8 ms·
Funny how not much changes in 200yr. Basically every part of MA that isn't a part of the Boston area still resents that the state is run economically and socia
by dsfyu404ed 8y ago
Funny how not much changes in 200yr. Basically every part of MA that isn't a part of the Boston area still resents that the state is run economically and socially (order of importance varies by who you talk to) according to what Boston wants/needs/wishes. I'm sure if you went and asked people in Springfield, Hoyoke, North Adams, Fitchburg, New Bedford, (not to mention all the rural communities) what they thought about the quality decision making on Beacon hill you'd get about the same responses you would have gotten in 1787.
Edit: By Boston area I do NOT mean [1] which includes a lot of the Fall River/New Bedford area, the Lowell area and places more under the effect of Worcester. I mean the area in MA where Boston is the major city that has the most effect on day to day life (not to be confused with "daily effect on life") of most people. The area covered by Boston Craigslist is a pretty good proxy for this.
[1] https://statisticalatlas.com/metro-area/Massachusetts/Boston/Overview https://statisticalatlas.com/metro-area/Massachusetts/Boston...
- ghaff 8y agoMassachusetts is at least somewhat atypical in that the state capitol and economic center are the same city. In a lot of states, the state capitol is in some smaller city precisely so that all the power in the state doesn't flow from a single place.
- TulliusCicero 8y agoSometimes I wonder about that. The US as a whole has the same setup (DC isn't the biggest metro area), and the way the legislative houses and executive branch are usually not controlled by a single party at once. Having that separation of power certainly sounds nice, but if you compare it to other countries where the capital IS the biggest city, and where there's always one party/coalition in control of the entire legislative and executive branches...well, they seem to actually function better, on average? Like, I'm not seeing the practical benefits here. Does anyone look at how Congress and the Presidency behave in the year 2018 and think, "ah yes, this clearly has the results we want"? It seems to me like the problem of splitting up power too much is that you get fragmentation, and situations where each party just blames the other and it's hard to tell who actually deserves responsibility for anything.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoMaking it harder to do things makes it hard to do dumb or bad things as well as good things. Not everything government does is good. Americans generally prefer be protected from bad government at the expense of making good government less effective rather than enable good government to do things quickly and risk that it does things they consider bad. I'm not sure how can you look at the US government and 2018 and say we need to enable these people to get more things done. I think the current administration is a relatively harmless (compared to alternatives) lesson in the importance of checks and balances and not concentrating too much power in one branch of government.
- ameister14 8y agoThey function more efficiently, sure - but longevity remains to be seen. Our system is by design not the most efficient one.
- mcphage 8y ago> but if you compare it to other countries where the capital IS the biggest city, and where there's always one party/coalition in control of the entire legislative and executive branches...well, they seem to actually function better, on average? > Does anyone look at how Congress and the Presidency behave in the year 2018 and think, "ah yes, this clearly has the results we want"? Here in 2018, we have the executive branch, and both houses of congress controlled by the same party. And as you point out, it's not going well.
- TulliusCicero 8y agoHa, touche. Although in this case, the legislative and executive branches are still separated more than they are in typical parliamentary systems of government, with differing incentives.
- barrow-rider 8y agoDC may not be the biggest metro area, but it's arguably the richest overall in terms of per household or per capita incomes. 5 of the top 10 richest counties in the US are DC 'burbs: 1 Loudoun Co, VA 2 Fairfax Co, VA 3 Howard Co, MD ... 5 Arlington Co, VA 6 Stafford, Co, VA With Montgomery Co, MD and Prince William County at 11 and 12 respectively. https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/richest-counties-in-the-united-states.html https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/richest-counties-in-the-...
- cbm-vic-20 8y agoAt the time, Salem had similar economic power to Boston. New Bedford and Portland (then part of Mass) as well. But the British established their seat of governance in Boston, and here we are today.
- emodendroket 8y agoI haven't really looked into this but I had always assumed this was more of an artifact of historical circumstances than an intentional decision.
- wutbrodo 8y agoIt's so natural for an economic center to become a political center (and vice versa), and so common in the US to see the opposite, that I always assumed it was intentional. I could be wrong though: Can you elaborate on what kind of historical circumstances might account for this happening across so many states?
- emodendroket 8y agoThe economic center of the state 200 years ago and the economic center of the state today being different cities (for instance, the capital of Florida presumably isn't Miami because the area was a practically uninhabitable backwater in the 19th Century)
- SamReidHughes 8y agoOne is that the states are often bordered by major rivers or oceans, the economic centers are there, and they want the capital to be somewhere closer to the middle of the state, geographically. Another reason is that it's more secure, militarily.
