.
- ApolloFortyNine 8y agoExcept a lot of people prefer single-family homes? It doesn't matter what's efficient if it's what is in demand.
- mywittyname 8y agoIt does matter what's efficient because inefficiency in this matter is a burden to society.
- aetherson 8y agoI bet that you do something that's "a burden to society," broadly defined, and aren't willing to give that up.
- Bluecobra 8y agoI agree, I think you would see a lot more renovations vs. new homes. Where I live in Chicago (not the trendiest part of town), the cheapest single family fixer-uppers are $350-450K. Not many people queuing up to drop at least $1 million on new homes here.
- siruncledrew 8y agoWhere are they going to find the space to build single-family homes? Realistically, there's no way the rate of construction of single family homes in a finite amount of area is going to stay fixed or keep increasing over time. The alternative is create an overload of urban sprawl, which expands the "metro area", and also increases commute times.