6 ms·
With the exception of Denmark, the areas that are in the "green" either have hydro og nuclear. I understand the issues with nuclear waste, but it seems that's
by mrweasel 8y ago
With the exception of Denmark, the areas that are in the "green" either have hydro og nuclear.
I understand the issues with nuclear waste, but it seems that's the current trade-off, if you want lower CO2 emissions and don't have access to large rivers.
- realusername 8y agoEven the colour scale does not really show how big the difference is between countries regarding clean energy. Germany is producing 8x more CO2/Kwh than France, Poland 16 times more and Estonia 24 times more.
- Tade0 8y agoFrance is pretty special in this regard. If my numbers aren't off it makes more environmental sense to carpool in an EV in France than to cycle to work - even assuming everyone is vegan.
- ancarda 8y agoHow is that possible? Wouldn’t there be more CO2 involved in producing the car compared to a few bikes? Edit: Slight amend to point out there’s several bikes to each car (as it’s a carpool)
- mrweasel 8y agoI'm not sure that point revolves around the manufacturing of the car and bikes, even though that should be included. There was a study, that sadly eludes me, that suggested that if you need to travel more than 2km to do you grocery shopping, then it would produce less CO2 to get in your car and drive, compared to walking. The reasoning is that you need to consume some amount of food to generate the energy required to walk to the store and back. The amount of CO2 used to generate that food, and the additional CO2 you exhale, would be larger than what a modern car would produce, traveling the same distance. I believe that the same argument that would make multiple people in an EV carpool more environmentally friendly than bikes. But that's also the case with regular cars.
- Tade0 8y ago> Wouldn’t there be more CO2 involved in producing the car compared to a few bikes? Crazily enough there's generally less CO2 involved in producing the car than having each of a few people ride bicycles a distance equal to a typical car's life-cycle mileage. Here's my math: For lack of a better source I'm using Renault's own environmental assessment for the Fluence Z.E[0], which puts its production-related emissions at ~8 metric tonnes of CO2. Over 150k km (which is not a lot for a car, but we want a number achievable by a cyclist over their lifetime) that results in ~53.3g/km of CO2. As for driving let's assume that a fully loaded EV requires 200Wh/km to move around - In France that amounts to 10.6g/km[1]. So overall we have a well-to-wheels footprint of 63.9g/km. Now here's the fun part: A typical Vegan will be responsible for 1.5 metric tonnes of CO2 annualy @ 2600kcal daily, so 1kcal = ~1.57g of CO2 - This is the most environmentally friendly diet. Cycling can vary greatly in intensity[3], but let's say 250kcal/h at 10km/h is a reasonable estimate. Given these figures a single vegan on a bicycle going 10km/h is responsible for 39.25g/km of CO2. According to some sources[4] my numbers aren't that far off. CONCLUSION (caps for visibility): Two vegans on bicycles having a 17km commute are responsible for 78.5g/km, while the same two vegans in an EV in France produce only 63.9g/km. Bump that to four vegans and we're getting awkwardly close to a typical combustion engine car's emissions. Meanwhile environmentally conscious(heh) meat-eaters should probably stay off bicycles, eat less and carpool in a compact car. [0] Page 91 of: https://group.renault.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/fluence-acv-2011.pdf https://group.renault.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/fluence... [1] http://environmentalprogress.org/big-news/2017/2/11/german-electricity-was-nearly-10-times-dirtier-than-frances-in-2016 http://environmentalprogress.org/big-news/2017/2/11/german-e... [2] http://www.greeneatz.com/foods-carbon-footprint.html http://www.greeneatz.com/foods-carbon-footprint.html [3] https://keisan.casio.com/exec/system/1350958587 https://keisan.casio.com/exec/system/1350958587 [4] https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2010/jun/08/carbon-footprint-cycling https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2010/jun/08/carbon-f... EDIT: formatting.
- morsch 8y agoThis is orthogonal to your point, but: people usually limit their commute by bike to, say, less than 5 to 10 km one way. On the other hand, people think nothing of commuting 50 to 100 km one way by car.
- skrause 8y agoThe problem with nuclear power is that it's too expensive unless you choose to simply ignore the long-term cost of the nuclear waste problem. At this point it makes more sense to invest in solar, wind power and energy storage capacity to reduce CO2 emissions.
- realusername 8y agoSolar & wind + batteries isn't enough, you also need a stable source of energy to compensate when the production is going down (those are not stable sources), if you are a country without good hydro possibilities, your only option for that is nuclear.
- Tade0 8y agoThere's natural gas for that. Sure, it's pretty CO2-intensive, but with enough overprovisioning of renewables and some storage it will rarely be used - if at all. Cheaper than having an inflexible nuclear plant.
- jabl 8y agoIf we're going to have any chance of hitting the 2C climate targets, electricity production must be more or less completely emissions-free by mid-century (preferably ASAP). So, any non-trivial amount of natural gas usage is out. Also, there's the rough rule of thumb saying that when variable sources (like wind or solar) approach a fraction of total generation in the grid equal to the capacity factor of said source, system integration costs start to rise rapidly (because that's, at the latest, the point where you'll start needing large amounts of storage, curtailment, or long-range transmission). Thus, in most grids wind+solar will unlikely see much larger than 50% of total generation without massive extra investment and/or breakthroughs in storage costs. If we're going for lowest-cost deep decarbonization, it looks like the share of nuclear will start to rise when we go deep enough, see e.g. slide 41 in https://kleinmanenergy.upenn.edu/sites/default/files/Getting_to_Zero.pdf https://kleinmanenergy.upenn.edu/sites/default/files/Getting...
- nickik 8y ago