4 ms·
Since the offer is actually open to "anyone", I will suggest the title of the piece is more intended to say something like "Yes, even you women! The word anyone
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
Since the offer is actually open to "anyone", I will suggest the title of the piece is more intended to say something like "Yes, even you women! The word anyone is not code for any white male with SV connections. Honest!"
A lot of underrepresented people know that generic invitations don't really mean they are also invited. It's really only open to the existing in-crowd. As a woman who gets a lot of reactions that suggest to me that women are not supposed to so much as initiate conversations with men, I can kind of understand the logic here.
Having been burned by an extremely toxic classist group where, no, the rules absolutely are not the same for "the wrong kind of people" -- by which we mean poor people (in this case, though they also do really shitty things to anyone who can't somehow establish in-group standing) -- I can understand why a lot of members of underprivileged groups err on the side of "They don't really mean me when they say anyone/everyone."
My mind doesn't work that way. I generally take folks at their word, even when I know they may not really mean it -- and recently got banned from a forum for doing so because they were full of shit and didn't mean any of the high minded BS that came out of their lying mouths. I'm willing to live with that.
But I'm also very well aware that if you get that result often enough, shunning can mean you de facto have no income at all, there is no place for you to go, etc. It can be essentially a death sentence, and I don't mean metaphorically. I mean literally.
I don't know what the fix is. I'm not really all that crazy about the framing of this promo. But my suspicion is that is the real impetus here -- to make sure women don't feel that the subtext is "Not really you, though we say anyone."
And, honestly, I don't have a better answer, so I'm not going to dog them for it.
- pc86 8y agoThis is a confusing, nonsensical rant, which is unfortunate because I feel like you're trying to make a good point but for the life of me I can't figure out what the hell it is.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoSocial stuff is complicated and one of the things that keeps oppressed groups oppressed is the fact that the rules are de facto different for them. So if you really want change, you need to somehow account for the fact that generic invitations won't be seen as "We really are actually inviting you, too" by some members of some groups. Is that any clearer for you? Because I don't think it's a rant at all.
- repolfx 8y agoIt isn't clear. Women are not 'oppressed', especially not in the tech industry. Far from it indeed. The only way I've seen the rules be different for women is that there are lots of events, funds, trainings and jobs specifically reserved just for women. Given this long history, I would assume from the headline on this page that men are either not allowed to apply or are strongly discouraged from doing so (like a group of men turning up at a "women in tech" event would be)- and if that isn't the case then Stripe are surely giving a very misleading impression.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoYeah, that's why I appear to be the only woman to have ever spent time on the leaderboard of HN (under a different handle): Because women are so fully integrated into the tech world. /s One name out of more than over 100 over the years. That's dramatically worse than the figure I have repeatedly seen of 17 female CEOs out of every 100. Edit: Don't get me wrong, I love HN. But the idea that there is no sexism in tech is laughable.
- repolfx 8y agoGiven how many people post under pseudonyms how do you know you're the only woman who spent time there? That's a huge presumption isn't it? Anyway, let's imagine it's true. Nothing keeps women away from Hacker News. They aren't discouraged or told HN is a "site for men". Despite that, they exclude themselves: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16159808 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16159808 "Leap: an online community for women" If you really think society has a problem with sexism amongst men you are clearly seeing what you want to see. Men build things that are for everyone. Women build things that are explicitly labelled as being "for women".
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThat's a huge presumption isn't it? Nope. I usually qualify the statement, as I did above. In this case, I wrote that I appear to be the only woman to have ever spent time on the leaderboard of HN. At other times, I use the framing openly female member. It's based on data collection and on the fact that claiming to be, for example, the highest ranked openly female member for the past 2 or 2.5 years has not resulted in substantive evidence to the contrary coming to light. So far, no one has come forward to state "I (or X person) post as openly female and I have more karma than you/ I'm on the leaderboard" or similar substantive rebuttal. I just get comments like yours asserting that I can't know that for certain, never mind that I typically carefully qualify the statement. Given how often individuals like you try to shoot me down and the fact that this is a huge group of pedants, I strongly suspect the lack of real evidence to the contrary confirms it. So I'm pretty confident that my qualified statements on this are accurate. There are people on the leaderboard who give out little or no personal info. I allow for the possibility that one of those individuals could be female. Even so, they don't post as openly female. I do. If there are women on the leaderboard hiding their gender, to my mind, that only lends more weight to the assertion that sexism is an issue. Men here do not feel compelled to hide their gender and never get told they "should," a thing I have been told more than once. For the record, I am not a member of Leap currently. I think it unlikely that I will become a member.
- 18pfsmt 8y ago>A lot of underrepresented people know that generic invitations don't really mean they are also invited. This is kind of interesting and in stark contrast to much of the hacker mentality that doesn't really care "what they really mean" when "they" make rules. In fact, the hacker mentality is usually to twist interpretations and tease out any technical loophole. It goes along with "ask for forgiveness, not permission." Certainly, something to think about.
- panic 8y agoThank you for sharing your perspective. It's sad (but somewhat unsurprising at this point) that in a discussion about gender, the only post recognizably written by a woman is at the bottom of the page.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- miramardesign 8y agoonce again we must coddle women even though they are overrepresented in college and have every opportunity to study computer science or go into tech.
- lucozade 8y agoThose could be the reasons but it's probably more likely that it's just a tie-in to the events Stripe just had for female founders. I guess it would be a bit less confusing if they'd just made the offer to folks that attended the events but it seems quite nice that they didn't.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI didn't know they had an event. That makes your comment one of the more substantive comments here. But what is your explanation for them having an event specifically for female founders if not the logic I outlined above that some groups need to be clearly signaled that they are equally welcome too?
- lucozade 8y agoI can’t say for sure but it’s possibly related to [0] and [1]. It appears that Aylin has a passion for fostering leadership in women. Can’t think of any reason not to take this at face value. [0] https://stripe.com/blog/international-womens-day https://stripe.com/blog/international-womens-day [1] https://www.missceo.org/aylin/ https://www.missceo.org/aylin/
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThank you. From your links: [1] she saw firsthand the importance of fostering leadership skills and self-confidence for young women at an early age. [0] We built Stripe Atlas to help entrepreneurs from all over the globe start and run an internet business, no matter which industry they're in, where they're based, or their gender or ethnicity. However, women are still not starting companies or raising money at nearly the same rate as men—women made up only 7% of founders whose companies received more than $20M in VC funding between 2009 and 2015. Which fits with my description of recognizing a need to actively reach out to women because (reasons). That in no way questions her genuine passion, etc.
- drharby 8y agoThis struck me too close to my bones