5 ms·
The article explicitly addresses SF So this article is about a state which enforces a minimum wage above the US norm for workers in tip-heavy industries. US min
by ggm 8y ago
The article explicitly addresses SF So this article is about a state which enforces a minimum wage above the US norm for workers in tip-heavy industries. US minimum wage is like $2.15 and federally mandated tip+wage rate is $7.25 and the Californian state wage is $10. This is functionally equivalent to federal minimum plus 30%.
I realize the transition moment here is confronting, and with family who work and depend on this class of labour I am completely aware of the immediate pay consequence, but even with this,
I think Californians should grab an opportunity to walk off tip culture, and walk into 'fair pay for work' culture.
The minimum wage is not fair? Lets support all workers for a fair minimum wage. End tip culture.
- gnicholas 8y ago> I think Californians should grab an opportunity to walk off tip culture, and walk into 'fair pay for work' culture. The minimum wage is not fair? Lets support all workers for a fair minimum wage. End tip culture. It is far from clear that getting rid of tips is good for tipped workers, at the end of the day [1]. Basically, there may be unintended consequences. Also, due to a quirk of tax law, getting rid of tips would result in higher total prices. This is because we don't pay sales tax on the tip currently. If this payment were built into the cost of the meal, sales tax would go up. Not a huge difference, but it adds up — and restaurants are low-margin businesses to begin with. 1: https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/get-rid-of-tips-and-lose-your-best-servers/2018/02/28/0756866c-1b32-11e8-98f5-ceecfa8741b6_story.html?noredirect=on&utm_term=.4798e30af06a https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/get-rid-of-tips-and-...
- ggm 8y agoI don't buy this argument. I understand he (and I guess you) believe it, but I think this argument doesn't reflect real world experience from non-tipping culture (I mean about net loss of high end staff) If you don't pay your wait staff above-award and want to keep the best, I think you need to think about their value to your business. The tax cost part, I recognize. I am not blind to unintended consequences, but this one? Not big enough to make me feel like reversing course. I'm reminded of a great "bill tidy" cartoon from the 1970s of a porter in a USSR hotel holding his tip-hand out to the guy he's just carried bags into the room while speaking into a not very hidden microphone tipping is evil and diminishes the dignity of labour
- gnicholas 8y agoI don't really have a dog in the fight, but in reading about this issue I've seen several articles about how some restaurants have tried out getting rid of tips – and then reverted to tips fairly quickly because it didn't go well [1-2]. I'm not aware of cases where restaurants got rid of tipping and then things went awesome — and I assume that if this had happened then it would be covered in the media just like the failed attempts were. 1: https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/05/why-restaurants-walk-back-no-tipping-policies/482151/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/05/why-res... 2: https://www.newyorker.com/culture/annals-of-gastronomy/the-limitations-of-american-restaurants-no-tipping-experiment https://www.newyorker.com/culture/annals-of-gastronomy/the-l...
- onion2k 8y agoI suspect distributing the cost of the money a restaurant makes from tips across all the customers would lead to many restaurants closing. A quick absurdist example - if a restaurant has 10 customers and 1 gives a $1000 tip, increasing all the bills by $100 instead would mean the 9 customers who didn't tip would likely stop eating there.
- mFixman 8y agoThe minimum wage in San Francisco is $15 per hour. That's including tipped work: if you don't make that amount from wages and tips you're supposed to be paid extra.
- Cogito 8y agoFor the people saying that this would have unintended consequences, that may well be the case. Somehow, the rest of the world seems to get by without the same tipping culture. Moving towards a fair pay for work culture may require more than just 'not tipping', but we already have many examples where it is the case. Prices may go up, or tax laws need to change, but just because there are thin margins in the industry doesn't mean that the only way to survive is to force workers to live off their tips. In so many cases it seems like tipping culture merely serves to hide the true cost of a meal or service. Similarly, the odd practice of not including any taxes in the sticker price on goods. This one in particular feels anti-consumer, and seems to persist because sellers worry that their prices, if listed including taxes, would seem higher than the competition. I'm surprised more retailers don't buck this trend more often; realising that taxes were included in Cafe du Monde's list price for their coffee and biegnets made the experience even more enjoyable than it otherwise would have been, and definitely contributed to a few of the midnight treks I made to get that particular treat.
- d1zzy 8y agoSpeaking about "unintended consequences", I would like to see a study if there's any correlation between heavy tipping culture and service quality. So far in my travels the US has been the place where waiters are the "nicest" while places with little tipping (but high menu pricing, ex. in Europe) I've had mixed service quality (but generally significantly worse than in the US).
- jacques_chester 8y agoThe flipside is that I can't just sit and eat or drink in peace in the US. I am either badgered because of a schedule ("how is everything?", inevitably mid-chew), or badgered to buy something ("another round?", "want to see the dessert menu?") or -- just as annoying -- totally invisible if I am judged as no longer having money-making potential. "Good service" is relative. What I want is to make an order, enjoy myself, then leave, with a minimum of fuss. I need a waiter. I don't need a bestest buddy evar!!1! who dabbles in bringing me food and drinks as a hobby.
- 8y ago
- tvh 8y agoI like how you think. I especially think you're in the right with the opportunity for Californians to walk off the tip culture. This would set a great precedent to reproduce this on a national level, if done correctly.