6 ms·
There are a lot of opportunities to make functional structures attractive (even attractions in themselves) but this approach seems to have fallen into abeyance,
by gumby 8y ago
There are a lot of opportunities to make functional structures attractive (even attractions in themselves) but this approach seems to have fallen into abeyance, in particular in the USA and the UK, for some reasons over the past 50 years.
For example instead of brutalist bollards and jersey barriers, pedestrian ways could be set aside via grade elevation or attractive, gapped structures that invite walking instead of looking threatening. Water plants could have "water temples" again.
It seems like some theory that doing anything beyond the functional minimum is a waste of the taxpayer's money. But isn't a crude structure also a tax on the psyche?
- sandworm101 8y agoRemember that barriers to protect pedestrians work two ways: to protect them from cars, but also to restrain them from getting into car territory. Gapped barriers have a place but do not stop drunks from wandering into traffic. Some gaps, if they obstruct sight lines for either car or pedestrian, can be worse than having no barrier. Bollards (wide gap structures) are not for protecting pedestrians. They are very dangerous for fast-moving vehicles. Bollards are to stop slow stuff like cars trying to park. They are for keeping drivers from driving into defined areas, not for shielding pedestrians from car accidents. Bollards are placed to stop cars entering city parks, not between a sidewalk and the highway.
- bobthepanda 8y agoSource? Bollards are used extensively in the US to protect from either ram-raiding burglaries or car-ramming terrorist attacks. For example, bollards stopped the vehicle from the 2007 Glasgow Airport attack from entering the terminal: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007_Glasgow_Airport_attack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007_Glasgow_Airport_attack
- toomanybeersies 8y agoGlasgow is in Scotland, not the USA.
- bobthepanda 8y agoAn example in New York: https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2017/05/18/what-stopped-car-times-square-closer-look-bollards/101851466/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2017/05/18/what-stopped-... The point is that if people are going to insinuate that bollards are not intended for protecting pedestrians, there had better be some evidence to the contrary. (They may not actually do so in the same way that guardrails don't actually help, but the road to hell is paved with good intentions: https://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/13/business/highway-guardrail-may-be-deadly-states-say.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/13/business/highway-guardrai...)
- microcolonel 8y ago> not for shielding pedestrians from car accidents I think you're making two separate distinctions here. Bollards are not appropriate as a first defense on motorways because they present a great risk to motorists. Bollards are however often built to shield pedestrians from car accidents (and other situations where cars enter pedestrian space inappropriately, like ram raids and vehicular terror attacks), they're just not good for protecting motorists when they do so. The most common bollards in major American and Canadian cities are explicitly specified and built to protect against fast-moving vehicles of a certain weight and center of gravity).
- sandworm101 8y agoA truck crashing into a series of bollards (a glancing blow, not a direct terror attack) turns into a meat grinder. The first bollard impact, say to the right of the front bumper, initiates a rotation. The vehicle then turns sideways to its direction of travel, becomes unstable, rolls, then impacts the next bollard. Anyone inside or anywhere near this chaos is injured. The bulk of the vehicle will eventually stop beyond the line of bollards, in pedestrian territory. This never happens, and there are no videos, because no idiot builds roads this way. The closest we have to bollards beside roads are telephone poles and trees. See this vid at 2m15s. Watch the car rotate, roll, become airborne and land on the sidewalk. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wMBimrlAauA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wMBimrlAauA More rotation after impact: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R3DC-Ryx7RA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R3DC-Ryx7RA And more rotation->roll->stop off the road: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pY7xo61drg4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pY7xo61drg4 At the 2010 winter olympics a luge slider also illustrated this as he left the track and hit a series of uprights/bollards. He died, his body landing outside the track. Anyone standing there could have also been killed. Modern traffic safety is about keeping cars away from pedestrians during a crash. Smooth barriers without gaps keep the crashing vehicle on the road. Many are designed to redirect front wheels, literally stearing the vehicle back into the road and away from people. The goal is to slow everything gradually while keeping the crashing vehicle away from pedestrians. Barriers are even tied together in a big chain so that they can gain strength from each other, allowing very small/low barriers to redirect enormous vehicles. They might not look pretty, but they work. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=22mzoAkJJBQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=22mzoAkJJBQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j-HevN1bzbA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j-HevN1bzbA
- vvanders 8y agoAgreed, it's not as impressive as in person but I've always liked seeing the Cushman Powerhouse #2[1] when I drive 101. I feel like we should take pride in our infrastructure and making them architecturally attractive is a great way to do that. [1] https://olympicaerialsolutions.com/cms/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/DJI_0003_ed_wm_02_1600.jpg https://olympicaerialsolutions.com/cms/wp-content/uploads/20...
