7 ms·
Should Rivers Have Rights? A Growing Movement Says It’s Time
- redahs 8y ago> Chile’s Water Code was established during the Pinochet dictatorship, and still treats water as a replenishable (rather than increasingly scarce) natural resource. Under the code, companies may trade water rights to the highest bidder If there's a bidding process already in place, the Chilean government can charge companies the bid value annually as a public natural resource rent, and place the tax revenues in a permanent fund for conversation efforts. Instead of calling a river a legal person, a formal government charted corporation can be created for the river to distribute revenues from taxes on water right holders in a pro-social manner. This would be somewhat similar to 'Cap and Dividend' proposal for climate change.
- xigma 8y agoIf a river becomes a legal person, the government can prosecute it for crossing some threshold. The sentence will be forced labor in a dam for 100 years. The duration may sound harsh, but rivers outlive humans by a long margin.
- warent 8y agoIsn't there some adage that it's not possible to step in the same river twice?
- xigma 8y agoNot according to my grandfather, whose axe had its blade and handle replaced three times each.
- schiffern 8y agoWe managed to avoid silly things like this while making corporations "legal people." I see no reason that legal theorists should be selectively incompetent here. Don't get caught up on the word "river," which is just a specific example. The general case is "ecosystem."
- kazoolist 8y agoThe concept behind corporations as "people" is that people don't lose rights just because they are engaging in their right of free association. The corporate entity only "has rights" because it is a collection of people, and those people have rights. Ecosystems aren't collections of people.
- schiffern 8y ago>Ecosystems aren't collections of people. Is the implication here that "only people have rights," therefore ecosystems shouldn't? Correct me if mistaken. To clarify, I wasn't arguing that ecosystems have rights because corporations do. This is indeed the status quo, but it's hardly immutable. Consider that 200 years ago neither women nor slaves were considered legal persons. Restating the status quo isn't an argument in its favor.
- rayiner 8y agoCorporations are legal entities composed of people, so it makes sense to treat that the aggregate would have similar rights as the individual. When we say a corporation has the right to free speech, we mean that you cannot restrict the right of people just because they’re acting together through a corporation. Rivers, of course, are not people nor are they composed of people. Nor are ecosystems. People might be affected by, for example, what happens to a river. All of this legal wrangling over river personhood is an attempt to avoid having to show that effect.
- pfdietz 8y agoCorporations are a weird kind of person, in that it's perfectly legal to murder them and sell their parts.
- schiffern 8y ago> Nor are ecosystems [composed of people]. Isn't that definition exactly the problem? An ecologist would disagree of course, but how curious that every other species is considered part of the ecosystem, but we are not! We're subject to all the same ecological laws. The humanity vs. nature separateness is of course entirely invented. But it's built into our very language: consider the other-ing effect of the term "environment" for instance. > All of this legal wrangling over river personhood is an attempt to avoid having to show that effect. You have it flipped around. The legal wrangling is almost entirely on the part of polluters seeking to avoid accountability (to great success, I might add). It helps that the 'environmental regulations' are written by the polluting industries themselves. They use poorly characterized mass flows through the environment (there's that word again) and pollution etiologies (often "poorly characterized" because the company covered up its toxicity research, eg PCBs) like a cryptocurrency tumbler, laundering away their own liability for poisoning their neighbors. It's unconscionable.
- arethuza 8y agoRivers can be amazingly old - far older, in some cases, than the mountains they cut through or the oceans into which they flow: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_rivers_by_age https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_rivers_by_age The idea that the Congo and the Amazon were once the same river before the Atlantic and the Andes existed is one of my favourites for a bit of geological sensawunda.
- mrec 8y agoThat's awesome. Particularly the idea that the Amazon, the biggest river (by discharge volume) on the planet, once changed direction.
- delbel 8y agoNo
- humanrebar 8y agoIf fetuses aren't legal "persons", I don't see why rivers should be. And if we're upset about corporate personhood, then why does it make sense to pretend other things are people? Edit: I don't know why this post is flaggable. What counts as a person is exactly the subject and I didn't use insulting or bigoted language.
- DanielGee 8y agoNo. This is as silly as vegans saying animals deserve the same rights as humans because we are animals too. Does that mean we have to prosecute a lion that kills a wildebeest? Or what happens when my dog kills a rodent or a cat kills a bird? Should they be imprisoned? If rivers have rights does it also has responsibility and culpability? What happens if a river overflows and few people drown? Do we punish the river? A question in the title aside, I love the advocacy embedded in the title. "A growing movement"? From what to what? 2 to 3 people? The article is trying to grow the movement, it isn't reporting on a growing movement. The only way to give rivers rights is to give it personhood rights in the same vein as corporations. But that means that rivers become privately owned entities. Do we want rivers to be owned by shareholders? Rivers, like animals, are natural resources. Nations and states are stewards of it.
- ben509 8y ago> If rivers have rights does it also has responsibility and culpability? I think that question is key to understanding what rights are and how they function in the constitution of a polity. Animals, rivers, etc. don't interact with us in the way other humans do. There may be analogous aspects to that interaction, so we can recognize that we have a responsibility to keep rivers clean, but that's an obligation on our part, not a "right" that the river has.
- eatitraw 8y ago> Should they be imprisoned? No, because other animals don't have mental capacity to truly understand the consequences of their action. That said, I've never really seen a consistent argument against _protecting_ prey animals from lions (and letting lions die out).
