6 ms·
Engineers Say They've Created a Way to Detect Bombs and Guns Using Basic Wifi
- _Microft 8y agoPaper (PDF): http://www.winlab.rutgers.edu/~yychen/papers/Towards%20In%20baggage%20Suspicious%20Object%20Detection%20Using%20Commodity%20WiFi.pdf http://www.winlab.rutgers.edu/~yychen/papers/Towards%20In%20...
- akshayB 8y agoThis technology can prove useful for public safety since there are WiFi almost everywhere these days and all entry points in malls or schools can be covered very easily. There is a chance this can be misused as well.
- vorpalhex 8y agoMy mom worked at a bank that installed what they called a "man trap". Essentially there's a large magnetometer between two sets of heavy doors that locks the doors if it detects someone with a firearm (or any large block of magnetic material) has tried to enter the bank. On any given week, they'd catch about a half dozen police officers, a maintenance person or two who still had their tools on them, and the occasional delivery person. After a few weeks they disabled the system entirely.
- neuralRiot 8y agoAn interesting article about false positives and negatives and their impact in the reliability of a detection system. (I believe it has been linked in HN before) It explains why "95% accurate" is BS. https://blog.danslimmon.com/2012/11/02/car-alarms-and-smoke-alarms-the-tradeoff-between-sensitivity-and-specificity/ https://blog.danslimmon.com/2012/11/02/car-alarms-and-smoke-...
- cesarb 8y agoI thought every bank branch had that (or a revolving door, also with a magnetometer). I don't recall ever seeing a bank branch without one. And it's not just large blocks of magnetic material, even small things like key chains can set them off.
- fcarraldo 8y agoAnother take on this paper would read, “Engineeers have created a way to weaponize Wi-Fi signals for invisible and invasive surveillance”. This turns consumer level tech into a militant authoritarian’s dream. Have they also developed ways to identify when this technology is being used surreptitiously?
- Isomatik 8y agoThis method appears to just measure the Tx and Rx paths on an off-the-shelf modem, so you'd have to physically check the router, or I'm sure this could be handled in firmware. They're measuring phase and amplitude differences from unmodified traffic on 2.4GHz so you can't detect it as an outsider.
- pluma 8y agoMy first reading of that headline was that "bombs" means unexploded ordnance (which is a regular problem for construction projects in my home town thanks to WW2 air raids). I'm not sure if this means I'm sheltered or level-headed.
- abeppu 8y agoIt seems like they can detect liquid and metal, which is very different from detecting bombs and guns. That's like building a face detection library and saying you can find terrorists. If mostly you just identify people with water bottles or laptops, what problem would this really solve?
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoPattern recognition of common bomb and gun configurations? Or better, any non-standard configuration.
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>Or better, any non-standard configuration. Sure, if your definition of better is generating a ton of false positives as a pretext for patting people down.
- jandrese 8y agoThat might be able to detect something like a hand grenade (but honestly I'm dubious), but finding "non-standard configurations" seems like it requires a full up strong AI. It has to be able to look at a jumble of components in a configuration it has never seen before and recognize that it is a bomb. This is hard problem for humans and hits on several hard aspects of AI at once.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoOr just recognize it as not-a-bomb. Easier - e.g. the set of metal things normally in luggage may be small
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- blackaspen 8y agoThis headline immediately make me think of Arthur C. Clarke's "The Trigger".
- bookofjoe 8y ago"The Trigger" (2000): https://archive.org/details/trigger00clar https://archive.org/details/trigger00clar
- bjt2n3904 8y agoMy cynical post script to the title, without reading the article: "in a laboratory setting".
- stewartjarod 8y agoThat's probably true for now. Less noise in their detection than in a real life, public space, situation.
- rm_-rf_slash 8y agoAgreed. When this method is applied in, say, Germany, to safely detect WWII ordinance, then it will have proven itself.
- stewartjarod 8y agoIf they can detect these things, they can detect anything on your person. Pretty crazy.
- Animats 8y agoThe paper [1] is interesting, although they spend too much space writing about the purported benefits. The concept here is to exploit WiFi gear's usages of many different frequencies. Measuring the amplitude and phase shift on each channel provides some info about what each channel bounced off of and diffracted around. Inevitably, they then dump all the data into a neural net. They trained on about 15 objects, which is a reasonable start. They didn't go on to testing with enough objects to be useful. "The results show that our system can detect over 95% dangerous objects in different types of bags and successfully identify 90% dangerous material types." By "dangerous" they just mean metal or liquid. It's not like they can tell a gun from a soup can. [1] http://www.winlab.rutgers.edu/~yychen/papers/Towards%20In%20baggage%20Suspicious%20Object%20Detection%20Using%20Commodity%20WiFi.pdf http://www.winlab.rutgers.edu/~yychen/papers/Towards%20In%20...
- fake-name 8y ago> The concept here is to exploit WiFi gear's usages of many different frequencies. Measuring the amplitude and phase shift on each channel provides some info about what each channel bounced off of and diffracted around. This exists. They're just reimplemented non-cooperative SFCW radar. It's not new.
- kqr2 8y agoReminds me of Wi-Vi: See Through Walls with Wi-Fi Signals from 2013: http://people.csail.mit.edu/fadel/wivi/ http://people.csail.mit.edu/fadel/wivi/
- fake-name 8y ago"Researchers rediscover non-cooperative radar, news at 11" It's really, really, really hard to do this with cooperative RF sources and way way more bandwidth. This is horseshit.
- cuckcuckspruce 8y agoEven better "Researchers suddenly remember WiFi are microwave".
- nixpulvis 8y agoCan't wait to see the day police show up at peoples houses because an opaque AI/ML/Statistical-thingy said they were creating bombs, when in fact it was a loaf of bread (or whatever). Minority report gets more and more real.
- astrodust 8y ago99% accuracy sounds impressive until you realize this thing will flag 1% of all objects as potentially threatening.
- godelski 8y agoSo we see forcing the use of clear backpacks as an invasion of privacy but don't see tech that scans a backpack as invasive?
- adamredwoods 8y agoI'm curious if I can do this at home, and if so if there are any plans online besides the paper. I'd love to play around with it.