3 ms·
I know the majority of those who read that study will either ignore it, dismiss it out of hand, or "study it carefully" and find all sorts of problems with it,
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
I know the majority of those who read that study will either ignore it,
dismiss it out of hand, or "study it carefully" and find all sorts of problems
with it, the best to convince themselves that it's not conclusive, or that
it's badly designed and its results can't be trusted, etc.
The truth is, it is extremely hard to accept that something that directly hits
your fabled pleasure centers -like fat, sugar, salt, nicotine, alcohol etc- is
so bad for you it's decreasing the time you have to enjoy it. There is an
extreme form of denial that seizes the human mind when someone tells you "this
thing you really like, it's very bad for you".
Our pleasures are immense sources of bias. Take what your heart
desires with, um, a huge pinch of salt and don't listen to the people who tell
you salt, fat, sugar, smoking, drinking etc are good for you when this
contradicts years of research and hundreds of trials, especialy when the
evidence for keeping your dietary habits unchanged is based on a couple of
studies with poor practices and few participants.
- nonbel 8y agoSorry, but there is really no debate about this study. Their definition of "low-carb" is not the one used by people who are adopting a "low carb" diet, so there is no reason to think their conclusions apply.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoI think "the people who adopt a low-card diet" would do well to pay attention to a study that reports increased mortality for people who reduced their carbohydrate intake less than they have. If a moderate reduction of carbohydrates in your diet is bad for you, almost entirely eliminating them does not look very promising.
- nonbel 8y ago>"If a moderate reduction of carbohydrates in your diet is bad for you, almost entirely eliminating them does not look very promising." Why?
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoAccording to the study, because minimal risk was observed at 50-55% carbohydrate intake. So extreme consumption on either end can't be very close to the minimum.
- nonbel 8y ago>"According to the study, because minimal risk was observed at 50-55% carbohydrate intake. So extreme consumption on either end can't be very close to the minimum." Your conclusion does not follow from the premise, so there are some additional assumptions you are making somewhere.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> Your conclusion does not follow from the premise (...) Why not?
- nonbel 8y agoBecause you have provided no reason that it is reasonable to extrapolate the trend from a 50% to 40% carb diet to 5% carb diet.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoI think it's reasonable to expect that if a small reduction is bad, a big reduction is worse. The opposite is not impossible, but it would be surprising.
- nonbel 8y ago>"I think it's reasonable to expect that if a small reduction is bad, a big reduction is worse." As I originally asked: why?
- 8y ago