- nostrademons 8y agoState capitals are usually established when the state is established (they can occasionally be moved afterwards, but in most cases aren't after the first decade or so of statehood). At that time, there is no economic center to most states, because economic development has not yet begun. Sacramento, for example, has been the capital of CA since 1854. At the time, the population of Sacramento was 10,000, San Francisco was 34,000, Los Angeles didn't exist yet, and most economic activity centered around gold mining, which usually happened near the Sacramento hinterlands. Similarly Nevada's capital has been Carson City since 1864. In 1864 the primary industry in Nevada was silver mining of the Comstock Lode, which is right next to Carson City. Las Vegas didn't exist until 1905. Some state capitals also have rather colorful histories, as well. The capital of Louisiana was moved from New Orleans (the economic center) to Baton Rouge because "New Orleans was too sinful". The capital of Idaho moved from Lewistown (the previous economic center, driven by a gold rush) to Boise (the new economic center, driven by mineral mining) in violation of a court order, and featured the governor fleeing the state for Portland and the state treasury being stolen from his steamboat cabin. There's a catch-22 for settlement patterns where large-scale settlement and economic development of many states didn't happen until after they gained statehood, at which point the capital is already decided.
- dwighttk 8y agoMetro Boston has 4.6M and Massachusetts has 6.9M. Wikipedia even has a "combined statistical area" of Boston at 8M. How many people (non-Bostonian Massachusites) are we talking about here?
- ghaff 8y agoThe Boston Metro area covers a fairly big area (and the combined statistical area even more, including cities in adjacent states). Within the city limits proper, the population is under 1 million--although that's partly because Cambridge and Somerville aren't part of Boston.
- maxerickson 8y agoThe statistical metro is probably the closer match to the Boston that controls the state than the proper city.
- ghaff 8y agoThat's true but the parent was asking how many people don't live in Boston but are effectively controlled by the politics there anyway. And the statistical metro is in some sense a measure of the area/population that can be thought of as associated with Boston. (i.e. more or less by definition, the people whose politics/economics are influenced by it)
- emodendroket 8y agoBut that's kind of the rub -- people in Hingham might carp that they don't want to pay for the T in Boston, and yet their own prosperity comes, in part, from having a nearby city with well-funded public services
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago
- eadmund 8y agoI really strongly believe that each state legislature should have a structure similar to the federal legislature in order to address this: state representatives should be apportioned by population and state senators should be apportioned by counties. This way the geographic regions of states would have a say, and you wouldn't have places like Boston, New York City or Denver running roughshod over the rest of their respective states.
- ghaff 8y agoWhile I tend to agree in principle, there's nothing special about how county lines are drawn. In Massachusetts (like many states), counties are pretty much irrelevant except for some fairly specific purposes. (For example, state courts and related legal institutions are organized by country.)
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoI like this idea. It seems like it would work well considering that the population in the US in 1800 was on the same order as the population of many states.
- TulliusCicero 8y ago> This way the geographic regions of states would have a say What's the ideological basis for giving "geographic minorities" extra voting power? Should we give extra voting power for other minorities too, based on race, religion, sexual orientation, etc.? Should we give Muslims and Jews their own legislative house so the Christian majority doesn't run roughshod over them? Maybe a separate house for racial minorities, or for gay people so that the straight majority doesn't dominate them?
- bcgraham 8y agoMany (most?) of the risks governments are trying to mitigate are fundamentally geographic - interpersonal violence, spread of fire, spread of disease, etc.
- TulliusCicero 8y ago
- drdeadringer 8y agoIt's also the reverse. When working in Cambridge I mentioned that I grew up in the Pioneer Valley, a five-college area in Western MA which includes two of the "Seven Sisters" among yielding some famous poets. "Oh, in the 413 huh?" the coworker snarked, referring to the area code of a large western portion of the state that wasn't Boston (which was 617 at the time). As if everyone west of Worcester was a rube.
- emodendroket 8y agoI live in the South Shore and they do that to me too.
- jessaustin 8y agoThey do that to the Central and Mountain timezones. Why would you be any different? I should say, I treasure the time I've spent in the Boston area.
- emodendroket 8y agoBecause I live like fifteen minutes away? I literally take the train from the South Shore to Boston every morning and yet people act like I told them I just flew in from Idaho.
- drdeadringer 8y agoExactly. It's like if I took VTA Light Rail from Campbell [where I currently live] to San Jose, which is comparable to your commute in terms of time, only to have people look down their nose at me. Fortunately, instead, I often receive "Oh Campbell yeah, I like that town" or similar.
- emodendroket 8y agoThe big thing is that the South Shore is more blue-collar and suburban (and I suppose in general more politically conservative) than the North Shore or Metro West area so they think of it as full of hicks.
- emodendroket 8y agoI mean, Boston is the economic engine of eastern Massachusetts and few in the greater Boston area are operating independent homestead farms anymore.