8 ms·
> Food stamps (EBT) are a good program. You can use them to buy the same food from the same stores as anybody else and you get to decide what to spend it on. F
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> Food stamps (EBT) are a good program. You can use them to buy the same food from the same stores as anybody else and you get to decide what to spend it on.
Food stamps tend to suck for a lot of the same reasons food pantries do. You're still telling people what to buy. It's not as bad because there are more choices, but it's still the same general problem where you have a bureaucracy telling you what to buy instead of being able to buy what you need the most like anybody else.
Sometimes what you really need is food. Sometimes -- or some specific days -- you have access to food and what you really need is to save up enough for a working car or gas to put in it so you can go to job interviews. Or something else that the person in question knows they need but arbitrary politicians have no way to predict.
But if you give people food stamps, they'll buy food with it. Even if they already have suitable food, because it's free money that can only be used for one thing. Then it costs the taxpayer $1 and provides the person with $.05 worth of value, which they take because $.05 is more than $0.
Meanwhile just giving the person $1 cash would give the person $1 in value and cost the government less, because then it isn't necessary to administer a system to force people to buy the thing they needed less instead of the thing they needed more.
And eliminating that bureaucracy reduces the Shirky principle problem.
- skrebbel 8y agoYou didn't at all consider the reason why food stamps might exist in the first place. I don't know anything about them, but I'd assume it has something to do with a correlation between homelessness and life problems that make financial discipline extra hard (eg addictions). I'm not trying to imply that all homeless people are addicts (quite the contrary) but if I'm a crack addict and you give me money I'm not sure I'd be using it to save it up for buying a car one day.
- grenoire 8y agoGood point and it's an active concern in development economics. Most often giving people cash will lead them to either use it for not-food (incl. things that are outright detrimental to their wellbeing), or to get low-nutrition (and high-energy) food such as snacks or soda. Not quite desirable either way.
- ada1981 8y agoIs this true? I’ve seen a number of studies, reports, NGOs, etc. advocating for giving cash directly vs. inkind donations. https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2017/08/07/541609649/how-to-fix-poverty-why-not-just-give-people-money https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2017/08/07/5416096... https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2015/09/welfare-reform-direct-cash-poor/407236/ https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2015/09/we... https://www.vox.com/2016/1/23/10810978/cash-transfer-givedirectly-spillover https://www.vox.com/2016/1/23/10810978/cash-transfer-givedir...
- burkaman 8y agoBut if I give you food stamps, you could just sell them and buy crack. Is there any reason to believe food stamps help solve the problem you're describing?
- shadowmint 8y agoI think the problem is more complex than you're bothering to give it credit. For example, food stamps may go to a family, where they are dealt with responsibly, in a way that money, which is very easy to grab and walk out to buy cigarettes with when things go badly, is not. Obviously, it's not a full solution, and a cynical recipient could sell them, true... but we're not talking about individuals acting in isolation for purely selfish reasons; that's a contrived subset of the problem. What's the alternative you're proposing? Just hand out cash? The research shows that people suffer severe difficulty in managing fiscal matters when under financial stress. It's the old 'why do people who are poor buy so many lottery tickets?'? Money isn't the correct solution; and maybe food stamps aren't either... but they're a better solution, and don't think that's even in doubt. ...but if you have a different one, I'm happy to hear it.
- cam_l 8y ago"why do people who are poor buy so many lottery tickets?" Answer, all people buy lottery tickets at the same rate for tickets which might materially change their life. If you are rich, spending 20 bucks for a 1 in a million chance to win 10k is not going seem worthwhile. The problem food stamps are solving is to keep a lid on the brow beating from taxpayers toward the poor. It is a mild form of punishment masquerading as help. It would be cheaper, easier, and more effective to just give cash (and because it would be cheaper, you could give more). The main issue poor people have in managing money, is simply that they do not have enough.
