52 ms·
Banks are the problem, not the people that think they in fact can afford this stuff. That makes as much sense as saying carmakers are responsible for auto acci
by gaius 16y ago
Banks are the problem, not the people that think they in fact can afford this stuff.
That makes as much sense as saying carmakers are responsible for auto accidents, not people who think they're better drivers than they are.
- jacquesm 16y agoCars don't come with hidden costs in the form of overdraft charges, late payment fees and foreclosure and the seizure of your assets, if you pay cash for them. There is nothing wrong with cars and the personal responsibilities that go with them, financing is something that most people that are eligible for do not understand sufficiently to evaluate the risk. Of course the standard capitalist answer is 'sucks to be you, should should have studied harder in school', but the fact is that this out-of-control lending is causing a large amount of trouble. People should not by default be allowed to borrow this much money for simple reasons such as financial health of the nation and (in)solvency of the banks. That way, if you can't afford a fancy car you won't be buying it. Cheap credit has become a way to push the economy forward on money that hasn't been rightfully earned yet, that can't go on forever before it will come back to haunt us, the mortgage crisis is one nice example of what happens when the financial system is rotten. I won't be surprised if there will be another chapter to this based on the amount of credit card debt there and the number of people that find that they are no longer in a position to fulfill their obligations.
- gaius 16y agoI do agree that people should live within their means, but the root cause is not "the banks". If the government creates an environment in which the choice is, lend too much or go out of business when your rivals do and you have no customers, then a bank has no choice. And the smarter banks knew this; the whole CDO thing was a desperate attempt to somehow offset the risk. If you want a root cause in the UK at least, look no further than Gordon Brown. 1 pound in 4 NuLabour spent was borrowed... And unlike my neighbours fancy car, that debt does affect me, despite having no part of it, aye, and no part of it spent on me either...
- gridspy 16y agoGovernments actually have very little control of the economy. They can tax stuff to discourage it, or adjust interest rates. Pretty much anything else they do has horrible side effects that are very difficult to predict and often take years to exhibit. To see what they can do: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monetary_policy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monetary_policy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macroeconomics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macroeconomics Or to put it more concisely, how exactly would you like the government to intervene? So yeah, it _is_ the Banks who are to blame.
- gaius 16y agoThey can tax stuff to discourage it, or adjust interest rates. Or borrow and spend, which ought to drive up inflation, but require the BoE to keep inflation low, by artificially holding interest rates low making money too cheap and risk impossible to assess. I say it again: if you are bank A and you won't lend at a low rate and banks B, C and D do then A goes out of business when its customers desert it for doing the "right thing" and the situation is unchanged. The alternative is for A, B, C and D to get together and fix interest rates (prices) themselves, at which point their CEOs are looking at jail time. The banks are merely scapegoats for the politicians. And you've fallen for it hook, line and sinker. What would I like the government to do instead? It can start by paying off the deficit...
- gridspy 16y agoOkay, so the government should cut domestic spending, reducing the amount of cash available to government agencies and their suppliers? Or did you mean it should raise taxes to collect more funds, essentially putting a drag on the economy and sending tax-sensitive organisations elsewhere? Possibly you meant it should print money, causing hyper-inflation and destroying the value of savings and the public's faith in them. All three options suck, and all three would lead to negative publicity. I think that the government should cut spending on stuff that I don't think is important. But you and I would probably disagree on what stuff that is. As for the banks model, bank A would probably launch an adversing campaign clearly describing that investing in banks B,C + D is a sure way to loose your money. This campaign (when successful) would make more funds available (term deposits, savings accounts) to A which it could then safely invest. Note of course that banks A..D are probably not competing on interest rates (they set them all the same) but instead on loan terms. Bank A decides that it is not in its best interest to grant loans to people without security/equity making money instead from 80% mortgages and the like. Bank A looses high-risk, heavy spending customers and attracts risk-adverse savers and spenders.
