4 ms·
Plausible deniability. The system should allow two (or more) passwords, one unlocks only the important stuff and one unlocks much less dangerous stuff while des
by squarefoot 8y ago
Plausible deniability. The system should allow two (or more) passwords, one unlocks only the important stuff and one unlocks much less dangerous stuff while destroying any evidence of the first, including the multiple passwords protection layer.
To add some credibility, the less dangerous data should contain something one could get in trouble for but not enough to have his life destroyed.
As an example, if after being forced to reveal a password my phone showed photos of myself having sex with a hooker, I don't think many prosecutors would believe I put them there to protect other more sensitive stuff that would ruin my entire life and not just my relationship. And if they did, I just served them with real proof of why I encrypted my phone which should be enough to counter their unfounded accusations.
- PunchTornado 8y agothat sounds like a really good idea and not that difficult to implement.
- gambiting 8y agoTruecrypt always had that - one password decrypts into your real partition, the other decrypts the prepared one, with a clear OS. It's impossible to say there is anything in the space where the hidden partition resides, and you have provided a password so at least in theory you are clear.
- cryptonector 8y agoBut it is possible to say that you have Truecrypt installed. Then the LEO just asks for the second password.
- lol768 8y ago> Then the LEO just asks for the second password. But it's entirely _optional_ to use. They cannot prove there is a second password.
- cryptonector 8y agoThey're not dumb. You installed the thing you're claiming gives you plausible deniability -- it's a fair inference that you wanted just that so that you could hide something, ergo the court will just demand that password. Which means you shouldn't install any such software unless you're going to have those hidden partitions and are willing to let LE have access.
- cesarb 8y agoDo most users of TrueCrypt/VeraCrypt use this "hidden volume" functionality, or do they just want the basic full disk encryption? It wouldn't surprise me if users of plausible deniability were in the minority.
- cryptonector 8y agoIf you could show that most users never do this, you might have an argument in court. How would you do this though? At the end of the day, the fact that you have this sw installed will make it fair to infer that you are using this feature. You can disagree, but it's what the courts say that matters here, not what I say.
- gambiting 8y agoThe problem is that you could totally have truecrypt installed and not have a second hidden partition. There is no way to prove that you do. Of course, the court could throw you in jail for not being able to provide something that doesn't exist anyway, but yeah....I'd hope that the lack of proof here would help you win the case.
- cryptonector 8y agoA prosecutor, a jury, and a judge, will all have a chance to decide that you're telling the truth. There is not mathematical proof here (there never is in any trials, really), so it will all come down to: do we believe the LEO's and the defendant's experts' testimony? Recall, the defendant won't testify -- their lawyer won't let them -- but if they did, they'd probably do themselves in anyways, the court (jury, judge) won't believe them. There is no plausible deniability here, really.
- stale2002 8y agoWhich is why you have 10 passwords, only 1 of which has the important stuff on it. You are industiguisable from someone who has 9. What, are the police just going to keep you in jail? What if you really ARE innocent? Jail for life then, because they didn't find anything incriminating?
- cryptonector 8y agoFree space management needs imply that at some point you must provably have all N passwords or that you're wasting some amount of space just to avoid that, but since that's dumb the fair inference is that you're not doing that, and that you have N passwords to reveal.
- justinjlynn 8y agoTools like this do not do free space management unless you've unlocked all hidden partitions. You are responsible for that. If you fill your partitions beyond capacity, you corrupt the other data in your other hidden partitions. Of course, unless you've unlocked all the hidden partitions you care about - then it can. However, well designed tools that do this have no way of knowing if you have.
- ransom1538 8y agoPlausible deniability systems are pretty amazing but didn't seem to catch on. Truecrypt was awesome, it had hidden drives. Edit: "didn't seem to catch on" I mean you can't do this with popular products like FileVault. https://www.truecrypt71a.com/documentation/plausible-deniability/ https://www.truecrypt71a.com/documentation/plausible-deniabi...
- cryptonector 8y agoIf LEO find you're using Truecrypt, do you think they'll not realize that you might have a hidden drive and ask for that password too??
- ransom1538 8y agoThat is where LEO is screwed. They can't prove if you do or you don't have hidden data. EG. There isn't a /hidden_stuff_here/ directory. Its somehow baked into the encryption blocks.
- stale2002 8y agoWell, then you give them your second password, and it is fine, because you actually have 3 passwords. The police can't just keep saying "we didn't find anything, therefore you MUST have ANOTHER double secret password!". At that point you are indistinguishable from someone who is innocent.
- cryptonector 8y agoThe device is rated 1TB. Given all of the passwords you gave us we can account for .5TB and we cannot find a free-space map. Ergo there is at least one more password that you're not sharing with us. Seriously, other people aren't dumb.
- stale2002 8y agoThat's not how partions work for these things. And the people who wrote these security systems thought of exactly this attack vector. If you create a passworded partion, it adds a bunch of extra unused space, that MIGHT be another passworded partion, or might just be random empty space. IE, maybe you have 3 passwords and 200 GB of extra space, or maybe it is actually 4 passwords and 150 GB of extra space that is random bytes. These 2 situations are identical and cannot be differentiated. The police tell you to access that 150GB of extra space, and it is impossible. Because it's random bytes, and there really isn't an extra partition.
- cryptonector 8y agoLEO are not stupid. If you are using tech with this feature then they'll ask for both passwords.
- mattnewton 8y agoN-passwords it is then.
- caconym_ 8y agoIf it's impossible to prove that you've set up the second password, they can't reasonably demand that you provide it if you deny that it exists. They could unreasonably demand a working second password and incarcerate/torture you until you either provide one or die, but that's the next level.
- cryptonector 8y agoLEO and courts will (reasonably!) make the following inference: "MIGHT be another password-protected partition" -> "is a password-protected partition"
- caconym_ 8y agoHow does the Truecrypt version of this idea work? I was under the impression that the double-secret data were written in such a way as to be indistinguishable from random bits that normally appear in the files that contain encrypted volumes, with no metadata (e.g. a partition table) to suggest that those random bits are actually interesting. I figure there is at least one good reason to include amenable "filler" in a "single-secret" file containing encrypted data: it means the size of the plaintext data cannot be inferred from the size of the file. So there is plausible deniability for having amenable "random" data present on that basis alone. I'm not saying it's easy to extend this scheme to accommodate all environments and/or user experiences. As you say, you can't just e.g. have another partition sitting around full of nothing but suspicious random data.
- jkaptur 8y agoSome thinking along these lines: https://web.archive.org/web/20100820175505/http://iq.org:80/~proff/rubberhose.org/current/src/doc/beatings.txt https://web.archive.org/web/20100820175505/http://iq.org:80/...
- skate22 8y agoDoesnt seem very different than flushing stuff down the toilet when you see the cops pull up to your door with a search warrent