3 ms·
In my opinion "take security more seriously" is too nebulous to be constructive here. What do we want these companies to do? Security is an incredibly hard pr
by slg 8y ago
In my opinion "take security more seriously" is too nebulous to be constructive here. What do we want these companies to do? Security is an incredibly hard problem. It is only exacerbated when we go years without speaking with one of these companies. Anything that you have to remember in that time whether it is a password, pin code, or "who was your childhood hero" type security questions can all be forgotten. How else is this company supposed to identify you over the phone, without something that can be forgotten, without referencing easy to find public information, and without using a secondary verified contact method like email?
- mikeash 8y agoIs there an absolute requirement to be able to demonstrate your identity over the phone even if you have no secret information with which to confirm it? How about, if you forget your password and can’t get into your account, you need to visit a store in person to show your ID, or mail in a notarized copy, or something like that?
- slg 8y agoRequiring customers to come to a store would basically exclude anyone from accessing their account outside the retail footprint of the company. That isn't realistic for companies that are trying to provide you a global service like most telecoms. It also introduces plenty of other problems. For example, if you are mugged on the street and lose your phone and wallet are you just frozen out of your mobile account until you can get to the DMV and wait the month until you get a new ID? It is a hard problem that can't just be fixed by "taking it seriously".
- mikeash 8y agoPhysical presence wouldn’t be required unless you forgot your credentials. If you are mugged and forgot your password, then you’d be screwed. I’m not sure how reasonable it is to try to make that particular situation better though.
- kodablah 8y ago> What do we want these companies to do? Stop giving out my data/access to anyone but me. Once you set a general company attitude towards distribution of data/access, you can't ask for pity when that attitude comes back to bite you. Collect less, lock it down, proliferate it less, etc. Then you'll get my sympathy when an employee at one of your stores gives away my data/access. And no, restricting data/access and ease of use are not completely mutually exclusive. There is a harmonious middle of the venn diagram that is completely different to the way things are currently run. Nobody's asking to force 2FA on cell phones here (unless we opt-in), we're just asking for better identity verification and less apathy towards giving out my info (in all cases).
- slg 8y ago>Stop giving out my data/access to anyone but me But the problem is the company doesn't know who "you" are.
- kodablah 8y agoReasonable attempts at identification validation, especially in these contexts, can be excused when they fail for a very determined actor. But I don't think these attempts are occurring not because the policies aren't there (even though many times they aren't), but because there is a general attitude to not care about what is being protected. If it were my bars of gold you can damn well bet vigilance would be higher.
- criddell 8y agoNo, the problem is often the company doesn't care. In their defense, they believe they are trying to help you and probably 99% of the time, that is what they are doing.
- axaxs 8y agoI think there could be a sliding scale of sorts, with the last resort as sorry, you must visit a store. Perhaps a series of strong security questions(no 'mothers maiden name' type), and if failed, you must present ID at a physical location. Perhaps a copy of an ID or other photo on file that you could match/resend? Maybe an option to 'lock' the account to changes, that can only be unlocked by the user when logged in, or by visiting a store? Just off the top of my head, I can think of hundreds of things these companies could be doing better..many of which are not 100% foolproof, but far ahead of what they're doing now.
- LyndsySimon 8y ago> Maybe an option to 'lock' the account to changes, that can only be unlocked by the user when logged in, or by visiting a store? AT&T sorta offers this - there's an enhanced security option that lets you provide a password or PIN if you want to make account changes. This is allowed in lieu of ID. My AT&T account is technically still tied to my father-in-law, because my wife and I took it over over a decade ago, when we were still in college. They no longer have AT&T phones and I consider it my account, but whenever I visit a store I have to provide the password before I can upgrade my phone or change the service plan. To move the account into my name would require me and my FIL to visit a store together, which is inconvenient enough that we've not bothered.