4 ms·
You're pretty much proving my point when it comes to confusing the law with what is right. Ignore the law, it's completely orthogonal to the discussion. Free sp
by Spivak 8y ago
You're pretty much proving my point when it comes to confusing the law with what is right. Ignore the law, it's completely orthogonal to the discussion. Free speech isn't prescriptive. Holding it as an ideal doesn't mean you want zero restrictions any more than holding liberty as an ideal means you want anarchy.
Your 'system' is simply unrestricted speech to the powerful and your 'solution' is just a suggestion that Gab's community become powerful enough to speak. Does that sound like free speech to you?
- lordCarbonFiber 8y agoIf we lived in a fantasy dystopia inwhich computers were outlawed to all but the silicon valley elite and the rest of the populace had to rent from them or be left in the cold, maybe your argument would have some weight. In the world we do live in, speech for your small niche community is literally a 30 dollar raspberry pi and an internet connection away. No one has any moral (or legal authority for that matter) to shut down the nazi chat rooms of others (under your views at least); just like Microsoft and others have no moral obligation to host content that breaks their terms of service and will drive others off of their platform. Arguing what is "right" in a law abiding society is nonsense. If the laws are flawed you argue against the laws, if they aren't pretending that people or groups of people should conform to your ideals is ultimately a waste of time.
- Rapzid 8y agoFreedom of speech literally has everything to do with the government. Microsoft should be under no more obligation to enable the spread of hate by hosting it online than a business hosting it in physical space.