2 ms·
> clearly incoherent "speech is powerful enough to cure social ills, but cannot inflict as much damage as a fist." There is nothing incoherent about this, exce
by mpweiher 8y ago
> clearly incoherent "speech is powerful enough to cure social ills, but cannot inflict as much damage as a fist."
There is nothing incoherent about this, except your mischaracterization.
The fist inflicts. Speech does not inflict, it informs, entices and incites. And when it incites it can already be regulated. Yes, there are involuntary aspects of speech processing, but these are not generally and certainly not immediately harmful. For speech to be powerful it requires the consent/cooperation of the spoken-to. The fist does not.
So you are constructing a straw man out of logical incoherence and then having a big old fight with it.
Have fun!
- jeromebaek 8y ago> For speech to be powerful it requires the consent/cooperation of the spoken-to This is where you are wrong. You already admitted that there are involuntary aspects of speech processing, and this is a step in the right direction. Your mistake is dismissing how powerful these involuntary aspects are, and this mistake probably stems from your irrational faith in human agency despite all odds.
- mpweiher 8y agoIt's not an "irrational faith", but a simple fact that without a human acting on those words, they have little to no effect.