2 ms·
In fact, many of those higher-tax countries do export their top academics and entrepreneurs to the US. None are as populous, large, and diverse as the US -- so
by gojomo 16y ago
In fact, many of those higher-tax countries do export their top academics and entrepreneurs to the US.
None are as populous, large, and diverse as the US -- so each may have an easier time (politically and operationally) centralizing and nationalizing services with consensus support.
But alternatively, why wouldn't we be getting economies of scale which make an equally high tax burden (as a percentage of GDP, which is the measure you seem to be using) unnecessary?
Also, the US is on average wealthier than many of those countries. Why wouldn't tax-funded goods and services -- being as they are for the benefit of people of all incomes -- be inferior goods, whose proportion of income should decrease as a consumer -- in this case, the nation -- becomes richer? We have a lower 'food burden', as a percentage of national income, than many countries -- yet few would argue we must increase that number for our national benefit.
The times of strong growth and high taxes occurred post-WW2, when the US had an uniquely unassailable competitive position, and much of the rest of the world had ludicrously high taxes, too. The whole world moved away from those peak rates; implying we could today have the same "unprecedented" world-beating export economy of the 50s/60s with similar ~70-90% top marginal tax rates would be insane.
- tptacek 16y agoYou're framing the debate in terms of the immediate postwar economy, but I could just as easily invoke the 1990's.
- gojomo 16y agoGrowth in the 90s wasn't 'unprecedented', and the 90s top 39.6% tax rate wasn't 'significantly more onerous' than today's 35% rate, considering the history of rates: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_tax_in_the_United_States#History_of_federal_income_tax http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_tax_in_the_United_States...