3 ms·
In the sense that I first used X on Linux on a 486 in the early/mid 90's. It was snappy then and snappy now. Also I like being able to minimize crashed window
by mixmastamyk 8y ago
In the sense that I first used X on Linux on a 486 in the early/mid 90's. It was snappy then and snappy now.
Also I like being able to minimize crashed windows, something other major OSs haven't done.
- dcbadacd 8y agoBut screen tearing is a plague on so much different hardware and multi-monitor, high-dpi, FreeSync, HDR, high-gamut (pick any combination of these things) really do not want to work perfectly with X. This is not to say Wayland is good, X Forwarding is an awesome feature and X runs probably can now run on a literally toaster.
- mixmastamyk 8y agoI'm using it with two 4k monitors now, no problem, and no screen tearing. Hi-color might be somewhat compelling, though I write text files for a living. Does X not support it?
- dcbadacd 8y ago> Does X not support it? It technically should, but there's no official page that says it does (and in which combinations) and then there's the question if the DE and other software Linux does. It all in total has a probability of breaking, combine a few rare features and it's pretty much certain something will break. It would be really awesome if say phoronix tested all of those features out in every combination :D
- acdha 8y ago> Also I like being able to minimize crashed windows, something other major OSs haven't done. What major OSes besides Windows and Mac OS did you have in mind?
- mixmastamyk 8y agoThose are the two I'm thinking of. May have changed however, haven't used either extensively in several years.
- acdha 8y agoFWIW, being able to switch away from or minimize a hung process has been supported since 1996 (Windows NT) or 2000 (OS X).
- mixmastamyk 8y agoYou could continue working, but not move the locked window. Because the window border and titlebar were in the same process. Maybe I’ll fire up a VM to see what it does.
- mixmastamyk 8y agoJust checked my XP and 7 VMs and that's not the case. Suspended notepad on both of them and neither is able to be manipulated at all. https://imgur.com/a/zsyKQbj https://imgur.com/a/zsyKQbj
- acdha 8y agoIf you Windows + D or use Minimize All, doesn't it minimize? I used to use that heavily at an employer with an internal app written by developers who thought networks never failed.
- mixmastamyk 8y agoNot with an app suspended. Interestingly, in Win7 one suspended window even prevents others from responding to those functions also. Probably reaches one in the list and stops.
- cptskippy 8y agoGiven that he referenced a 486 he might be referring to earlier versions of both. Prior to Windows XP (possibly NT/2000) applications using GDI wrote directly to video memory and if one crashed it could create a black hole on your screen. I believe Windows Vista was when Microsoft introduced true off screen rendering and added GPU based composition of the desktop. GDI/GDI+ are now considered legacy and the issues the OP described aren't much of a problem anymore. I believe Quartz is the OSX/MacOS equivalent to GDI on Windows however it's been less problematic than GDI and I believe OSX was launched with off screen rendering and composition that made the issued described by the OP impossible. I have no idea of OS9 or prior versions performed desktop composition.
- cptskippy 8y agoMy understanding is that X was designed during the Terminal/MainFrame era of computing where window rendering, composition and display were distributed between the client and server which may or may not be the same machine. And that paradigm is maintained to this day in X which is limiting when all rendering, composition and display are handled locally and possibly offload to a GPU with the distinction between a client and server being unnecessary. So Windowing environments like Wayland have a distinct advantage over X when it comes to performance. I could be anywhere from completely right to utterly wrong on this so take it with a grain of salt.
- DougMerritt 8y agoX11 has always supported both networked client/server and everything happening on the local machine, using tcp/ip for the former, and either shared memory or local sockets for the latter, depending on implementation. > So Windowing environments like Wayland have a distinct advantage over X when it comes to performance. I haven't seen numbers myself, but you can't simply assume that. Programmer-millenia of work has gone into making the various implementations of X11 efficient.