4 ms·
> though he ultimately takes on guilt for the extermination of the alien buggers, his assuming this guilt is a gratuitous act > ... > In this Card argues that
by scotty79 8y ago
> though he ultimately takes on guilt for the extermination of the alien buggers, his assuming this guilt is a gratuitous act
> ...
> In this Card argues that the morality of an act is based solely on the intentions of the person acting.
This book must be a mirror where different people see different things.
For me, morally, it was a tale about how some deeds are so horrible, that no matter what your motivations or circumstances were they can never be good. You saved humanity? Doesn't matter if you exterminated entire intelligent species for that. You were decieved to do that? Still doesn't matter.
It resonated with me, an atheist, very strongly that some evils while might be forgiven by some people for some time, they can never be "absolved".
For me on personal level such unabsolvable deed is killing. By extension I think that army won't be moral untill each soldier comming back from the war is ready to be tried and sentenced for each life he took. We are probably closer to singuarity than to morality defined like that.
- Ntrails 8y ago> You saved humanity? Doesn't matter if you exterminated entire intelligent species for that. Do you truly believe that? In a war of extinction you feel the moral choice is to allow humanity to be exterminated instead? Surely inaction is just as morally unjust as action? I do not believe that not switching the train onto the track which doesn't kill someone is different from switching it onto a track which does. In more direct terms I, for one, would feel no guilt killing to save my own life from an aggressor, or to save those of my family/friends.
- mcguire 8y agoTake care that you can distinguish "allow humanity to be exterminated" from "there is a vague possibility that some people may be hurt." In the heat of the moment it's not always an easy line to distinguish. Way back in the early 2000s, there was a discussion of the morality of torture; would it be moral, or should it be legal, to torture someone if they know where the bomb is? My answer was that it was the wrong question. Torture is wrong, and should be illegal, but a true patriot (or a reasonable facsimile) would certainly be willing to do it anyway if necessary, and if the bomb is defused I'm sure everyone would pardon him.
- scotty79 8y agoFortunately whole theoretical debate was stupid because torture doesn't work as information extraction tool.
- scotty79 8y ago> In a war of extinction you feel the moral choice is to allow humanity to be exterminated instead? Moral choice is not always the right choice. The fact that the choice is right or logical doesn't make it moral. > Surely inaction is just as morally unjust as action? Nothing sure about that. For example in case of "trolley problem" I would not reroute the trolley so that 1 person dies instead of five because I believe that saving people is optional, but not killing them is mandatory. Or I would reroute the trolley accepting that even though it might be correct it was immoral. > In more direct terms I, for one, would feel no guilt killing to save my own life from an aggressor, or to save those of my family/friends. I would feel the guilt if I killed someone.
- LordKano 8y agoI don't believe that the dilemma faced by Ender is akin to the traditional trolley problem. It's not a straight utilitarian choice of 1 innocent or 5 innocents die based on your decision to act or not. Namely, the people on the trolley have intentionally run down innocents in the past and to the best of your knowledge, they are doing so again. You have the choice to do nothing and allow those innocents to be killed or to throw the switch and kill those whom are trying to kill the innocents.
- scotty79 8y agoIf you are seeking analogy he had a trolley problem where 5 people are his family and on the other track there is a guy who commited serious crime, maybe killing, some believe it was even a murder. Everyone around agrees he should make every effort possible to throw the switch while he himself is led to believe that he's throwing training switch and even after throwing real switch the bad guy will rather be maimed not killed. Still, he throws the switch, it was the real switch, guy is killed and eventually it turns out his offence was an accident and if left alone the trolley wouldn't kill 5 people. Ender is guilty of killng a guy even though what he did was perfectly reasonable considering circumstances.
- LordKano 8y ago
- mcguire 8y agoThe major part of this article that I find convincing is that Card worked hard on the structure of the story to make Ender innocent. Sure, he may guilty and tormented about what he's done, but you and I, the readers, know he doesn't need to. He was tricked! and It was necessary! and all that. Some deeds may never be good, but it sure looks from the story like what Ender does isn't one of them.
- scotty79 8y ago> but you and I, the readers, know he doesn't need to. He was tricked! and It was necessary! and all that. That's the whole point. It's constructed this way to show that no matter how innocent circumstance make you, you are still guilty. > Some deeds may never be good, but it sure looks from the story like what Ender does isn't one of them. Did you read the second part? "Speaker for the dead"? Few hundreds years have passed and he's remembered by everyone as genocidal murderer of the past. Maybe that's why for me "Ender's Game" means what it means, because I read it back to back with "Speaker for the dead".
- mcguire 8y agoI haven't read Speaker, so I don't know, but from everything I've seen, Ender is still the "hero" and the one leading the speaker-for-the-dead movement. He's portrayed as good but misunderstood.
- scotty79 8y agoPlease, read it. Speakers are just a sort of secular religion focused on speaking thruth about the dead. Ender is just one of the "priests". He's not a hero. He's remembered as the guy who commited xenocide. Highly regrettable affair. Nobody remembers circumstances. Imagine living in a remote village and suddenly in a conversation it turns out that your local pastor, Khan, is actually (let's say) the Gengis Khan, responsible for wiping out whole nations. You still say 'hello' to him as usual because he's thoughtful, helpful and impeccably polite but you can't help feeling bit uneasy.
- zeveb 8y ago> For me on personal level such unabsolvable deed is killing. By extension I think that army won't be moral untill each soldier comming back from the war is ready to be tried and sentenced for each life he took. We are probably closer to singuarity than to morality defined like that. We've already been there, and still are — there were & are Christian churches which prescribe confession & penance (to include temporary excommunication) for those who return from war.
- scotty79 8y agoGreat to hear that. It might help them personally, but after confession and penance, are the sins of killing people absolved? Or just accepted?