3 ms·
What I don't get, why the complicated design to assemble the blocks into stacks? This seems to add a lot of non-essential complexity: Now you need cranes, a hoo
by xg15 8y ago
What I don't get, why the complicated design to assemble the blocks into stacks? This seems to add a lot of non-essential complexity: Now you need cranes, a hooking/unhooking mechanism (that seems to even require cameras and image recognition!), the ability to move blocks horizontally and lots of computing power to coordinate the whole thing.
Even more, the up-front cost to recover energy is higher because you need to lift the blocks from the stacks before you can drop them.
Why not simply use a fixed hook/rope/motor/generator assembly per concrete block? Or, if there are too many blocks for that, use a hydraulic system? (But then again, what is the advantage of using many small blocks instead of a few large ones?)
Nothing against the company - the idea is awesome - but it seems weird that almost all the advertised innovations are solutions to problems that wouldn't exist without the "put the blocks into stacks" design:
>The innovation in Energy Vault’s plant is not the hardware. Cranes and motors have been around for decades, and companies like ABB and Siemens have optimized them for maximum efficiency. The round-trip efficiency of the system, which is the amount of energy recovered for every unit of energy used to lift the blocks, is about 85%—comparable to lithium-ion batteries which offer upto 90%.
Pedretti’s main work as the chief technology officer has been figuring out how to design software to automate contextually relevant operations, like hooking and unhooking concrete blocks, and to counteract pendulum-like movements during the lifting and lowering of those blocks.
(Not counting the described innovation of finding a new mixture that includes waste and reduces the amount of cement needed.)
- becasuretarded 8y agoBecause a single crane can move blocks in a r^2 * Pi area. (7.5m)^2 * 3.14 = 176.62m^2 Your little cuck lift per block idea doesn't work out. Let's say you have a giant 8m * 8m block per lift. You'd still only have 64m^2 capacity. The entire idea of a gravity battery is already infeasable from the start and this crane idea makes it a little more feasable but for some reason people like you just want to make it impossible again.
- ubercow13 8y agoThe tower in the video looks like it contains hundreds of these blocks. You would therefore need hundreds of assemblies to do it that way, and each one has to lift the same weight that the crane is lifting. All of this to save on the cost of making the crane complex enough to move about, and the cost of the software involved.
- xg15 8y agoBut what is the advantage of having a large number of small vs a small number of large blocks?
- surrealize 8y agoIn the system you envision without stacking, are all of the large blocks suspended from the crane simultaneously when the system is fully "charged"? That would require the crane to support a much higher max load.