2 ms·
> Our system is rigged to require people to work That is a very strange thing to say following a comment about natural law, considering there is nothing about
by zdragnar 8y ago
> Our system is rigged to require people to work
That is a very strange thing to say following a comment about natural law, considering there is nothing about nature that guarantees you a right to live.
Rather, specialization of economy and and social safety nets means that it's a hell of a lot easier to survive working even a low paying job than it is to try otherwise.
As it stands right now, even if you taxed 100% of the income reported by the top 1% of earners, we might not close the government's budget gap, let alone expand the government's budget to guarantee survival for all citizens (not to mention the economic chaos that would result in taxing 100% of all income earned by anyone).
- ryandrake 8y ago> That is a very strange thing to say following a comment about natural law, considering there is nothing about nature that guarantees you a right to live. I think we agree there is no natural law when it comes to macroeconomics, which is a human invention, and the various economic systems that each come with their own strengths and weaknesses. What we have now is better than primitive hunter-gatherer economy, but we seem to be stuck with this belief that only "more extreme capitalism" can make things better. > As it stands right now, even if you taxed 100% of the income reported by the top 1% of earners, we might not close the government's budget gap, let alone expand the government's budget to guarantee survival for all citizens (not to mention the economic chaos that would result in taxing 100% of all income earned by anyone). I don't think anyone proposed taxing 100% of anyone's income. A 100% marginal tax after a certain AGI sounds intriguing, and is not far from what was implemented in the USA back in the mid 20th century, to no apparent detrimental effect on the economy.
- zdragnar 8y ago> is not far from what was implemented in the USA back in the mid 20th century, to no apparent detrimental effect on the economy. I was merely trying to make a point, not suggesting that it was something someone wanted to do. However, you may be interested in some light reading. http://teachinghistory.org/history-content/ask-a-historian/24489 http://teachinghistory.org/history-content/ask-a-historian/2... https://taxfoundation.org/taxes-rich-1950-not-high/ https://taxfoundation.org/taxes-rich-1950-not-high/ There were "no apparent detrimental effects" because so very few people actually paid those taxes. Part of the problem with the soak-the-rich idea is that they're the ones who can readily adjust their wealth strategies if taxes on, say, earned income rise to obscene levels. Not much different than sin taxes (alcohol, tobacco, etc), though probably even more effective at discouraging behavior. Heck, I knew a couple who would retire for a few years, work for a few years, retire for a few years. Sometimes it was for fun, sometimes just a reaction to an increase or decrease in local / state/ federal taxes.