6 ms·
The big figure that stood out for me in this article was that the number of independent bookstores in the United States has increased 30% in the last ten years.
by reaperducer 8y ago
The big figure that stood out for me in this article was that the number of independent bookstores in the United States has increased 30% in the last ten years. And there's enough people who love brick-and-mortar shops and physical books to warrant Indigo to expand into the U.S.
I think the article was spot-on about following the Waterstone model of making it a chain of hyper-localized stores, instead of a homogenous behemoth trying to be everything to the masses. Book readers are thinkers, and are turned off by mass marketing.
It's like how local coffee shops continue to survive and thrive, in spite of the ubiquitous presence of Starbucks. People like local, special things. What people on 35th Street in Chicago want to read is not the same as what people in Haight/Ashbury in San Francisco want to read.
If one wants to explore something from the other, there's always in-store ordering, and online. Plus the more-popular-than-ever-in-spite-of-the-zeitgeist libraries.
- imglorp 8y agoBorders helped lead the way with this model, but there wasn't room for two mega-chains.
- ethbro 8y agoIt's bizarre that bookstore consolidation, homogenization, and expansion happened just as text was converting to digital and becoming available via network. B&N (1986) & Borders (1992)
- gringoDan 8y agoAbsolutely. There's no way that Barnes & Noble (or any retailer) can compete with Amazon on selection or price. Where they can compete is on discovery. Amazon is really great on converting high-intent customers, but terrible at discovery. (This is why it is beginning to open physical bookstores.) When was the last time you went to Amazon to "browse" for books? The physical retailers that can compete in this space will have a niche and a carefully curated selection of books to capture the type of people who want to relax and find a good book to read, rather than the people who already know what they want.
- DarkTree 8y agoI actually find Amazon to be pretty amazing at discovery, but it's dependent on the "Customers who bought this item also bought" section under a book I know I like or am interested in. I don't go to Amazon books just to start browsing aimlessly, but if I am yearning for a book in the same vein as another book I liked, I'll just search that book and look through the books suggested below. It does keep my discovery narrow, but that consequently keeps my reading wish list small and wieldy.
- adw 8y agoWaterstones is fairly high up the list of things I miss from the UK high street (along with Pret a Manger).
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoI haven't bought anything in Waterstones for years, I think the WHSmith era ruined it for me (and the fact Blackwell's is close).
- Someone1234 8y ago> Book readers are thinkers, and are turned off by mass marketing. You cannot infer any of that from the simple act of consuming books. Books range from essentially written porn all the way up to dissertations on philosophy. Plus book readers aren't some elite niche, the majority of the adult population (72%) reads books[0]. [0] https://www.irisreading.com/how-many-books-does-the-average-person-read/ https://www.irisreading.com/how-many-books-does-the-average-...
- msla 8y ago> You cannot infer any of that from the simple act of consuming books. Books range from essentially written porn all the way up to dissertations on philosophy. It's just someone regurgitating Received Wisdom from the TV Age, when everyone was absolutely convinced that the world was on its way out as everyone got TV and destroyed their minds watching nonsense. Why, I betcha they'll be up to 1500 channels by 2015, I betcha, and absolutely nobody reading anything at all. Think "Brian O'Blivion" from Videodrome, except people being obtuse enough to take it seriously. Anyway, ideas have a way of sticking around, zombie-like, well after their original context is gone, being parroted by people who have no idea where they originally came from, or why. It's impossible to seriously evaluate everything in your head, but stepping outside the system every once in a while and asking why you think what you think is a good thing.
- skookumchuck 8y ago> the world was on its way out as everyone got TV and destroyed their minds watching nonsense. And it has come to pass!
- Apocryphon 8y agoTV has become a prestige form of entertainment. We are currently in a new golden age of television. Rather, it's 30-second meme videos or hour-long YouTube fringe conspiracy theory dissertations that are more problematic. Or social media, which has largely supplanted the trashy reality TV boom of the '00s. One wonders what future form of entertainment will uplift social media and online videos, at least in comparison.
- JKCalhoun 8y agoFirst the chains ate the small booksellers. Then the chains ate each other. Why should I be sad? Yes, their passing will see the further increase of independent booksellers.
- ksdale 8y agoSpeaking of coffee shops, I can't for the life of me remember where I heard/read this story, but there was a guy who owned a coffee shop who said that they got a big boost in business when Starbucks opened across the street from them. His claim was that Starbucks was approachable enough to turn more people in the town into regular coffee drinkers, and once they became regular coffee drinkers, they would often seek out something they liked better than Starbucks and end up in his shop.
- Pxl_Buzzard 8y agoMy uncle in Kansas City runs a coffee shop that ran Starbucks of out business[1]. Starbucks brought coffee shops to the masses, but once people get hooked they generally like to support local craft shops that often taste better and feel more personal. 1. https://www.nytimes.com/2008/01/30/business/30sbux.html https://www.nytimes.com/2008/01/30/business/30sbux.html
- specialist 8y agoI worked at Starbucks in Store Planning in the early nineties. The Real Estate group at the time was superior. Picking locations, revenue projections, competitive analysis. This was received wisdom inside the org. Having Starbucks show up in your town educated (or created) the market. The nonsense about Starbuck driving local coffee shops out of business was never reality based. Competing chains? Sure. But not the mom & pops. And since then, there's been a proliferation of local chains. That said... Starbucks (for coffee) != Amazon (for books). Starbucks is more like Anheuser-Busch: mass market, consistency, broad appeal. By their nature, both leave plenty of room for microbrews and local roasters. Amazon is more like Walmart, a destroyer of markets. Your margin is their opportunity.
- fencepost 8y agoThere's also a "cluster of restaurants" aspect to this kind of thing. If you have multiple restaurants or coffee shops within the same area when people are interested in going out for food or coffee they'll go to that area. If there are multiple choices available when they arrive it may be up in the air which one they go to.
- kosei 8y agoIt's possible that the Waterstone model is something to consider moving forward, but it's unreasonable to act as if the flaw in B&N's business model was a "thinker" book reader market that is "turned off by mass marketing". Toys R Us, Radioshack, Payless, Circuit City, Sports Authority. There are dozens of retail businesses that have gotten the ax in recent years and they're all in very different industries. The internet just flipped a bunch of retailers' business models upside down, and they're all dealing with the consequences. The retail apocalypse is real. Links: https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2017-retail-debt/ https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2017-retail-debt/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2017/04/retail-meltdown-of-2017/522384/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2017/04/retail-... https://www.businessinsider.com/the-retail-apocalypse-has-officially-descended-on-america-2017-3 https://www.businessinsider.com/the-retail-apocalypse-has-of...
- fencepost 8y agoI'm not sure about the others but I'm pretty positive that Toys R Us was killed by a standard vulture capitalist business model. Arrange a bunch of financing, purchase a company, saddle that company with the payments for the debt that you used to acquire it, charge that company large management fees and take out any profits that you can. Eventually when the massive debt load and payments are too much for the now under capitalized business see if you can sell the remains to someone else who thinks they might be able to get a little more meat off those bones.
- dajohnson89 8y agobut weren't the unfavorable terms of the purchase a result of poor sales?