4 ms·
I really hate this meme; Randall did the world a great disservice by missing the point and putting it in a format which spread like wildfire for smug people to
by Spivak 8y ago
I really hate this meme; Randall did the world a great disservice by missing the point and putting it in a format which spread like wildfire for smug people to quote until the end of time. Free speech is a principal which extends farther than a very limited right in US law -- it's not a rule, it's not prescriptive, it's not afforded by any law -- it's an ideal. I don't in any way deny that you can find people who confuse the legal right with the ideal but if you talk to any lawyer for twenty seconds you'll realize that speech is far from the only area where this happens.
What happened is a free speech issue. Did the actions Microsoft took promote the healthy and open exchange of ideas or did they take an action in order to silence? Since Gab is largely a closed community this action wasn't so much protecting people from abuse so much as it was preventing like minded people from talking to each other. And no matter what I think about the things they said I still hold that they ought to be allowed to say them among themselves.
- ufmace 8y agoI agree. What I have been saying is that Free Speech means far more than the literal text of the First Amendment and nothing else. Free Speech is a critical cultural norm to the maintenance of Democracy. Free Speech means that all people and all institutions hold as important values to not restrict the speech even of those they disagree with. Values such as these do not flow from the Government to the people and culture, but from the people and culture to the Government. If the culture is to disregard free speech for certain forbidden opinions, then that will seep into the Government eventually. I fear that if we continue on the path we have been going down for the last few years, we may lose the Freedom of Speech at the Government level in a generation.
- joshuamorton 8y ago>And no matter what I think about the things they said I still hold that they ought to be allowed to say them among themselves. And they are. No one is stopping them from talking to each other. They however are telling people to stop talking to each other in the office building Microsoft owns and rents out. Perhaps that's the best analogy? Providing (P|I|S)AAS is a business transaction. Its like renting out commercial space. And landowners turn down potential leases for all kinds of reasons that have nothing to do with money ("we're trying to cultivate a certain image in this area"), and we don't bat an eye. We would think absolutely nothing of a landlord saying "no, local KKK chapter, you cannot set up your lounge here". But when the space is virtual, it magically changes from a landlord to a speech thing. Even though the activities at the KKK lounge would be, by and large, the same kinds of activities that would happen at stormfront, except perhaps overall less harmful (more potlucks, less extremism). The landlord isn't stopping them from chatting, he just isn't going to be party to a transaction that actively facilitates it. Why's Microsoft (or Google, or anyone else's) action different? I'm happy to provide thought experiments to test where you actually lie on this debate. I expect that your views will normally fall on the "no one is under any obligation, even ethically, to provide someone else a speech platform, and refusing to provide someone a platform is not the same as censorship", although I can't say for sure.
- geodel 8y ago> But when the space is virtual, it magically changes from a landlord to a speech thing. I think it because whenever there is piracy or unauthorized access to entertainment or information resource from cable/media companies comes up, apart from company whose property get stolen, all seem to have sympathy towards culprit . The standard arguments are couched in user freedom rather than taking someone's property without consent. All this is because resource is digital so my access does not deprive other. So blocking is claimed to harmful, immoral, greed by media or cable companies for things some people want to have. And now non-blocking is considered harmful by social media companies for things some people do not want.
- mindslight 8y ago> All this is because resource is digital so my access does not deprive other It's not surprising that people don't treat something that lacks one of the key aspects of property as property. Especially when the desired enforcement regime for this concept always seems to necessitate encroachment on their actual property! Copyright applied to individuals is even less enforceable than drug persecution. And we see how well that's working out.
- lordCarbonFiber 8y agoI love how you can say "free speech is an ideal" while simultaneous arguing to limit the free speech of platform holders. The reason free speech only lawfully bounds the government is because the ability to kick bad actors out of your business is an essential free speech to the populous. MS is free to moderate their platform in anyway that doesn't violate US law; that's their exercise of free speech. Groups that disagree can go elsewhere with their business. The "fine" folks over at gab can say what ever they want among themselves; on their own servers, hosted by them. Until then freedom to say what you want is not freedom from the consequences of public opinion.
- ufmace 8y agoNow this is where things get interesting. There's a decent argument to be made that internet communication is becoming dominated by a handful of platforms. There may be a point at which you are practically unable to speak on the internet if a half-dozen Silicon Valley companies do not like your opinion. I do not say that we are at this point yet. It is a possible and visible future, though. I think we can consider how we would determine when that domination of internet discussion constitutes a monopoly, and what should be done about it in that case. We don't allow companies that are monopolies in critical industries to do as they please, in many areas and for many reasons. If there is effectively widespread censorship of speech, who elected Facebook, Google, Amazon, Apple, Microsoft, et all to be the deciders of what gets censored and what does not? If the ability or potential for that is out there, shouldn't it be the democratically elected government that determines what does and does not get censored and not a cabal of private corporations?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Spivak 8y agoYou're pretty much proving my point when it comes to confusing the law with what is right. Ignore the law, it's completely orthogonal to the discussion. Free speech isn't prescriptive. Holding it as an ideal doesn't mean you want zero restrictions any more than holding liberty as an ideal means you want anarchy. Your 'system' is simply unrestricted speech to the powerful and your 'solution' is just a suggestion that Gab's community become powerful enough to speak. Does that sound like free speech to you?