2 ms·
Retractions aren't issued just for falsifying data. Each field has its own culture of retracting papers, some only retracting deliberate fraud (each one with a
by whatshisface 8y ago
Retractions aren't issued just for falsifying data. Each field has its own culture of retracting papers, some only retracting deliberate fraud (each one with a different standard of evidence), and others retracting mistakes as well. It is also well-known that certain countries contribute more than others to scientific fraud - and it would be unlikely for them to all have exactly the same gender ratio. By the time all of these factors (along with whatever else can be thought of) are included there might be a lot less statistical significance left than we started with.
- et2o 8y agoThe retractions of people on this top 30 list are generally for falsifying data, severe plagiarism, or other misbehavior which would fall into the category of deliberate fraud. I don't disagree that the rate of misbehavior and gender balance of scientists differ internationally and would ideally be factored into an analysis.