4 ms·
Indeed. Furthermore, "secure elections" are a solved problem. Have paper ballots, and scan them later. If you have any reason to suspect the scanners, then thro
by dragontamer 8y ago
Indeed. Furthermore, "secure elections" are a solved problem. Have paper ballots, and scan them later. If you have any reason to suspect the scanners, then throw away the scanners and then proceed by hand.
There are statistical methods to count a small number by hand (+ corroborate with poll results) to ensure a degree of consistency. Chi-squared distributions and stuff (I'm not a mathematician, but I'm sure there's some statistical method to verify the results without counting everything by hand).
The main problem with blockchain is that it requires everyone to trust the blockchain. With humans counting by hand, you don't require any trust. As long as the ballots are properly stored, you can always recount the results.
- nixpulvis 8y agoCalling "secure elections" a solved problem made me laugh.
- swerveonem 8y agoThanks for pointing that out. I laughed too. Shill obviously works for a problem.
- nixpulvis 8y agoI remember back in college listening to a guest lecturer talk about the problems with electronic voting. It was very interesting. I think the entire political world is still feeling the wrath of the 21st century. Hopefully we all make it out alive.
- CuriousSkeptic 8y agoPaper ballots are fine for infrequent elections. But not for things a bit more ... liquid[1] [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delegative_democracy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delegative_democracy
- aeternus 8y agoYou still require trust with the paper ballots, there are multiple threat models: - System needs to ensure everyone votes only once - Ensure each person meets the qualifications to vote - Ensure ballots cannot be counterfeit or additional ballots inserted somehow - Ensure votes are confidential throughout the process - Ensure voters cannot prove their votes to others - Ensure the people counting are trusted or the results checked / verified - Ensure all ballots are actually counted One significant negative with the paper ballot method is that voters cannot confirm the last point. I have no way of confirming that my ballot was actually counted and contributed to the final tally's.
- foepys 8y agoTo attack paper ballots you need people. Like thousands of people working with you to manipulate important elections directly at the source. With electronic voting, you potentially need a single person with a computer on the other side of the globe exploiting a security flaw, that will inevitably be there. Whoever claims to write bug free software is a conman. I also don't want to be able to verify my vote. If I can, that means that somebody else also can. Given how tech-illiterate the average human is, voting crypto keys will be littered all around the internet.
- aeternus 8y ago>I also don't want to be able to verify my vote. If I can, that means that somebody else also can. Given how tech-illiterate the average human is, voting crypto keys will be littered all around the internet. Right, I should have been more clear. You typically do want voters to be able to prove that they voted and that their vote was counted, but you do not want voters to be able to prove the contents of their vote (who they voted for).
- DennisP 8y agoSome kinda famous cryptographers have designed verifiable paper voting systems: https://rangevoting.org/RivSmiPRshort.html https://rangevoting.org/RivSmiPRshort.html https://rangevoting.org/RivSmiAnswers.html https://rangevoting.org/RivSmiAnswers.html https://rangevoting.org/SleatorCheapo.html https://rangevoting.org/SleatorCheapo.html
- gnarcoregrizz 8y agoFor tallying results, trust has to be placed in the people and/or machines tallying the results. With a blockchain-based system, every voter would count everyone else's votes
- icebraining 8y agoHow would you know every vote was registered in the blockchain?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gnarcoregrizz 8y agoBecause its a public, verifiable data structure. That's not to say it's perfect, it's subject to 51% attacks so yes votes could possibly be discarded in that case.
- swerveonem 8y agoThis removes the cryptography aspects, which is what keeps the system and results verifiable after the fact. Of course the votes can be counted and statistical estimations of accuracy can be used to attempt to detect fraud but that can also be performed AFTER each individual vote is recorded on a blockchain. In fact the only reason not to utilize blockchain technology in election processes is to ensure the results can be manipulated.
- icebraining 8y agoWhat blockchain voting scheme(s) provide at least as much anonymity as paper ballots?
- throwawaymath 8y agoCan you clarify this a bit? What unique security assurances are offered by a blockchain that cannot be provided by other cryptographic methods?