4 ms·
An iPad or PowerPoint may be more "sophisticated" than an overhead projector and dry wipe pen, but I'm not certain they are better. (Actually now I wonder if t
by rwmj 8y ago
An iPad or PowerPoint may be more "sophisticated" than an overhead projector and dry wipe pen, but I'm not certain they are better.
(Actually now I wonder if there is a tablet application which faithfully replicates the overhead projector and roll of acetate experience?)
- raverbashing 8y agoNot a tablet app, but there are "smart whiteboards" that do a nice job of combining showing things + scribbling/writing.
- 2muchcoffeeman 8y agoYou probably want to have both though. I don’t want to sit in a lecture taking notes. But OHPs were great for worked examples and answering questions that needed diagrams.
- rwmj 8y agoHonestly I'd never remember a thing if I didn't take notes. I take notes even today, whenever I'm in meetings or presentations: https://rwmj.wordpress.com/2017/11/24/keeping-a-work-notebook/ https://rwmj.wordpress.com/2017/11/24/keeping-a-work-noteboo...
- magicalhippo 8y agoThe best lectures I had at uni were some math lectures where the professor had an overhead with a transparency roll. He'd write on the transparency as if it was a blackboard, and could roll up and down as needed to review older equations or make room for new. Blackboard worked well too, but not as good, since the professor could sit in front of the overhead so things lined up better, and the transparency pens had much better visibility than chalk on a (green) blackboard. Most other lectures used PowerPoint, due to the professors being forced by the uni administration, but for me a PowerPoint lecture was barely worth the time. The information just wouldn't stick, since the PowerPoint format doesn't lend itself well to writing notes from, and without writing notes I hardly remembered anything.
- rleigh 8y agoThe other factor is the pacing. If the lecturer is writing, on a transparency or blackboard, you can take notes at the same pace. PowerPoint allows stupid amounts of information to be delivered, which just washes over you--it's too much to transcribe, and too much to digest on the fly. Writing constrains the lecturer to delivering a reasonable amount of material, so that the participants can actually focus on it and retain it. PowerPoint might be good for business proposals, sales and marketing, etc. But I personally think it's a travesty for educational use; there are few lectures I've attended which I found better for the unnecessary use of technology.
- magicalhippo 8y agoYes, pacing is a huge factor. Written notes naturally lend themselves to be written, and with the professor writing them live, you usually have time to write them down and think about what you're writing as you go. I caught many small mistakes, missing signs etc, while taking notes. I would not have caught that when looking at some slide.
- extra88 8y agoI has a number of faculty who would print "slides" on acetate sheets to display using an overhead projector, they had the same potential for being overloaded.
- rleigh 8y agoIt's possible to be a bad lecturer and use acetates. But physical constraints still act against it: they are bulky, you can't easily manage a lecture with 100 acetates, they have a tendency to slide onto the floor and make a jumbled mess, and they also cost money to make and take up physical space to store and move around. While you can still abuse them, these factors limit how far you can take that abuse. PowerPoint knows no bounds. I only used to print diagrams and figures onto acetates, leaving writing for the blackboard/whiteboard/blank acetates. You would use one or two for an entire session. I try to do the same with PowerPoint (well, Beamer), but some organisations increasingly mandate the whole thing be word for word on slides and stored in Blackboard for students to get. I find this wholly detrimental to the purpose of giving and attending a lecture, since it constrains the lecturer to this terrible presentation style.