4 ms·
> What the patient seeks is irrelevant. The only one who decides what prescriptions a patient should take is a doctor. That kind of rubs me the wrong way, but
by umvi 8y ago
> What the patient seeks is irrelevant. The only one who decides what prescriptions a patient should take is a doctor.
That kind of rubs me the wrong way, but I'm not sure why. I like having the option of overriding the doctor if I disagree.
- stef25 8y agoIt would be fair to make choices in the sense of picking a longer treatment that doesn't force you to stay home from work, vs a shorter treatment that would. And of course "another round of chemo" or "I can't be f*cked anymore" are valid choices. But really, when things like opiates are involved patient input is rarely useful.
- skookumchuck 8y ago> But really, when things like opiates are involved patient input is rarely useful. Since there is no method for determining the level of a patient's pain, and opiates are for pain management, how can you conclude that?
- stef25 8y agoYeah, I didn't phrase that properly. Of course patients should communicate how much pain they are in, but they shouldn't communicate the type of painkillers that are to be prescribed.
- roenxi 8y agoMaybe one of the following? These are a couple of takes of that attitude from a few slightly different viewpoints. * Removal of agency from the patient in relation to how their body is treated; anti-individualism. * Decision making power assigned to an agent who does not have skin in the game; anti-system-thinking. * Attitude runs counter to having a strong sense of personal responsibility; anti-some-morality-systems. * Imposition of doctors value system overrides patient values; not-sure.
- amaccuish 8y agoIn the NHS, that isn't possible. You either take the doctor's treatment, or you get no treatment at all. You can go around, asking different doctors, or having a discussion with your doctor, but you will not be prescribed something you don't need. The incentive being, that with a tax payer funded system, money should go to those who actually need it. It is understood here I guess that the doctor is the expert, not you.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoI can totally appreciate this. As an American though, I have gone around my doctor and ordered prescription medications online when they would not prescribe them (ivermectin, anti-parisital, non-controlled substances, almost zero risk to myself if my diagnosis was inaccurate).
- umvi 8y agoSlightly related, sometimes I just want a new pair of glasses without the hassle of going to/paying the eye doctor. I can still see 20/20 with my current prescription, but since it's "expired", physical retailers won't sell me glasses nor will they use their refractometer to read off the prescription of my current pair. So I instead go online and order a pair from Zenni using my expired prescription that I wrote down.
- toomanybeersies 8y agoThat's an interestingly unique problem to the USA I think. Here in Australia, I haven't been to an optometrist in 5 or 6 years. I just keep ordering new glasses for $60 a pair online, my vision hasn't changed enough that I feel that I need to go to an optometrist again. The optometrist is legally required to give me my prescription, which I can then use as I want. I haven't bought glasses in a brick and mortar store for 5 or 6 years (last time I got an eye test), but I'm fairly sure they won't/can't refuse to make me a pair to my specifications. Actually, I did get a pair made in the shop in Vietnam 2 years ago, and they were more than happy to make them (overnight too, I might add), although they did laugh at how blind I was.
- toomanybeersies 8y agoI understand where you're coming from. I have a little stack of benzos (valium, xanax, some others) that I use on the odd occasion, despite not being prescribed. Obviously possessing them is illegal. I know that I'm sound enough to know when to use them and when not to, and they've saved me a lot of avoidable pain. I wouldn't go so far as to say they've saved my life, but they've come damn close. I also use my fair share of recreational drugs, as I've mentioned in previous comments. I know I'm good for them, I practice harm reduction strategies and rave safe. However, I am aware that not everybody is me. There are people who have amphetamine habits, or benzo habits, or {{drug_of_choice}} habits. It's by luck,good planning, and good friends that I don't have a habit and manage to use drugs without causing excessive harm. That's something that a lot of readers here seem to forget. The average HN reader is very intelligent and usually very capable of looking after themselves (although I am aware there is a fair share of HN readers who've had struggles with addiction). Not everyone is as switched on as the average HN reader though.
- sangnoir 8y ago> That kind of rubs me the wrong way, but I'm not sure why. I like having the option of overriding the doctor if I disagree. If you're American - my guess is it is cultural: you don't want someone else making decisions for you, rather, they should be making suggestions and you have the final say. American culture extolls autonomy/individualism. I think this is explains some of the differences between the US and other developed countries when it comes to drug abuse and over-prescription. In the US, the doctors tend to defer to the patient on what's good for them more than elsewhere, especially around pain management.