4 ms·
>Considering Germany is an economic powerhouse this law probably isn't harming the economy. Germany is economically successful. But here is few things for you
by baybal2 8y ago
>Considering Germany is an economic powerhouse this law probably isn't harming the economy.
Germany is economically successful. But here is few things for you to know about it: 1. the industry taxed near to the limit. 2. Welfare is not cheap by any means. 3. Germany is an ageing country, and the amount of welfare payouts will go even further.
I not fan of idea that a company can be public, nor the form of relationships in between its owners and management that evolved in the USA: 1. I find the idea that a man owning a single share of the company can sue the management to death for doing virtually anything. 2. The subsequent dominance of extreme CYA attitudes that American managers are famous for. 3. The fact that company ownership became an extremely bureaucratised thing.
I'm a big believer that a business must have an owner. My own experience working in public companies: an omnipresent atmosphere of "ownerlessness" and people not minding "leaving things broken" for reasons that they are not paid to fix them. Without a clear "boss" around, work tend descend into being a Brownian motion. And all of that gets progressively worse closer to C-suite offices, if the company is of type that changed few generations of management.
Words of my father: "a collective ownership of business is like life in family where a woman has 10 husbands, all trying to make love to her at the same time."
- prolikewh0a 8y ago>1. the industry taxed near to the limit. 2. Welfare is not cheap by any means. 3. Germany is an ageing country, and the amount of welfare payouts will go even further. Want to explain to me how this is even a bad thing? It sounds like the Germans have solidarity for their fellow people/workers and realize everyone should be provided the basics for a peace of mind and overall better workers that can rest and enjoy life outside of work. American capitalism doesn't have to happen everywhere. It's a system that provides for the few instead of the many, unlike Germany that provides for the many instead of the few
- baybal2 8y ago>Want to explain to me how this is even a bad thing? I believe Germany can do even better if they can find ways to reduce the ratio of people in workforce to welfare recipients. Don't forget, we talk about that in the context of EU. Germany is carrying half of EU on its shoulders. >it sounds like the Germans have solidarity for their fellow people/workers and realize everyone should be provided the basics for a peace of mind Doing just "basics for a peace of mind" is doable with not much less, but nevertheless less money. The few developer countries in Asia can show how to do that well. My main criticism is that Germany's welfare is more expensive that that of other countries because not only direct payouts are moderately high, but welfare paid infrastructure and services are taking quite a lot too: lifts for pedestrian overpasses in the middle of nowhere, free transit ticket for people with minimal and non-mobility hampering disabilities, access to free housing (depending on a state) for people with income that qualifies as high in countries just across the border... and on and on Big issue with all extensive welfare systems in the West is that in them, needs of people in need are not being known by people who are entrusted with administering welfare to them. I can easily pull out many example of welfare states where people in need live miserably. When the welfare does not benefit to the person in need, what's use of it? In that case it just becomes wasted money. With all my militant atheism, I can give high mark to welfare administrators in the gulf region. Zakat distribution by mosques is very straightforward, addressing needs of people in need in the most straightforward way. >and overall better workers that can rest and enjoy life outside of work. I believe a professionals can enjoy life even more if they simply get higher salaries. In that context, I believe that German labour councils serve a good role, making people understand that "they can't milk a dead cow." It is very good when both sides can come to terms knowing how much money they can extract from the business before it kicks the bucket.
- polotics 8y agoYou wrote: "Germany is carrying half of EU on its shoulders." This statement is ludicrous! There is no prosperity transfer of any kind to poorer states in the EU, and a very clear wealth transfer to the center of the EU. May I suggest you read "And the weak suffer what they must" by Yannis Varoufakis?
- hueving 8y ago>It's a system that provides for the few instead of the many, unlike Germany that provides for the many instead of the few That's a silly argument. US citizens make more on average than German citizens. Both systems provide for the many (with the US arguably providing moreso for that middle of the curve). The problem is the unfortunate people on the left side of the curve who get hit with medical bankruptcy, a loss of industry, etc. Those people get screwed in the US where there is a better safety net in Germany.
