3 ms·
> fallacy .. and speech float in the ether. No, speech is transmitted by the movement of air molecules. And the movement of these air molecules typically does
by mpweiher 8y ago
> fallacy .. and speech float in the ether.
No, speech is transmitted by the movement of air molecules. And the movement of these air molecules typically does no damage, unless amplified to absurd pressure levels.
> harms the body
Nope. A "cutting" comment produces no incisions in the body. I think you are also confusing "harms the body" with "feels like pain". There are studies that show that, for example, social exclusion produces a pain sensation in the brain that is hard to distinguish from physically caused pain.
However, that's not the same, just because there is a pain sensation as if you were physically harmed does not mean you were physically harmed. And no, the pain sensation is not the same as the actual physical harm. And yes, long-term cortisol exposure will cause negative effects on the body, but again not everything that causes harm is violence.
If I give you wrong directions, I am causing you harm, but that doesn't mean my directions are violence. If I drop a banana peel and you slip on it, that causes you harm, but it is not violence. The sun causes you harm, but the sun is not violence.
- jeromebaek 8y ago> speech is transmitted by the movement of air molecules Under this definition of "speech" English, which I understand, and Chinese, which I don't, would have the same effect on me. But of course they don't. When somebody speaks in English or another language I understand, I have no choice but to hear it, not as noise, but as meaning, as sensations and memories activated in my brain and body. Since you're German you probably like Kant. Korsgaard is a Kantian philosopher at Harvard: "If I say to you, “Picture a yellow spot!” you will. What exactly is happening? Are you simply cooperating with me? No, because at least without a certain active resistance you will not be able to help it. Is it a causal connection then? No, or at least not merely that, for if you picture a pink spot you will be mistaken, wrong. Causal connections cannot be wrong. What kind of necessity is this, both normative and compulsive? It is obligation. " https://tannerlectures.utah.edu/_documents/a-to-z/k/korsgaard94.pdf https://tannerlectures.utah.edu/_documents/a-to-z/k/korsgaar... p.78
- mpweiher 8y ago> would have the same effect on me What on earth leads you to make such a fallacious statement? > no choice but to hear it Sort of. You can wear ear-protection, turn on the music of your headphones, but overall it is arguably a bug of our physiology that we cannot close our ears the same way we can close our eyes. > If I say to you, “Picture a yellow spot!” you will. No, not necessarily. Also, this is not because speech is a command, but because we interpret speech automatically. So if I tell you "Whatever you do, do not picture a pink elephant", you will nevertheless think of a pink elephant, counter to the command I gave you. And of course, if I say "Jump off the bridge", you will probably not do so, because, again, it's not that speech is a command, but that we interpret speech more or less automatically. Anyway, no idea what any of this has to do with the question of whether speech is violence. > Since you're German you probably like Kant. Stereotype much?
- jeromebaek 8y ago> No, not necessarily. Also, this is not because speech is a command, but because we interpret speech automatically. So if I tell you "Whatever you do, do not picture a pink elephant", you will nevertheless think of a pink elephant, counter to the command I gave you. Very good, you almost grasped my point. In fact you even managed to produce spontaneously one of the most famous examples of this principle by the great philosopher George Lakoff (read "Don't Think of an Elephant!", which was used for Clinton's campaign) > we interpret speech more or less automatically This is more or less my point. Speech is interpreted automatically: it is not a choice to interpret it, or not. In cases of drastic power imbalance -- again, for example, parental emotional abuse of child -- the person on the receiving end of "violent speech" has no choice to not interpret whatever hate and bigotry the speech consists of. So "free speech" ends up encroaching on others' freedom: again, the listeners have no choice but to have their semantic lightbulbs activated. Sometimes, ironically, the belief that humans can always make choices, ends up creating less choices for humans.. > Stereotype much? :)
- mpweiher 8y ago> you almost grasped my point. In fact you even managed to produce spontaneously one of the most famous examples of this principle Hmm...try to think for a second. Which do you think is more likely: (a) that I "spontaneously" produced this famous example, or (b) that I am actually quite familiar with the field in general and Lakoff's work in particular, for example by having studied linguistics? Hmmm... Rest assured that I disagree with you not out of ignorance of the point you are trying to make, but by knowing the point quite well and disagreeing with it, because it is incoherent. As I explained before, you are combining two very distinct things, first the more or less autonomous speech processing that we do and second the longer term effects, positive and negative. These two are not the same at all.
- jeromebaek 8y ago> I think you are also confusing "harms the body" with "feels like pain" Nope, wrong again. I am talking about cases where abusive speech is systematic, unescapable, and occurring in the context of a drastic power imbalance. Parental child abuse, for example. I can point you to countless studies where parental child abuse leads to physically harmed bodies, harm here consisting of chronic unmitigated pain, autoimmune disorders, even brain tumors. For a start, try "The Body Keeps the Score" by Bessel van der Kolk
- mpweiher 8y agoYes, and I clearly wrote to that, but points for completely ignoring what I wrote and instead arguing against more straw-men you constructed.
- jeromebaek 8y ago> just because there is a pain sensation as if you were physically harmed does not mean you were physically harmed. ... long-term cortisol exposure will cause negative effects on the body, but again not everything that causes harm is violence. > If I drop a banana peel and you slip on it, that causes you harm, but it is not violence. This part of your reply was too silly to even warrant a reply. You are the one setting up a straw man. The article does not say (nor do I): "speech causes harm, if x causes harm, x is violence, therefore speech is violence", which is what you are arguing ("not everything that causes harm is violence"). Violence, obviously, is meaningless unless there is some person behind the violent act. This is why your silly sentence "bananas are literally violence" is incoherent: you are confusing an act (speech) with a thing (banana). You are constructing a meta-straw-man by construing me as a straw-man construer.