3 ms·
> These key tropes—“we will not tolerate” and “this is not a debate”—are now frequently deployed to curtail discussion of issues deemed to be taboo, invariably
by mschuster91 8y ago
> These key tropes—“we will not tolerate” and “this is not a debate”—are now frequently deployed to curtail discussion of issues deemed to be taboo, invariably to “protect” people deemed vulnerable from speech deemed hateful.
The point is that denying trans people (for example, as they're targeted the worst by both rightwingers, "centrists" and some lefties aka trans-exclusionary radical feminists) the right to choosing freedom over their bodies is a direct attack on their basic human right to exist. Either one supports letting trans people live in peace or one does not - and the latter position is directly and actively intolerable in a society that calls itself "civilized" and "respecting human rights".
There is no valid position in any society that denies a group of people the right to exist. We had that already with the Nazi regime and with Stalin's Soviet Union, no need to repeat history again.
- mpweiher 8y agoPure hyperbole. Nobody is denying their right to exist.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mschuster91 8y agoA couple days ago "concerned parents" literally declared "hunting season" on a 12-year old child: http://www.towleroad.com/2018/08/hunting-season/ http://www.towleroad.com/2018/08/hunting-season/ This is reality, there's a reason why suicide and self harm ratios are enormous among LGBT, especially youth.
- mpweiher 8y agoWhile I find the actions of these parents despicable, they do not constitute "denying the right to exist".
- jeromebaek 8y agoWhat else denies the right of someone to exist, other than threats to physically mutilate and kill? Do you think the child has a soul separate from the body that the parents won't be able to touch? Do you think the child has a clean innocent soul that's immune to harm?
- mpweiher 8y agoI did not see a threat to kill. The "knife" comment was a crude, terribly crude, reference to a "transitioning" operation. Again, I am not condoning the crude language and possible actions, but among those I don't see "denying the right to exist". Objecting to use of bathrooms is not denying the right to exist.
- jeromebaek 8y ago> The "knife" comment was ... reference to a "transitioning" operation Just because you dress up violent language in multisyllabic official-sounding words like "transitioning operation" doesn't mean the violence of the language disappears.
- mpweiher 8y ago>> > The "knife" comment was ... reference to a "transitioning" operation The ellipsis: "crude, terribly crude," If the only way you can make your points is by egregious selective quoting, maybe you should reconsider those points. Anyway, I've already stated that I find the language not just crude but also despicable. While I think it is rather obviously over-the-top hyperbole it could also in my mind (no legal expert) rise to the level of incitement to violence, and of course the language is violent, though not "violence". None of it is "denying the right to exist", which again, does not mean it is not completely wrong and despicable.
- jeromebaek 8y agoThe ellipsis doesn't matter, because whatever reservations you may have about the comment, your final verdict is that it is harmless. I don't care whatever reservations you have. They only serve to make your position seem more palatable when in fact what matters isn't your reservations, it's your conclusion. And your conclusion is wrong. Maybe you are misguiding yourself with softening language like "crude, terribly crude" to lead you to a conclusion you realize is wrong, immoral.