- jlawson 8y agoAnd that they'll do things like spend their last penny to get the latest iPhone, or on buy $400 sneakers. Or if they inherit 50k, immediately go to Vegas and lose it all. These are all real examples I've known personally. The people you're describing exist but it's hard to imagine someone who is great with money staying poor for years and years, considering almost everyone in America moves between income quintiles during their life and most spend time at the top. If free food is punishment please sign me up to be punished. Also, I'm interested in the source for your lottery ticket info. It sounds fairly absurd in a world where many jackpots are over 5 million, which is enough to change almost anyone's life. I've never even heard of a lottery for 10k.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> You didn't at all consider the reason why food stamps might exist in the first place. I don't know anything about them, but I'd assume it has something to do with a correlation between homelessness and life problems that make financial discipline extra hard (eg addictions). I wouldn't assume that, since food stamps aren't particularly focussed on the homeless. In fact, the original purpose of the food stamp program was clearing agricultural surpluses (hence why the program was created in the Department of Agriculture and not the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare where you would have expected it to be if it were a welfare program and not an ag industry support program); you originally had to purchase food stamps, and for every dollar you got $1 of unrestricted (but still only for food) stamps, and $0.50 of restrictes-to-items-deemed-to-be-in-surplus stamps. The exact restrictions and mechanisms changed over time in subsequent iterations of the program (and it's hard to find a clear purpose for many changes because lots were compromises between competing visions with fundamentally opposed goals.)
- ada1981 8y agoIf your a crack addict, you’ll prob sell your food stamps or the food you bought to get crack. Unprocessed trauma coping circuits (aka addiction) highjacks intelligence to get the dopamine trigger, it doesn’t nessesarily eliminate intelligence.
- Broken_Hippo 8y agoTo be fair, folks will do the same if they need cigarettes or need to fix a car to get to work and back.
- ada1981 8y agoI agree. Folks will find a way to get their needs met. You don’t solve trauma with cash, but you also don’t make it worse and the benefits to others seem to be greater. A regulated nervous system is a need, and if someone never developed that capability and doesn’t have awareness or resources to develop it as an adult, it’s actually a pretty logical move to use drugs.
- 8y ago
- gumby 8y ago> I'm not trying to imply that all homeless people are addicts (quite the contrary) but if I'm a crack addict and you give me money I'm not sure I'd be using it to save it up for buying a car one day. Drug addicts make up a negligible percentage of people getting a helping hand. The statistics show this and it has been born out by the states that introduced drug testing for assistance recipients: they cost more to administer than the money saved by kicking people out of the assistance programs because the numbers are so tiny. Even in SF where it seems like all the crazy homeless people are strung out or tweaked, well, that's a sample problem: indeed many of the crazy ones are, but they are a minuscule, though highly visible, percentage of the people in need. If you're struggling to make ends meet you don't have time to take drugs. Whereas if you start out OK, become drug addled and fall out of the system, you probably by that time are too out of it to ask for help.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- zaroth 8y agoFood stamps don’t suck just because they don’t solve all your problems. Rather, they solve a baseline universal need, and they do it in an extremely attractive way which is even better than handing cash. A lot of people don’t realize that “food stamps” are just a debit card that you use to checkout at the supermarket, yes, even Whole Foods. There are some limits to what you can buy, but generally speaking if it’s unprepared food you can pay for it with the food stamp debit card. I was on food stamps for a short while. While the value of the balance wasn’t literally cash, it was equivalent because I was spending at least that much on groceries anyway. You can also carry a balance forward from month-to-month so there’s never a need to spend it down wastefully. It’s only about $100/person/month so it’s never too much for just food. Food stamps have low administrative overhead and low levels of fraud. It’s a government program I have very few gripes about, which is indeed saying something. And it’s not a small program either, around $100B per year (less in the last couple years due to very strong employment numbers).
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y ago$100 / person / month. $100B a year cost. 100,000,000,000 / 12 = would feed one person for 8.3B years. Or a billion people for 8.3 years. You can see where this is going. $100B should be able to feed one hundred million people for 83.3 years. Assuming $100 / month could feed a person. You can buy a lot of lentils, rice, and potatoes with $100. But you're saying food stamps costs $100B a year. Where is all this money going?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- justinsb 8y agoI believe you forgot to divide by the $100
- evan_ 8y ago(I posted this before but made a mistake in the math, I think this is right now.) The latest numbers in Wikipedia say that SNAP costs $70.9B and distributes an average of $125/month to 44.2M people. That means the cost is $133 to distribute $125, or an overhead of $8 per person per month. Still not great but not nearly as bad as I was expecting, to be honest.
