17 ms·
I spent nearly six years homeless. I ate at soup kitchens and got food from food banks for a small portion of that time. I grew up with a garden in the back ya
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
I spent nearly six years homeless. I ate at soup kitchens and got food from food banks for a small portion of that time.
I grew up with a garden in the back yard. My dad hunted and some of the meat on our table was squirrel and deer he killed. My mother cooked from scratch.
I'm used to eating well for relatively little money. Most of the food at soup kitchens and food pantries fails to meet my expectations for food quality.
Food stamps (EBT) are a good program. You can use them to buy the same food from the same stores as anybody else and you get to decide what to spend it on. (Though the program could use more funding. They tend to last only 3 weeks of the month.)
Soup kitchens and food pantries tend to suck, even the better ones.
I'm not saying we shouldn't provide compassionate support to anyone. I'm just saying some programs for doing so would be acceptable to people with middle class expectations and some wouldn't be. For many reasons, including germ control, we need to be shooting for programs that fit middle class sensibilities and not act like "beggars can't be choosers."
Furthermore, if you are homeless, you are living without a fridge. Produce doesn't keep well under those conditions. When I was around a lot of other homeless people for a time, it wasn't unusual for free produce to go to waste, in part for that reason. Some idiot would give a homeless person some giant bag of apples. They could eat a few of them before they rotted, but not all of them. Maybe they managed to give the rest away. Maybe they didn't.
Last, I have serious reservations about creating systems to serve the poor instead of creating systems to help them resolve their problems. Systems designed to serve the poor tend to actively keep poverty alive, a la the Shirky Principle:
"Institutions will try to preserve the problem to which they are the solution"
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clay_Shirky#Shirky_principle https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clay_Shirky#Shirky_principle
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Food stamps (EBT) are a good program. You can use them to buy the same food from the same stores as anybody else and you get to decide what to spend it on. Food stamps tend to suck for a lot of the same reasons food pantries do. You're still telling people what to buy. It's not as bad because there are more choices, but it's still the same general problem where you have a bureaucracy telling you what to buy instead of being able to buy what you need the most like anybody else. Sometimes what you really need is food. Sometimes -- or some specific days -- you have access to food and what you really need is to save up enough for a working car or gas to put in it so you can go to job interviews. Or something else that the person in question knows they need but arbitrary politicians have no way to predict. But if you give people food stamps, they'll buy food with it. Even if they already have suitable food, because it's free money that can only be used for one thing. Then it costs the taxpayer $1 and provides the person with $.05 worth of value, which they take because $.05 is more than $0. Meanwhile just giving the person $1 cash would give the person $1 in value and cost the government less, because then it isn't necessary to administer a system to force people to buy the thing they needed less instead of the thing they needed more. And eliminating that bureaucracy reduces the Shirky principle problem.
- skrebbel 8y agoYou didn't at all consider the reason why food stamps might exist in the first place. I don't know anything about them, but I'd assume it has something to do with a correlation between homelessness and life problems that make financial discipline extra hard (eg addictions). I'm not trying to imply that all homeless people are addicts (quite the contrary) but if I'm a crack addict and you give me money I'm not sure I'd be using it to save it up for buying a car one day.
- grenoire 8y agoGood point and it's an active concern in development economics. Most often giving people cash will lead them to either use it for not-food (incl. things that are outright detrimental to their wellbeing), or to get low-nutrition (and high-energy) food such as snacks or soda. Not quite desirable either way.
- ada1981 8y agoIs this true? I’ve seen a number of studies, reports, NGOs, etc. advocating for giving cash directly vs. inkind donations. https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2017/08/07/541609649/how-to-fix-poverty-why-not-just-give-people-money https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2017/08/07/5416096... https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2015/09/welfare-reform-direct-cash-poor/407236/ https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2015/09/we... https://www.vox.com/2016/1/23/10810978/cash-transfer-givedirectly-spillover https://www.vox.com/2016/1/23/10810978/cash-transfer-givedir...
- burkaman 8y agoBut if I give you food stamps, you could just sell them and buy crack. Is there any reason to believe food stamps help solve the problem you're describing?
