4 ms·
What is the ideology that makes this acceptable and justifiable in their minds, because I cannot understand it. It's cultural relativism. Since every culture c
by chongli 8y ago
What is the ideology that makes this acceptable and justifiable in their minds, because I cannot understand it.
It's cultural relativism. Since every culture can only be judged within the value structure defined by that culture, every culture is good by default.
It tends to go hand in hand with the view that Western countries are destroying every other culture and thus are evil. It's a sickness spreading throughout the West, but in the US in particular.
- shredprez 8y agoA couple thoughts: Cultural relativism is amoral. It isn’t about good/evil, it’s about local norms. What is normal one place may not be normal elsewhere, from the national level down to the family level. When paired with fatigue over the US’ complicated, open-ended interventions at home and abroad, you will often hear people provide a moralized version of cultural relativism as a reason not to engage. The real reason, obviously, is that these people no longer believe intervention will be effective and could even be damaging. In that framework, it’s understandable to have a “hey, it’s their house, they can do what they like” response. I say all this as someone who believes it absolutely is the responsibility of liberated people to liberate others, while also recognizing how challenging it can be to achieve that goal on any large scale. In conversations like these, I think it can be helpful to consider the context in which people arrive at their conclusions rather than casting ideas you disagree with as a “spreading sickness.” By that metaphor, we ought to focus on the cause of the disease, not the weakness of the ill.
- snowwrestler 8y agoThat's not what cultural relativism is and that's not why Google is thinking about taking this step. They are thinking about taking this step because: a) they are a business, China is a huge potential market they will lose if they don't try to compete for it, and b) they believe their product does good in the world, and therefore they think a partial good (partial access to Google) is better than no good (no access to Google). Whether b) is true or not is obviously in the eye of the beholder. I tend to think it's closer to a rationalization of a) than a sober evaluation of the objective truth. For those wondering what cultural relativism actually is, it is a useful mental tool for thinking about the evolution of cultures other than your own. It is not moral relativism, nor is it a hatred of the west.
- jackhack 8y ago>they believe their product does good in the world Perhaps, but good, for whom? It is useful to ask "What class of people benefits? Who is harmed?" and is the net change worse that if we did not meddle? Does it give power to some, at the expense of others?