- giantsloth 8y ago> "a collective ownership of business is like life in family where a woman has 10 husbands, all trying to make love to her at the same time." This is an absurd and invalid metaphor. This is a typical attempt at oversimplifying and reducing complicated networks into a nonsensical scaled down version. You use different management techniques for teams of 2 vs 10 vs 50 vs 100 vs 1000 vs 10,000 vs a state vs a nation vs the world. If there is 2 people on a development team, we can largely get by on vocal communication of goals, ideas, tasks, etc. If I'm working on a team of 100 developers, you can't possibly communicate goals, ideas and tasks effectively person to person, now you need to add bureaucracy, automated systems, layers of management, or split the 100 developers into small teams so they can have the person to person communication with team to team liaisons (or insert X strategy of the week for managing large software projects with many people). You state the following, clearly as problems with 0 explanation: >1. the industry taxed near to the limit. A useless truism >2. Welfare is not cheap by any means. A useless truism >3. Germany is an ageing country, and the amount of welfare payouts will go even further. A useless truism >1. I find the idea that a man owning a single share of the company can sue the management to death for doing virtually anything. Please be more specific of what "virtually anything" means and please show a "virtually anything" lawsuit. >2. The subsequent dominance of extreme CYA attitudes that American managers are famous for. Covering your ass is an unavoidable outgrowth of large systems of people. When doing things at scale, redundancy and fail over is extremely important. >3. The fact that company ownership became an extremely bureaucratised thing. Bureaucracy is a necessary outgrowth of large systems of people. Yes, it sucks that you can't coordinate your team of 1000 on a whim, like you can a team of 2, but this is unavoidable at scale, do to the communication gaps between large networks of people. > I'm a big believer that a business must have an owner. My own experience working in public companies: an omnipresent atmosphere of "ownerlessness" and people not minding "leaving things broken" for reasons that they are not paid to fix them. Without a clear "boss" around, work tend descend into being a Brownian motion. And all of that gets progressively worse closer to C-suite offices, if the company is of type that changed few generations of management. Do to your clear lack of material understanding of large systems of people, I find this anecdote dubious.
- genericid 8y ago> I'm a big believer that a business must have an owner. Surely you are also a big believer that a country must have a king. If not, why not? > Words of my father: "a collective ownership of business is like life in family where a woman has 10 husbands, all trying to make love to her at the same time." Quotations aren't even arguments if they come from famous people.
- baybal2 8y ago>> I'm a big believer that a business must have an owner. >Surely you are also a big believer that a country must have a king. If not, why not? No, I believe that monarchies are weak, and risky. There might be modern day monarchs doing best for their realms, but the chance that after 3-4-5 good successions will come a man "who wrecks it all" is just too high. This is what history has demonstrated. In case of business, the risks are not human lives. In case of a failing business, an employee is free to vote with his feet at any moment, moreover if he is valuable specialist in a competitive market. In such circumstances, business owners are compelled to do well do deter desertions. This is in big contrast to command economies dominated by state businesses. Speaking about command economies, that not necessarily assumes communists countries - just how much of F500 a decade ago were de-facto state co's? GE - with net negative tax rate, GM - needs no explanations, defence companies - being de-facto one with their states in every country, agri businesses with roots in banana republics, dozens of megabanks kept alive by financial life support from taxpayers.
- genericid 8y agoDemocracies elect idiots "who wreck it all" all the time. That is not the problem with monarchies. The problem with monarchies is that a monarch will promote the interests of the monarch, the nobility will promote the interests of the nobility. Only a democracy will promote the interests of everybody. That is true whether we talk about a state or a company. > In case of a failing business, an employee is free to vote with his feet at any moment, moreover if he is valuable specialist in a competitive market. A non-democratic economy works for certain people under certain circumstances. That is simply not enough. Equating democratic elections, the act of freely chosing how you run your society, to what amounts to fleeing a sinking ship is beyond ridiculous. So is calling the US a command economy.