2 ms·
No. If the study was flawed, there is no real take away. Pretty much period. Imagine if physics claimed it was ok that they couldn't predict the motion they w
by taeric 8y ago
No. If the study was flawed, there is no real take away. Pretty much period.
Imagine if physics claimed it was ok that they couldn't predict the motion they were trying to describe, because they still had fancy equations. The entire point is the predictive point.
Now, if there are parts that are replicating, then good. We hopefully learned something. But if the study doesn't replicate, you are just pushing an agenda. Odd, as that is what you claim others are doing.
- abnry 8y agoCorrect. As a study stands flawed, there is no real takeaway. However, a flawed study does not mean the original conclusion is false. Merely that the evidence the study provides for it cannot bolster it. But now the study is part of the societal conversation, and this means the idea of moral plasticity is something on people's minds, especially in the context of the study. This isn't the same thing as a rigorous study, but it does prove the point that many people /feel/ that moral plasticity /is/ a thing. This is not rigorous, but in a way, it gives a weak confirmation of the relevance of the idea. Think of some alternatives: we aren't wondering if the study suggests people will become hyper moral when given the power to act harshly. Nobody talks about that.
- taeric 8y agoI sorta agree. A flawed study says nothing about any conclusions. Neither for nor against. Is it an interesting question? I think so. But right now I see no evidence that I trust one way or the other. Instead, I see a ton of posturing. This is akin to picking a movie like Shawshank Redemption and claiming it proves something of human nature. No. It doesn't. I feel it helps me relate to and accept some behaviors. But it proves nothing. As it is fiction.
- Kalium 8y agoIt's possible that the notion of moral plasticity has taken hold in part because of this flawed experiment that set out to prove it. That people feel moral plasticity to be a thing in the wake of being systematically lied to the tune of "moral plasticity is a thing!" should not be taken as evidence of moral plasticity. That is at best circular reasoning. Indeed, by that line of reasoning every religion should be thought to be true simultaneously, as their respective adherents feel them to be true. The only confirmation I see here is that of squishies being over-eager to fit facts to convenient and familiar narratives.
- mcguire 8y agoThere is a persistent story that there are "good" people and "bad" people, and that "good people" only do bad things under very extreme circumstances. Everyone wants to believe they would never do that, for various definitions of that. Only real monsters would do that. There is plenty of evidence that this story is false, yet one sees it constantly.
- eeZah7Ux 8y ago> If the study was flawed, there is no real take away There is no real takeaway, OK, but people confuse this with the idea that moral plasticity might be unproven. That's not the case. It's well known in psychology, and well proven, that people be manipulated into becoming the "cruel guards".
- taeric 8y agoAgreed on that point. I am under the impression that the "well proven" part was under serious consideration now. But it should not be due to this study. Which should not be used to inform either side of the debate.