- rick888 16y ago"Cars don't come with hidden costs in the form of overdraft charges, late payment fees and foreclosure and the seizure of your assets, if you pay cash for them." You are mentioning all of them here. Can we really call these costs "hidden"? Many things in life are hidden from ignorant people. This doesn't mean we should ban them from everyone. "People should not by default be allowed to borrow this much money for simple reasons such as financial health of the nation and (in)solvency of the banks." This really just means less freedom for people. The government is then deciding what you can and can't do because you may make an irresponsible and wrong decision. When will it end? Should we ban Mcdonalds because it's making people fat? "Cheap credit has become a way to push the economy forward on money that hasn't been rightfully earned yet, that can't go on forever before it will come back to haunt us, the mortgage crisis is one nice example of what happens when the financial system is rotten. I won't be surprised if there will be another chapter to this based on the amount of credit card debt there and the number of people that find that they are no longer in a position to fulfill their obligations." I know so many people that are in Credit card debt (I was also in debt myself..and managed to cut back spending for a couple of years to pay it off). Most of them are there because they wanted to buy things they couldn't afford. The mortgage crises can also be blamed on irresponsibility. I saw a dateline special where a woman lied on her application to get a house she couldn't afford it ended up going into foreclosure. She blamed the banks. She said they shouldn't have allowed her to get the loan in the first place. It's this line of thinking that is destroying the US.
- rdtsc 16y ago> The government is then deciding what you can and can't do because you may make an irresponsible and wrong decision. When will it end? When most people will _not_ systematically fall into the same trap, get into bankruptcies or lose their homes. We are not talking isolated cases of a couple of idiots, but about 3m foreclosure listings (about 1 foreclosure listing for every 100 people in US). So a couple hundred thousand people are totally stupid and deserve what they got, but when you talk about whole percentages of the population something else is going on. Did people all of the sudden get stupid in the last 15 years? Somehow I doubt that. Nobody minds the government telling them if they can drive, what kind of additions to the their house they can build, watching over so food companies don't sprinkle lead and arsenic in the food. Why can't the government also prevent them from getting stupid loans that, if not checked, nationally (or even globally) will lead to the supposed total collapse of the economy? There is another general issue we have to deal with and that is the assumption that people are rational, autonomous agents. They will process information logically and make the best possible decision for themselves and their dependents. That sounds really good on paper or if one had to design an agent based AI world. In practice, it turns out, people are not rational. They lack critical thinking skills, they will make many decisions that will eventually hurt them, their dependents and their country. The real answer is a better education system. But that is a long term solution (and we are already failing that US terribly). In short term I think it is acceptable for the govt. to play the role of a nanny. Otherwise we end up with bigger problems overall: poverty, huge income inequality, lots of sick people, lots of homeless people and lots of angry people.
- philwelch 16y agoLoans and mortgages don't come with hidden costs, either--it's all in the paperwork if you can be arsed to read it or hire a lawyer to read it for you. And by that standard, cars come with "hidden" costs too, in terms of maintenance and insurance. (And the maintenance costs can be pretty well hidden, too. Who knows whether your car's going to be a falling-apart piece of shit in five years?)
- jacquesm 16y ago> Loans and mortgages don't come with hidden costs, either--it's all in the paperwork if you can be arsed to read it or hire a lawyer to read it for you. Better bring a magnifying glass then. I wasn't exactly joking about the 1 point gray-on-gray text. You'd almost wonder if there is something there that they don't want you to read.
- sigstoat 16y agohaving borrrowed probably more than one million USD from banks, and having read most of the paperwork, i call BS on anything which could even be jokingly described as "1 point gray-on-gray" text. everything i've encountered has been pleasantly type set, 10 to 12pt (maybe 6pt footnotes), very high contrast. it's all there. i've never been pressured to read things quickly, in fact i've usually had the documents in hand days or weeks before they had to be signed and returned. i've had bankers suggest i take longer reading, since i seemed to be signing too quickly for their tastes. IME, there's a big difference between the folks that loan you money with lots of zeros at the end, and the folks that loan you money a credit card transaction at a time.
- cynicalkane 16y agoBut in an earlier post, you seem to imply that you don't have a major problem with buying something that hasn't been "rightfully earned yet" so long as it's a home. Make up your mind, please.