- jpindar 8y agoWhen deer don't have predators (of whatever species) they overpopulate and die of starvation or of running in front of vehicles. I'm not convinced that dying of starvation is better than a sudden death. The vehicle accidents harm humans as well as the deer. The hungry deer damage crops and gardens. I think the overpopulation also causes the spread of parasites (ticks etc.) which carry disease.
- schiffern 8y agoI never understood this concept (always stuck me as 'woo') until I watched this video by award-winning environmental lawyer Thomas Linzey. I won't try to paraphrase since it would leave so much out. https://www.linktv.org/shows/thomas-linzey-earth-at-risk-2014/episodes/earth-at-risk-thomas-linzey https://www.linktv.org/shows/thomas-linzey-earth-at-risk-201...
- pier25 8y agoSo what happened after 2014?
- xalava 8y agoWe worked on a concept based on this idea a couple of years ago, at the highest of DAOs and Smart Contracts hype. There is already the possibility to create environmental protection non-profits for a specific area. In France, and other countries, it gives you the right to participate in lawsuit and even collect reparation for ecological prejudice (https://www.euractiv.com/section/climate-environment/news/erika-oil-slick-trial-sets-ecological-prejudice-precedent/ https://www.euractiv.com/section/climate-environment/news/er.... You can't however sue on behalf of the river's endangered interests. Giving legal personnality doesn't necessarily change the law as the article implies but change the way the law works. Our concept was to add 'economic personnality'. Natural resources such as a river would have a cryptoasset account collectively managed by donors. "Gardeners" are local people hired by this collective to execute maintenance tasks, or lawsuits, while this board of donors oversee the management of the founds. Compared to a local non-profit, you gain easy internationalisation of donors and more transparency on funds allocation, potentially avoiding corruption. The key is in the governance rules. As pointed in the article, it is extremely difficult to represent fairly and combine populations' interests and environment protection at the local, national and worldwide levels. A visual demo can be seen here http://forest.lesusineslouise.com/ http://forest.lesusineslouise.com/
- schiffern 8y agoYou're solving the wrong problem. That's just an inefficient, roundabout way to manage a environmental legal defense team (will lawyers accept crypto-Monopoly money?). But such legal defenses are actually quite ineffective (by design!) at preventing ecological harm, even when they win the lawsuit.[1] [1] https://www.linktv.org/shows/thomas-linzey-earth-at-risk-2014/episodes/earth-at-risk-thomas-linzey https://www.linktv.org/shows/thomas-linzey-earth-at-risk-201...
- xalava 8y agoI beg to differ. Exactly as shown your video, environmental protection is currently mainly led as an element of public policy. Hence, when it conflicts with economic and individuals' interests there is not much weight to preserve regulations and budgets. The approach taken in recent years consist in creating or empowering an entity to represent of those interests. The more legitimate and the more economically robust is this entity, the more difficult it will be to act against its interests. It is imperfect, but I think that this approach should be explored when existing regulations consistently fail
- __m 8y agoSo this provides some legal framework to handle questions regarding environmental impacts of human activities? Is it really that difficult to implement laws that protect rivers without engaging in a debate whether a river can hold rights? Opponents will have a field trip ridiculing the argument distracting from the goal of protecting the environment.
- rayiner 8y agoThe article is really out to lunch from a legal point of view. > Western legal systems and governments traditionally viewed water and water rights as property, leading to overuse and contamination That’s exactly the opposite of what is true. At least English law has never treated water as property. In England, and most of the east and midwest of the US, riperian doctrines apply to water. (I’m going to leave out the west coast, which has a nutso way of doing things.) Common law riperian doctrine was strict: upstream property owners cannot impair the quality of water flowing through their land because downstream property owners have a right to unimpaired water quality. If we still did this, our rivers would be very clean! During the industrial revolution, the riperian doctrines were made looserc weakening the rights of downstream property owners. The problem is that we don’t treat water like property. We can pollute it freely because nobody can sue us for it. I live on a river, and we can’t swim after a heavy rain because of all the crap washed into the river from upstream farms. If I had property rights in the water, I could sue those farmers, and the price of food would rise to reflect the externalities of farming. But we treat water as a commons, where no individual has enforceable property rights.
- petermcneeley 8y ago"If I had property rights in the water, I could sue those farmers" What I love about libertarians is that they are forever optimist about their place in the future social order.
- mmirate 8y agoIf water property rights were more explicit and the OP didn't gain property rights in the water as part of his/her house purchase, then the house's purchase price would have had to be much, much cheaper than it doubtless was.
- petermcneeley 8y agoRight but this change occurred during the industrial revolution and also is sanctioned by the court. So either the house was purchased pre industrial revolution (so part of a historical context) or more recently. If it was purchased more recently then OP did pay for the new version of the water rights not the old ones. Second OP seems to think that the courts would settle in his favor but the very court that would do this is also the court that has weakened the water rights down stream. My original comment is simply a recognition of the pattern in which Libertarians tend to naively see a future of property and civil suits as ending up with them in the favorable position. Have I addressed your response?
- gruez 8y agothis idea -the concept of treating nature as a legal entity and awarding them damages to protect the environment- isn't new. see: "should trees have standing"[1]. [1] https://iseethics.files.wordpress.com/2013/02/stone-christopher-d-should-trees-have-standing.pdf https://iseethics.files.wordpress.com/2013/02/stone-christop...
- furbyhat 8y agoNo one takes as good care of property as well as the owner. We are sering polluted rivers because they are not owned privately and instead taken forcibly from the homesteaders by coercive and violent rulers.
- pwaai 8y agobut a river is not an animal or human.....