- MaxGabriel 8y agoThe link isn’t working for me—I get a Cloudflare error saying the site doesn’t allow hotlinking
- enra 8y agoI think in US culture there isn't generally much regard for taste or aesthetics for some reason. You can see in cities, public places, transport, offices, people's homes, clothing, packaging. Aesthetics or function is either not considered at all, or done with a horrible taste (think most airports, government offices). In general, at least in Northern Europe, we have beautiful well kept and functioning cities, libraries and I think it's some kind pride or attitude in the culture, that while things are necessary, they can be also be beautiful, it doesn't necessarily have to cost more.
- erikpukinskis 8y agoThis is so wrong. America is full of beauty, and many have great taste. Maybe America is not to your taste.
- DmenshunlAnlsis 8y agoHe didn’t say that America wasn’t beautiful, he was talking specifically about American cities. There are some beautiful parts of some American cities, but I think the general criticism is fair. I think it just so happens that the same is true of most cities around the world too. There are beautiful parts of Paris, London, Athens, St. Petersburg etc, but also large gray, dirty, ugly parts. It’s right to point out that large parts of many cities are dirty and ugly, but unfair to single out America as being uniquely culpable in creating such spaces. It’s also unfair to compare the the nicest parts of Amsterdam with the worst parts of SF, just as it’s unfair to compare the nicest parts of Boston with the worst of Mumbai. What America is full of is natural beauty, but generally outside of the cities. From sweeping desserts to warm beaches and deep forests, they have it all, and it really is beautiful. Northern Europe is lovely too, but it’s also small, far from densely populated, and homogenous. America is vast and varied, and if we’re talking about the whole continent it has everything from glaciers to rainforests.
- lifeformed 8y agoI don't think it's America specifically, I think it's just all newer parts of cities. Old parts of cities are nice because the ugly parts have been torn down and only the nice buildings remain. The ugly parts of otherwise nice cities tend to be the stuff from the past century that hasn't died off yet. America is pretty young and grew a ton in the past century, so there's still a ton of 50's era mass-produced architecture and car-centric civic designs. They're not old enough to need replacing yet. I don't think those will stand the test of time, but there's still some gems in there that I hope to see persist. I think we just need more time for the cities to evolve.
- erikpukinskis 8y ago> It seems like some theory that doing anything beyond the functional minimum is a waste of the taxpayer's money No, I don’t think that’s the cause. The cause is that we are in a period of financial intermediation. Every sip of coffee, every home construction, every dentists office needs to be a financial instrument, easily tracked so that the markets can be made. Essentially: as long as every endeavor is a private money-making endeavor, we can only do one thing at a time. How would you even do the accounting on some sort of pedestrian walkway that both covered your liability and provided a public right of way? That’s some sort of public/private partnership... how would you short something like that? Integrated systems are not amenable to finance so we have to wait. In a few years we might have software that could efficiently underwrite multi-purpose projects like that, but it’s just not possible on today’s markets.
- aaron695 8y agoI'll call you on this. I'd be willing to bet more government buildings are architecturally designed than ever before. Certainly in general private buildings are getting designed more then before. Art in public across the world is on the increase everywhere I've been. I'd need clarification on what you mean.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]