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> But if you give people food stamps, they'll buy food with it. Even if they already have suitable food, because it's free money that can only be used for one thing. Well, no. A lot of them will sell the food stamps at a discount to people who do want food, but would like to pay a little less for it. The poor person gets money and so does the grocery shopper.
- gamblor956 8y agoA lot of commenters are focused on the reselling of food stamps... They're not physical stamps anymore and haven't been for at least a decade. It's a debit card that gets money deposited monthly. You can't sell the money without selling the card and your future access to the money going to the card. In other words, the fraud you're all worried about has already been addressed.
- thaumasiotes 8y agoYou can easily sell the money without selling the card. You just need to ask what people want, and buy it for them.
- solatic 8y agoThere are two basic ways to provide funding, either you force people to ask for it and deal with a long approval process, or you trust them with it in the beginning and subject them to an audit process. Approval processes suck because they take too long and the bureaucracy stunts your ability to react to changing conditions, which is why most private sector companies use audit processes internally. And even though the public sector incurs real costs due to an approval process (you're not just paying the salaries of the overview bureaucrats, but also the salaries of the project workers who need to sit around and wait for funding to come in), it persists because it is viewed as more legitimate and more protective of legitimacy. If you ask the public whether they would prefer for a public program to cost $100 million, including $20 million which ended up being embezzled into private pockets, or $150 million spent entirely legitimately, most members of the public would rather spend the $150 million for a legitimate program, even if you could show them how the additional taxes needed directly affected their personal bottom lines. The reason why we don't give poor people cash directly is simple: even if 99%+ of beneficiaries will use the money responsibly, a tiny minority will not. That tiny minority will get written up in the press, and the perceived unfairness will politically doom the program. How public money is spent is, unfortunately, important.
- sokoloff 8y agoAll the more reason to support $600/adult type of UBI, IMO.
- user5994461 8y agoSo rent can increase by $300.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoSo build more housing.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- guelo 8y agoMoney is fungible, not spending money on food means you might be able to spend some on gas. The advantage of food stamps over cash is that it helps overcome middle class voter's judgmental attitude towards the poor.
- fipple 8y agoYou’re not looking at this from the money supply side in a democratically chosen policy environment. I am a high taxpayer and I’d happily vote for increased EBT distributions at the expense of my own tax rate. I would not do the same for unrestricted money. I’d vote for even more if luxury foods were eliminated from EBT. There are many like me. I don’t want anyone to go hungry but I am also not volunteering my wallet at their discretion.
- noelsusman 8y agoGiving them cash would take fewer of your tax dollars to achieve the same goal.
- wool_gather 8y ago> if luxury foods were eliminated If someone who's dependent on EBT money is spending it on caviar and filet mignon, they're going to go hungry for most of the month. Restrictions just add administrative overhead without benefit. (They also make the program more paternalistic and potentially stigmatizing, but that's a different argument.)
- fipple 8y agoI’ve seen a person buying organic ribeye steaks with EBT. I assume they were not going hungry because they were morbidly obese. And paternalistic is fine with me, that means like a father which is what buying someone’s food is, really.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoAnecdata: I lost several dress sizes by eating things like organic beef. I have a medical condition that causes malabsorption. It is routinely treated with expensive prescription digestive enzymes, plus large amounts of prescription drugs. I'm a former military wife. Technically, I should be able to get the $100k/year or more worth of medical treatment I am supposed to need for free, at taxpayer expense. Eating right is vastly cheaper, saves all kinds of tax dollars and also gives me a hugely higher quality of life. Win/win/win. Does anybody thank me for doing the right thing here? No. Instead, I am frequently attacked for any number of reasons, some of which seem to be rooted in this idea that poor people aren't entitled to eat well, and their health be damned. You have no idea what that person's needs are. Being able to see that they weigh a lot and what they purchased on a particular day doesn't really give you enough information to know if they were spending wastefully on frivolous purchases or not on that day.