- shadowmint 8y agoI think the problem is more complex than you're bothering to give it credit. For example, food stamps may go to a family, where they are dealt with responsibly, in a way that money, which is very easy to grab and walk out to buy cigarettes with when things go badly, is not. Obviously, it's not a full solution, and a cynical recipient could sell them, true... but we're not talking about individuals acting in isolation for purely selfish reasons; that's a contrived subset of the problem. What's the alternative you're proposing? Just hand out cash? The research shows that people suffer severe difficulty in managing fiscal matters when under financial stress. It's the old 'why do people who are poor buy so many lottery tickets?'? Money isn't the correct solution; and maybe food stamps aren't either... but they're a better solution, and don't think that's even in doubt. ...but if you have a different one, I'm happy to hear it.
- modells 8y agoAs a rubber tramp, I have EBT/SNAP (for the next 2-3 months until the Republicans take it away), 2 propane burners and Costco but no fridge (it needs servicing). It’s often buy fresh as-needed, which is expensive, or buy things that keep like protein bars and bag of rice/lentil/quinoa. Giving homeless people canned goods is a waste because they usually require can openers or are too heavy for the amount of food contained. Grocery Outlet and WinCo often have hydroponic LiveLettuce for cheap that keeps for a long time. Apples and some citrus last. I wish I had fresh tomatoes, they’re so good. Fresh tomato, basil, onion and garlic salad is to die for: see FrenchGuyCooking on IG. If I had a solar-powered hydroponic greenhouse trailer, I’d grow all of my own vegetables. One modern adaptation is some farmer’s markets take EBT and offer extra incentives... which all well-and-good if you have refrigeration. The bigger problem in the produce industry is the parallels with swipe dating apps: optimizing for looks, but not taste or nutrition... hence why store-bought vegetables taste like cardboard. As an example, a former coworker had a job at one of those fruit stands. Blemished fruits and vegetables were fine to eat but wouldn’t sell, so they went into pies and soups. It seems to me shrewd farmers and shoppers would find a way to rate/compete produce, shorten the supply chain and deliver naturally-ripened food. Finally, a Russian hustler friend of mine fregans all sorts of stuff: steaks, salads, takeaway meals, whatever. I should do that more TBH because expiration dates are very conservative.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoFrom my old homeless blog: https://sandiegohomelesssurvivalguide.blogspot.com/2014/08/life-without-refrigerator.html https://sandiegohomelesssurvivalguide.blogspot.com/2014/08/l... Best.
- toomanybeersies 8y agoThe vast majority of canned goods I buy these days have tear tops. Is this not the norm in the USA?
- sokoloff 8y agoI’d say 95% or more are still stamped ends, requiring a can opener. (Though a field can opener [P-38/P-51 type] is light and cheap, so shouldn’t be viewed as an impenetrable barrier, IMO.)
- wild_preference 8y ago> Some idiot would give a homeless person some giant bag of apples. Is that the appropriate word for that person?
- hedora 8y agoIt looks like correct usage to me: https://www.wordnik.com/words/idiot https://www.wordnik.com/words/idiot The hypothetical person is certainly not offended, and previous usage as a medical diagnosis is considered archaic. Yes?
- sonofblah 8y agoNo.
- wool_gather 8y agoI'm also not really sure why apples were singled out here, since they're an example of produce that does last pretty well without refrigeration.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoIt was an actual incident that I witnessed. Perhaps it stuck with me precisely because apples keep relatively well. But there they were, going bad. If you aren't homeless, no one expects you to sit and eat a giant bag of apples all by yourself within one to three days. People in housing who are gifted a large amount of produce or whose gardens overflow will post questions to forums concerning creative uses. They will can, pickle, etc the excess -- the amount they can't reasonably eat fresh. People expect you to eat an apple or two in a day, not twenty or thirty of them. Unless you are homeless, I guess. Then suddenly you should be grateful for 30 apples instead of revolted at the idea of trying to finish them by yourself before they rot in the heat. Canning, pickling etc is beyond the means of a homeless person. So I have no idea why any middle class person would think giving a huge bag of a single type of fruit to a homeless individual in hot weather would make any sense whatsoever. I cannot fathom it. If you give a big enough bag of even a hardy fruit to someone with no means to preserve it, it will rot. Even apples.
- dguo 8y agoThank you very much for mentioning and linking to the Shirky Principle. I've been thinking about the idea for a while but didn't know that it has a succinct name.